News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by jacquesm on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:59AM (#17226565)
> I am German and "IG Farben" means nothing to me.

How did you manage to get through German school without picking up a reference or two to IG Farben?

I'm not German and there were multiple accounts of their contribution to the Holocaust. Google 'Zyklon-B' for more info.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by ekianjo on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:33AM (#17227593)
> I'm not German and there were multiple accounts of their contribution to the Holocaust. Google 'Zyklon-B' for more info.

Then by that line you may as well put Dow Chemicals and Monsanto in the same bin as they have been producing Agent Orange to bombard Vietnamese civilians with well known effects during the Vietnam war.

Or instead, you could point the fingers to governments who are basically at the origin of such illegitimate actions. Oh, and in War, pretty much everything becomes legal anyway, until you lose and are judged for it. The US will never be judged for the crimes they have committed, just like the Soviets will never be either, because they have never happened to be directly involved on the losing side.

So moral authority is very relative in this world.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by jacquesm on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:25AM (#17228017)
> Dow Chemicals and Monsanto in the same bin as they have been producing Agent Orange to bombard Vietnamese civilians with well known effects during the Vietnam war.

I do.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by ams6110 on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:27AM (#17228034)
Please, you can't put wartime use of a defoliant in the same category as Zyklon-B and what it was used for.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by ekianjo on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:37AM (#17228858)
OK, so a chemical that causes an horrendous list of conditions, many of them being fatal, and used on purpose on civilians during a conflict, is a bad comparison with Zyklon-B? Where do you draw the line then? How much toxicity is enough to draw the parallel?

https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/agentorange/condit...

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by searine on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:44PM (#17230188)
>used on purpose on civilians during a conflict

It wasn't used on purpose. 2,4-D, the defoliant used, wasn't the carcinogen and wasn't sprayed on people intentionally. The carcinogen in this case was a dioxin contaminate inadvertently created in the manufacturing process. The US military thought they were spraying a chemical they thought was (mostly) safe.

Was the effect of 2,4-D a horrific disaster? Yes. Was it a mistake to use this tactic? Yes. Has the US provided all the necessary restitution? No. Is it equal to IG Farben knowingly producing Zylkon-B for genocide. No even close to the same.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by benjaminsuch on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:04AM (#17226606)
I'm from germany too and never heard of IG Farben. Of course we know about Auschwitz but the term "IG Farben" has never been mentioned.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by cf498 on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:10AM (#17226637)
How long did you go to school and when? German here and ofcourse I heard of IG Farben. They are the prime example when it comes to companies complicit with the Nazi regime.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by zaarn on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:22AM (#17226712)
Went through that era about 7 or 8 years ago and there wasn't any big mention of it. It might have been in the foot notes but the classes usually focused on a broader overview of the war rather than individual happenings (we did watch Schindler's List though). Of course the crimes at the various KZ' and such are also thoroughly covered.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by jessaustin on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:40AM (#17226821)
Why does any of this have to come from school? I would have expected that a general exposure to culture would have covered all of this? Maybe I'm misled by the fact that in USA there are cable channels that seem to be 50% devoted to Nazi misdeeds...
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by zaarn on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:51AM (#17226870)
This is generally covered in school because Nazi history is a rather depressing topic for Germans. Doesn't really stop the documentary channels but those don't have high exposure (Football and News have high exposure. European Football that is.)
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by ams6110 on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:32AM (#17228074)
It sounds to me a lot like the topic of slavery in the USA. It's a historical fact, and everyone learns about it in school, but it's not a popular topic in the culture. I'd wager few people in the USA are familiar with the names of the companies that were complicit in it, though undoubtedly some still exist.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by cf498 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:15PM (#17258577)
I dont think talking about the nazi regime is a depressing topic anymore in Germany and it hasnt been for a long time. It paved the way for people to define themselves as not just as the descendants of the German empire but people unwilling to be quite about their forefathers misdeeds. It empowered a lot of people to disregard the excuse for horrible deeds as people "just doing their job". It empowered the point of view, that the government can be wrong and should be opposed if so.

