News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by xmodem on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:40AM (#17143348)
The Instapaper one - #1 - is troubling for a non-obvious reason. One of the tenets of GDPR is that you have to be told how your data is being used. So the only explanation for this behaviour is that there's some shady shit going down that they want to stop before they have to admit to it.

If I used Instapaper I'd be filing a complaint with my local DPA about this.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by dingo_bat on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:48AM (#17143402)
> So the only explanation for this behaviour is that there's some shady shit going down that they want to stop before they have to admit to it.

No, it can something as simple as "we cannot guarantee that all your data is deleted with our current storage system". It would be a lot better if people stop being so alarmist.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by Silhouette on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:49AM (#17144498)
It would be a lot better if people stop being so alarmist.

Indeed. It's odd looking at discussions about the GDPR on HN.

On the one hand, we have people who argue that compliance isn't really that big a deal if you're not doing anything horribly wrong, most ethical businesses would already be mostly compliant anyway, etc.

On the other hand, we have people who argue that even if that is the case, the length and ambiguity of the regulations and guidance combined with the potential penalties still cause significant overheads and risks, particularly for smaller businesses without dedicated resources to deal with compliance matters.

There is some truth behind both of those positions, I think.

But then I've seen so many comments now on HN and other geek-friendly forums that seem to be based on the premise that most/all businesses are somehow doing evil things with personal data and they must be stopped. A noticeable number of people are advocating obviously vexatious use of the new subject rights, not in response to any specific concern or after some unsatisfactory attempt to resolve concerns reasonably, but as a weapon with the clear goal of causing maximum disruption and cost to organisations. I wonder how anyone can think giving so much "legal ammunition" to these people is a good idea.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by 4684499 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @02:42PM (#17147004)

    > so many comments now on HN and other geek-friendly forums that seem to be based on the premise that most/all businesses are somehow doing evil things with personal data and they must be stopped
I think it's pretty reasonable to have that premise when those businesses can't tell their users what they did or will do with personal data. No one could even tell whether it's evil or good if you don't show me some details. And sometimes, you assume it's good for me, but I think it's bad for me. Thank you for your good intention but all I want is just an opt-in option, not opt-out, is that so hard to accept? When you drag me into something I don't want, why would I assume you are doing something good? Users being alarmist is not users' fault, data companies' unethical use of data made users react this way.

    > "we cannot guarantee that all your data is deleted with our current storage system".
If so, just say it. But after that, you may want to explain to me why you can't even take care of my data while claiming you respect it. Did you collect my data then just forget where you store it? If the deletion is that hard, why should users trust such company in the first place?

GDPR is an action of defense, not a weapon for invasion. Only predator would think it's a weapon and be afraid. GDPR is not perfect for now, but complaining the ambiguity of it doesn't make internet companies' vague ToS or Privacy Policy clear as crystal. Let's not play double standards here.

I'm quite aware HN is full of people work in data industries, I just have to say it.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by gregknicholson on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:56AM (#17143475)
If it were something that simple and reasonable, they'd be happy to say so.

The fact of not giving an explanation implies that the real explanation is worse that you would expect.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by kuschku on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:22AM (#17143706)
The deletion doesn’t have to happen immediately, just in a reasonable time frame. A few weeks is okay, too.

So if it was just that, they wouldn’t shut down.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by xmodem on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:55AM (#17143463)
Why can't they comment on it? It's very suspect.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by aeorgnoieang on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:35AM (#17144335)
I'd guess they're afraid of legal liability.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by bryanrasmussen on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:54AM (#17143458)
I think the instapaper one is just they aren't compliant yet, realize it, and are shutting down EU access until they reach compliance. There can be ways they are not compliant without necessarily selling data.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:50AM (#17143419)
Hey there – Brian from Instapaper here – we have a pretty clear and accurate privacy policy around the data we collect and how we use it, you can find it here: https://instapaper.com/privacy
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by fiiv on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:52AM (#17143438)
Hi Brian! Thanks for taking part in the discussion.

But what part of GDPR was it that caused you to have to close off European Union users?

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by TillE on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:13AM (#17143616)
It's worth noting that GDPR applies to EU citizens regardless of where they happen to be in the world (or if they're using a proxy), so an IP ban does absolutely nothing to help comply with the law.

You'd think a real company would have talked to a lawyer about this.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by snowwolf on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:50AM (#17143923)
That is incorrect.

GDPR makes no mention of EU citizens or residents.

The 2 main groups it applies to are:

1. activities of an establishment of a controller or a processor in the Union (so if the company is in the EU, ALL processing has to be GDPR compliant regardless of where the user is)

2. processing of personal data of data subjects who are in the Union by a controller or processor not established in the Union (if the company is not in the EU, processing of data of people in the EU - note they just have to be in the EU and not residents or citizens - so if you are from the US and on holiday in the EU and you order pizza delivery to your hotel, that personal data has to be handled in a GDPR compliant way, notwithstanding that the pizza company is probably in group 1 anyway but hopefully you get the point. And the converse of that, if you live in the EU and are on holiday in America and order pizza, that personal data does NOT need to be GDPR compliant as you are not IN the EU)

There are a few other scenarios included too.

