Nevertheless, KDE itself comes with a set of background services too, which some users might find bloated.
I think nowadays its just a matter using what fits your needs. The only thing that nobody is perfect at is 'settings' as they mostly focus on desktop specific settings and many users don't know where to find more advanced settings (e.g. /etc).
Oppositely, if I haven't paid anything I am happy to put up with quite some grief. Just knowing you could fix it if you wanted to spend the time has value for me too.
However using MacOS makes me very sad: paying $1000 for the privilege of bugs and user interface flaws galls me.
I have quite low expectations of Windows too, but that is (a) historical expectations and (b) I don't expect much from a now advertising-based OS. [Aside: I just wish Microsoft would charge me a subscription for a professional version that didn't have crapware and adverts].
Funny you should say that, it literally just took me hours to create a new kb layout (my keyboard has a broken P key that I wanted to substitute). It was a mess of error messages and "keyboard already existing" problems. Ugh.
https://gist.github.com/mauron85/5f4b640aa4e5e968e0496ac5a08...
As long as something is an "alternative" rather than common/default, its users will mostly be self-selected because they specifically went out of their way to use it.
Sometimes it can even be the same person depending on their needs.
On my coding laptop I swear by i3, it's fast, simple and powerful. Everything is just a keystroke away. On my entertainment machine though (TV, music and games) I find gnome much better because friends can use it and these tasks are better handled with a mouse.
This is the fundamental problem with convergence as well, different devices have different use cases and you can't make one person happy all the time.
There is never only going to be one best solution, as that depends critically on the problem you are trying to solve.
Cinnamon devs: Thank you!
Isn't the same true for closed-source desktops? I mean, how on earth could any software be perfect for everyone?
I myself do jump from one DE to another every other year. But that's more out of curiosity.
Could you elaborate on what you mean by "feel welcome"? AFAIK neither of those systems is open to contributors: if a UI/UX designer wanted to improve some aspect of the design, they're either limited to whatever config/theming the company decided to allow, or they must go and convince the company of their idea (especially sales, marketing, etc.), sign NDAs if they want to see/fix any of the implementation details, and so on.
With FOSS they could just post to a mailing list or something, which I would imagine is more welcoming. Maybe the difficulty is social: FOSS projects certainly suffer from toxicity, but their transparent processes also make it more visible. Companies are better able to hide toxicity using firewalls and private/internal communication channels.
In Windows and macOS systems, and even on Google platforms, you go to a conference, there is a wealthy set of talks and discussion forums about UI/UX ideas.
We just get to use Sketch, XD, Photoshop, whatever gets the job done to transmit the ideas and how users interact with the platforms.
On UNIX world, or what is left of it BSD/Linux, GNOME and KDE designers get bashed and something like xmonad is considered the epitome of GUI experience.
A similar conference will be about filesystems, network protocols, graphics drivers, kernel modules and very seldom about anything UI/UX related.
So the designers that still try to contribute to GNOME and KDE apps do so in spite of community, because they believe that they can still make a difference.
Everyone else just moves into places where they feel welcome.
I am still wondering how long elementary OS is going to be around.
I would expect working on Gnome (or KDE or Cinnamon or Mate or XFCE or LXDE, the list goes on) to be a thankless task. You try to please everybody and yet please nobody. The imperfections of Linux desktops are more grating because of the knowledge that alternatives exist.
On Windows or Mac OS, you are stuck with the desktop you have, with little ability to do anything other than basic customizations. But people soldier on and get used to it because they have no choice.
I wonder whose users are truly more satisfied in the end.