Between the Gestapo and the Stasi, the German executive has to lobby hard for support outside of their state employed peers to be viewed as a force tasked with their job by democratic mandate. As little as that is the case in reality, it still is a great development historically. Just the part alone, that soldiers are meant to be citizens in uniforms has done a lot to root out any possibility of the military having a say in politics.

Just to point it out, I dont think that shift happened with the end of the war or shortly after, quite the contrary. It is sadly clear, that warcriminals were protected by large parts of society. The change happend two decades later, when people were willing to speak up about their parents beeing mass murderer who got away.

[dead]
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by frostburg on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:50AM (#17227204)
The rest of the world hasn't really moved on. By the way, new account, creeping nazi apologism, oblique (but not really) references to the jews... do you people have some kind of bot warning you of certain keywords being used?

I recall a thread from last year that immediately summoned a bunch of nazi propagandists, too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13704300

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by kojon55 on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:53AM (#17227228)
No, I visit daily. I use new accounts every time I visit for privacy reasons.

I don’t know which part of my comment you found inaccurate, I’ll be happy to explain further.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by jessaustin on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @04:43PM (#17250938)
Whenever I'm around Britons, they're always slagging on the Germans. If there are any French around, they join in. (although maybe only to avoid becoming targets themselves?) When I ask why they won't stop picking on the poor Germans, it becomes very clear that they haven't "moved on". I presume that e.g. Poles or Czechs would agree, but I haven't had the opportunity to find out.

If you get to know e.g. Filipinos or Singaporeans, especially those of a certain age, you'll find they have similar feelings about the Japanese. History has consequences. I fear for my own nationality...

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by gpvos on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:46AM (#17227178)
Interesting! Maybe you live in a country that wasn't occupied by the Germans or otherwise affected much by the war? It's a major item in history lessons here (also Europe).
[dead]
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by gpvos on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:43AM (#17227688)
That's sad that you don't take this seriously. The wilful extermination of 6 million people is not something to be taken lightly, and something we should all keep remembering. Also sad that you're proud of kicking people out.
Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by perl4ever on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:51AM (#17227208)
I don't think it's accurate to say the world has long moved on other than "a part of the American population"[1].

IBM[2] and Prescott Bush are constantly mentioned in association with the Holocaust. It's a fair question why IG Farben or for that matter Thyssen-Krupp should be obscure.

[1]By which I assume you mean American Jews.

[2]As in this thread.

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by llao on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:56AM (#17226908)
I managed to get through school just fine, thank you. Zyklon-B is well known to me.

How does one company name from 70 years ago matter in the big picture anyways? Please don't assume that the rest of the world uses the same history syllabus like your US school might have. Did they at least also teach you who fabricated Agent Orange if they focused on manufacturers so much?

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by jacquesm on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:15AM (#17227019)
> Did they at least also teach you who fabricated Agent Orange if they focused on manufacturers so much?

In fact, yes they did: Philips Duphar and I learned this in school.

Check out the "volgermeerpolder" if it interests you.

And it was just a question, no need to perceive any insults, I was just wondering if the German school system is still highlighting WWII the way they used to, perhaps not, perhaps it never was done to the extent that it was presented to me in the first place.

As for why it matters: For anybody involved in industry IG Farben and IBM are important because of the ethical implications.

Finally, I never went to a US school (talking about assumptions...).

Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name by fileeditview on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17228779)
When I was at school (in Germany) the Nazi topic was ubiquitous at the loss of other historic topics. After hearing the same things again and again year after year I became very uninterested with history lessons. Maybe it was the fault of my school or my teachers but I gathered that this is a common thing in German schools. In hindsight I have to say that I really didn't learn much about German history besides the 1st and especially 2nd world war time.

While I absolutely agree that this topic has to be part of the curriculum it should not be so dominant. Who produced Zyklon-B is in my opinion a detail. There are other things in history that I am more interested in and that are more important. I understand you didn't want to attack anyone and I'm just telling you my opinion, no offense.

p.s. I knew about IG Farben but I don't know where I gained that knowledge.. maybe it was school, maybe my parents or maybe because I studied at Goethe Uni for some time.