Re:Bayer to retire Monsanto name
by ams6110 on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:27AM
(#17228034)
Please, you can't put wartime use of a defoliant in the same category as Zyklon-B and what it was used for.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
OK, so a chemical that causes an horrendous list of conditions, many of them being fatal, and used on purpose on civilians during a conflict, is a bad comparison with Zyklon-B? Where do you draw the line then? How much toxicity is enough to draw the parallel?
https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/agentorange/condit...
>used on purpose on civilians during a conflict
It wasn't used on purpose. 2,4-D, the defoliant used, wasn't the carcinogen and wasn't sprayed on people intentionally. The carcinogen in this case was a dioxin contaminate inadvertently created in the manufacturing process. The US military thought they were spraying a chemical they thought was (mostly) safe.
Was the effect of 2,4-D a horrific disaster? Yes. Was it a mistake to use this tactic? Yes. Has the US provided all the necessary restitution? No. Is it equal to IG Farben knowingly producing Zylkon-B for genocide. No even close to the same.