i see what you did there, you rascal--use a forum where people might care about such signalling and make sure they will know your watch in the future, so when they see it on your wrist, they'll wish they were you.
-- non-watch wearer (see how much cooler i am for not caring?)
I mean, I don't mind if others have such hobbies -- to each their own. As a matter of fact, I have some friends, too, who are into collecting expensive watches. Yet, I still don't get it, just like in the grandparent comment.
Your imagination needs work. Being on HN, I'd assume that you have at least one hobby that necessitates a significant amount of electronics (gaming console + TV, monitor + PC, laptop). Any one of these (if you actually care about the hobby) will run you thousands of dollars.
You'll probably dodge at this moment and say how necessary or important or utilitarian all those things are, but that's just because you like your hobbies and don't like other people's.
I'm not sure I see the distinction between "wearing it" and merely "owning it", as they both seem somewhat passive activities (if you'll pardon the oxymoron).
In other words, I'm asking, is the hobby one of collecting (as with stamps or coins), or is there something involved in the wearing that is the fundamentally interesting/engaging part of the hobby?
Perhaps what most commenters (including me) are skeptical of is that hobbies have also been known as "pastimes" and are, presumably enjoyable, ways to pass the time.
I suspect that most here would agree that for "expensive" hobbies, such as high-end computer gaming, automotive racing, or aviation, they would still participate in it and call the hobby by the same name if they didn't personally own the equipment necessary to engage in their chosen activity (and merely had unrestricted, or even shared/restricted, access to it).
I'm not so sure this is the case, however, for something like art collecting. If that person doesn't get to keep the art, isn't that really just an art buyer, not a collector?
I am, indeed, surprised by that, but only, again, because it seems passive. Is there more to it, like being seen? Seeing others' reactions? I'm genuinely curious.
I also suspect you're unusual, which is why I was hoping to hear from the original commenter. I could, of course, be quite wrong.
> If there was a service where I could wear different watches without owning them I would be all over that.
I did a web search for "luxury watch rental" and found something at least vaguely similar. If those services aren't what you're looking for, maybe that's a business idea, along the lines of pooling/sharing private jets.
> If I could only own watches to display them in my house and never take them out I wouldn't bother.
Seems like a false dichotomy. However, it's closer to the actual practice (as I understand it) of owning multiples units but only ever wearing one at a time.
Of course, I'm lumping "collectors" in with "wearers", but that's partly because it's so difficult to distinguish from external observation and partly because some commenters have described watches as art, something which doesn't generally have an activity it can be used for.
Jaeger-LeCoultre owner here
I tried the Ultra Thin, but I found it was a bit too thin for my wrist.
And when it comes to the hobby of expensive watches...you get nothing but an expensive watch.
Every other hobby, you get something.
PC gaming? You've got games you can play, and a monster computer that can run them with beautiful graphics.
Card games? You've got a collection of cards and can quickly build new decks to adjust to the changing meta.
Model trains? I've seen some really impressive miniature towns people have built around a model train set.
I just don't understand expensive watches.
> Here's the disconnect you're struggling with: you don't value watches. Or more accurately, you don't appreciate them beyond simple utilitarian timekeeping.
That sums it all up pretty well. If I'm spending a lot of money on something, I want there to be at least something useful or enjoyable that I'm getting out of it, beyond the enjoyment of simply having it, which typically is not something ever feel about things. Things are just things. The only value they have IMO is their utility.
(Though I would certainly attach sentimental value to something that was made by hand by a relative and passed down)
So it is with watches (or anything else, really). You think that the enjoyment of a watch is simply having it, but that's not how the hobby is enjoyed by its enthusiasts. Watches like this are enjoyed by talking with other collectors, admiring the movement, geeking out over the features ("complications") built into the watch, commiserating over ingroup gossip, etc.
It's not for everyone, and I don't blame people for not "getting" watches! The subculture might be somewhat inscrutable from the outside, and it can be easily dismissed as an idle fancy for the rich, but there is a lot more depth to it than what you're seeing.
And like art, it has a robust secondary market, which means some of the rare ones can go up in value, sometimes by a lot. People don't buy art because they get something, they buy art because they simply appreciate it.
Everybody is different. I'd pick a thousand dollar watch over a MTG collection or a gaming tower any day (mostly because I don't think gaming is valuable at all)
But rest assured - given your demonstrably comprehensive knowledge of my altruistic habits, I'll make a note to consult with you about which particular lives I should deign to save the next time I'm considering funding one of my hobbies. I'm sure playing messiah and saving "a dozen lives" will be even more satisfying to my narcissism than shiny things; thanks for the suggestion!
Maybe your judgementalism is as much a problem as their relativism?
And, by the way, the point about "relativism" wasn't about moral relativism at all.
Here's someone with $1M. They give away $25K in a way that saves a dozen lives. They also spend another $25K on a watch. Are you outraged? Are you more outraged than the previous example because they wasted money on the watch? (Is that better or worse than keeping the money in the bank?)
Here's someone with $1M. They give away $975K, saving 468 lives. They take the last $25K and spend it on a watch. Are you outraged because they didn't also give away the last $25K? Does the watch blind you to the good they did? Or did they have to give away all $1M to avoid your "perfect contempt"?
See, you're judging their selfishness by the one purchase, not by the whole of their economic activity. I dispute whether that is a relevant metric.
Here's the disconnect you're struggling with: you don't value watches. Or more accurately, you don't appreciate them beyond simple utilitarian timekeeping. That's fine, most people don't really care about them. Instead of trying to relate to people who buy expensive watches by valuing watches - which you clearly don't - relate to them through the broader experience of spending a lot of money on a hobby.
Do you have any hobbies you spend "a lot" of money on, perhaps more than what's required just to engage with the hobby? Keep in mind that "a lot" is arbitrary. I have a friend who spends thousands of dollars on card games. I don't see the appeal, but it makes him happy and trading card games can be a fun activity. That hobby "doesn't require" a purchase of the most expensive, collectible versions of various cards, but people do it anyway. I'm pretty sure my friend doesn't do it to signal that he can spend that money :)
The point is this: what's expensive for one person is affordable for another, and what's valuable for one person is frivolous for another. There's not much beyond that. It's all relative - in principle it all comes down to whether or not you spend strictly more than you need to on a thing so you can enjoy it beyond its raw functionality. If you do, then you're no longer treating that thing as a tool, you're treating it as a form of art. Like all forms of art, expensive watches are polarizing and subjective, and they attract a subculture of people who discriminate between things which seem utterly arbitrary to people who don't appreciate them.