So it is with watches (or anything else, really). You think that the enjoyment of a watch is simply having it, but that's not how the hobby is enjoyed by its enthusiasts. Watches like this are enjoyed by talking with other collectors, admiring the movement, geeking out over the features ("complications") built into the watch, commiserating over ingroup gossip, etc.
It's not for everyone, and I don't blame people for not "getting" watches! The subculture might be somewhat inscrutable from the outside, and it can be easily dismissed as an idle fancy for the rich, but there is a lot more depth to it than what you're seeing.
And like art, it has a robust secondary market, which means some of the rare ones can go up in value, sometimes by a lot. People don't buy art because they get something, they buy art because they simply appreciate it.
Everybody is different. I'd pick a thousand dollar watch over a MTG collection or a gaming tower any day (mostly because I don't think gaming is valuable at all)
And when it comes to the hobby of expensive watches...you get nothing but an expensive watch.
Every other hobby, you get something.
PC gaming? You've got games you can play, and a monster computer that can run them with beautiful graphics.
Card games? You've got a collection of cards and can quickly build new decks to adjust to the changing meta.
Model trains? I've seen some really impressive miniature towns people have built around a model train set.
I just don't understand expensive watches.
> Here's the disconnect you're struggling with: you don't value watches. Or more accurately, you don't appreciate them beyond simple utilitarian timekeeping.
That sums it all up pretty well. If I'm spending a lot of money on something, I want there to be at least something useful or enjoyable that I'm getting out of it, beyond the enjoyment of simply having it, which typically is not something ever feel about things. Things are just things. The only value they have IMO is their utility.
(Though I would certainly attach sentimental value to something that was made by hand by a relative and passed down)