It's well written, but that's not the impressive part. The impressive thing is that this "expose" was written in 1982, 36 years ago. As Epstein mentions, diamonds are not "forever", or even particularly robust (they can be burned, crushed, chipped, etc), but the industry seems to age quite well. In the half-lifetime since that article came out, nothing has changed.
[1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1982/02/have-yo...
I like the pitch about Moissanite, and I'll have to check it out for other purposes other than an engagement ring!
(1) https://www.statista.com/statistics/585450/market-share-of-d... (2) https://secure.debeersgroup.com/content/de-beers-auction-sal...
Ditto with diamonds. DeBeers associated this relatively common gem with luxury.
From that point, the economics are driven by women. A woman does not want a cheap purse. A fiancée does not want a cheap diamond. The quality is irrelevant. What matters is how much the guy sacrificed for her.
Sort of silly and irrational. But, it's true.
I am for free markets, but I had read, and I will need to confirm if this is still true, that diamonds are plentiful, so the raw stock before cutting and them should be cheaper than current market price due to keeping them in stores to maintain an inflated price. Whether that's De Beers acting alone with its market share as you cited, or two or three other companies colluding on this scheme to keep an inflated market value or not, I need to confirm.
The wedding industry, like the funeral industry, really preys on people's emotions to make the hard sell. "If you really love her you'll give her the best" (implying that giving her something inexpensive means you don't really love her.) "You want to show her (and the world) how committed you are to her."
Then because everyone is so highly pressured to spend big then it becomes a societal expectation in a generation.
(I agree it's weird to me too! Personally, I don't even own an engagement ring or a wedding ring - I see them merely as trinkets and I'm just not a jewelry person)
That's $X,000 that you've tied up in something that doesn't actually have the value you paid for it, and even if you did want to sell it, it likely has sentimental value, making it an illiquid asset.
Like the site points out, most people getting married are not in a position to afford that kind of expense. But they do, and they try to make it work, because that's what's "expected".
One way is to find someone that teaches Jewelry making at a university and who also does commissions. They will often have skilled students who are looking for commissions as well. I heard jewelry and gem shows are also a great way to buy gems at a reasonable price and meet people in the industry, many jewelers that do commission will be happy to use gems you supply.
Additionally private jewelers advertise themselves on the internet, on flyers at art shows and own store fronts.
I swear I've seen "four months salary" somewhere.
Who says poop can't smell worse?
[0] http://diamondssuck.com/
via
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12944464