Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by d0m on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:28PM
(#17232062)
I think that's exciting because raising an A is really stressful and time consuming, and often as a startup you need to pivot and do short-term non-optimal things to be able to raise it. If that same "non-bullshit" that YC is using for seed-stage is used for the A, I'm sure it'll improve startups in the long-term.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by akharris on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:29PM
(#17233589)
Our hope is that we can limit as much of the BS as possible while helping companies and investors focus on the parts that matter. Doing that should increase the rate at which YC cos get quality As done.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by lbotos on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:39AM
(#17237451)
I assume GP is talking about dedicating time effort and energy to round up the money vs. spending that time effort and energy building the product.
At $small_startup_where_i_was_employee_3, when we were raising, it was the CEO's full time focus, and cost a fair bit of money to generate the meetings, be in the right cities, etc, etc. He was also responsible for a lot of our marketing efforts (4 person co) so that took a toll, and shuffled onto others shoulders where it wasn't our strength.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by d0m on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:54AM
(#17237566)
Yes, but also even the product/company vision sometimes need to slightly change in the short-term to get those critical metric numbers to line-up with VCs' expectation. I.e. getting a few important contracts to prove product-market fit even if it's very costly for a small startup whereas it would have been wiser to wait a bit, focus on the product and scale the team before tackling these contracts.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by akharris on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:55PM
(#17232361)
Important question. We think signaling is a tricky subject, especially with the number of VCs investing in As. There's a lot to unpack there, which I'll write about in the future.
For YC - we're thinking actively how to prevent any signaling. That's why we invest pro-rata in all of our companies in the same way.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by fredophile on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:27PM
(#17233214)
YC typically invests at the seed stage. If YC makes, or doesn't make, a large follow up investment for some companies in series A it sends a signal to other investors about what YC thinks about the company. Since YC has access to information about the company's financials from already being an investor this kind of thing can influence other investors to make, or avoid making, an investment.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by wasd on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:29PM
(#17234491)
I don't believe this is an issue. YC's stance is to always participate in their pro rata.
"We exercise YC’s pro rata investing rights in all follow-on priced financing rounds, beginning with a company’s first priced round. At post-money valuations equal to or below $300M, we exercise our rights in all companies where we have a formal pro rata right."
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by acjohnson55 on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:51PM
(#17234849)
Is the "signaling" idea mostly about the differential signal that would be sent about companies they didn't invest in, if this automatic policy were not in place? Like, no matter how awesome Company A is, if YC chose to invest a disproportionate amount of money in Company A, then everyone would say, "what's wrong with Company B?"
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by akharris on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:34PM
(#17232127)
Not dumb at all. It's something we thought about a lot. The program is just for YC companies, though we'll continue to release information and learnings for other people.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by alfredallan1 on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:53PM
(#17234859)
Why?
If someone has “seeded” from personal funds/friends/family and gotten to a stage of reasonable traction, why disqualify them from direct entry into Series A, or artificially force them into Seed even when they’re clearly past that stage?
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by alfredallan1 on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:47AM
(#17245925)
No charity expected, being very founder friendly is sufficient. I must have missed this bit - “Series A program is free”.
In any case, what I wanted to say is an independent Series A program (that allows direct entry in addition to Seed Program graduates), parallel (and similar) to the seed program, sounds like a good idea. Maybe that’s what this experiment might morph into eventually.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by angelguy on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:01PM
(#17234389)
Aaron, thanks for answering these questions.
What is the YC Series A program's advice to founders around giving round allocation to prior investors? Is there an official stance on who should be let in?
I've found with popular YC seed rounds that the founders turn to their YC partners to ask who should get in. Extending this to A's is a bit scary from a concentration of power standpoint.
Re:Introducing YC Series A Batches
by wasd on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:57PM
(#17232378)
Sorry for the confusion. Yes, I was asking how much you think companies who graduate form YC should raise (say seed) compared to companies who are graduating from YC Series A.
Could you elaborate?
At $small_startup_where_i_was_employee_3, when we were raising, it was the CEO's full time focus, and cost a fair bit of money to generate the meetings, be in the right cities, etc, etc. He was also responsible for a lot of our marketing efforts (4 person co) so that took a toll, and shuffled onto others shoulders where it wasn't our strength.
Yes I saw such things too.
Company wanted to rise $4M and the investors wanted a "Cloud Product" with >10k customers etc.
Which was ridiculous, because we needed the money for the stuff we already did and it was an on-premis solution for like 10 big corporations.
Thanks.
For YC - we're thinking actively how to prevent any signaling. That's why we invest pro-rata in all of our companies in the same way.
"We exercise YC’s pro rata investing rights in all follow-on priced financing rounds, beginning with a company’s first priced round. At post-money valuations equal to or below $300M, we exercise our rights in all companies where we have a formal pro rata right."
From: https://www.ycombinator.com/continuity/
> For YC - we're thinking actively how to prevent any signaling. That's why we invest pro-rata in all of our companies in the same way.
If someone has “seeded” from personal funds/friends/family and gotten to a stage of reasonable traction, why disqualify them from direct entry into Series A, or artificially force them into Seed even when they’re clearly past that stage?
In any case, what I wanted to say is an independent Series A program (that allows direct entry in addition to Seed Program graduates), parallel (and similar) to the seed program, sounds like a good idea. Maybe that’s what this experiment might morph into eventually.
What is the YC Series A program's advice to founders around giving round allocation to prior investors? Is there an official stance on who should be let in?
I've found with popular YC seed rounds that the founders turn to their YC partners to ask who should get in. Extending this to A's is a bit scary from a concentration of power standpoint.
2. How much do you think YC companies will raise post YC vs YC Series A?
Not sure what you mean by the second question. Are you asking about the size of seed rounds vs. A rounds?
Overall, though, the companies coming out of the A program will raise significantly more than they did at seed.