Edit: It's worth pointing out that 1 seems to have been completed missed in almost all GDPR coverage I have seen, possibly because most of the coverage has been heavily US centric. If the company is established in the EU, it has to comply with GDPR for ALL users, not just people in the EU. This is why Facebook [1] and others changed their terms so that only EU users have a contract with Facebook Ireland, and everyone else now has a contract with Facebook Inc (US) - previously everyone had a contract with Facebook Ireland.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-privacy-eu-exclu...

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by crankylinuxuser on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:52AM (#17144534)
And that's the companies' out. Make shell companies that exist only in Europe to exfiltrate liability for the multinationals.

There's no real difference in "Facebook US" and "Facebook Ireland". The only difference is this methodology skirts the law.

Hopefully, the EU will climb up these jokes of shell companies and rightly smack them down.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by ghaff on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:37AM (#17143810)
How would that even make sense? A country enacts some arbitrary rule such as "You are not allowed to provide access to social media for its citizens." How do you possibly enforce that for citizens visiting or living in the US? (Short of demanding all users to verify their citizenship to access the site.)
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by kgwgk on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:18AM (#17143666)
No, it doesn't apply to EU citizens regardless of where they happen to be in the world.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by sleepyhead on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:12AM (#17143603)
close off European Union users? I don't see any info about that.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by Sean1708 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:26AM (#17143738)
Am I misunderstanding you here? Instapaper's email literally starts with:

> Starting tomorrow May 24, 2018, access to the Instapaper service will be temporarily unavailable for residents in Europe

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by xmodem on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:57AM (#17143480)
Hi Brian, thanks for replying to my post. I apologise for my reactionary tone above, but do you understand how by declining to share specifics your tweet aroused suspicion?

EDIT: I've just read through your privacy policy and I wish other companies had a privacy policy as clear, straightforward and detailed.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by matte_black on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:02AM (#17143522)
How is this a big deal?

They probably sell your data or use it to show you ads or targeted content. Who cares?

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by itchyjunk on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:33AM (#17143785)
People in this thread saw the title "GDPR Hall of Shame", possibly read it. Now they are trying to discuss stuff relating to "General Data Protection Regulation". My wild guess is people who are commenting on this thread care.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by matte_black on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:34AM (#17145012)
Do they really care or have they been pushed to care?
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by nathanaldensr on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:56AM (#17145231)
What the heck are you implying? Are you implying there's astroturfing going on? If so, that's ridiculous.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by snowwolf on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:57AM (#17143995)
As long as you are telling the truth about only sharing anonymous and aggregate data with publishers and advertisers, I can't see anything in your privacy policy that would preclude you from being GDPR compliant right now.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by amaccuish on Thursday May 24, 2018 @02:45PM (#17147024)
Hi Brian, I've downloaded all my data to move to self hosting and deleted my account due to this. I hope you've actually deleted everything :)

P.S. I still have access in the UK...

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by eli on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:51AM (#17143435)
That's extremely uncharitable.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by crankylinuxuser on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:56AM (#17143479)
I think we should reserve opinion here until bthdonohue gets back with fiiv's comment of "But what part of GDPR was it that caused you to have to close off European Union users?"
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by aeorgnoieang on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:42AM (#17144413)
I'm not sure it's reasonable to expect an answer to that question; at least not from someone other than their legal representative.
Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by crankylinuxuser on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:57AM (#17144585)
Well, i'm reading their silence as "We don't give a fuck about protecting customers' data.... cause its mine!"

In the end, companies whom don't go through with the GDPR prep and implementation tell me precisely one thing: there's something in their process that makes it hard for them to comply. But not seeing "We're in progress to comply at $date" tells me that they're doing some pretty nefarious stuff. Is that actually the truth? Well, we don't know and can't figure that out.

It's either you comply with the GDPR globally, or for $reasons you don't. I choose to work with GDPR compliant orgs first. I know how my data will be used. And if I buy European IoT hardware, I know its not a spy-station.

Edit: FUCK rate limiting. Here's my response.

Given that I'm an American who has had many accounts exfiltrated or otherwise leaked, I'm frankly sick of companies treating me as a data pinata.

I could go on to cite countless examples, but that dead horse has been beaten time and again. And in many cases, my data is used even without my permission (sending to gmail addresses, facebook ghost profiles, etc).

It might be charitable initially, but I've seen my own impact on bad data practices. It was the wild west... And now the GDPR finally puts a stop to a lot of badness.

Re:GDPR Hall of Shame by aeorgnoieang on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:10AM (#17144750)
That seems like an uncharitable reading. I'd guess they just don't want to express anything that implies some specific interpretation of the law.

I'm not sure there's anything they're doing that's not compliant, but uncertainty about whether that's true might be sufficient for them to consider it too risky to conclude that they are.

I think, if anything, the facts that the law is written is relatively 'simple' language, doesn't specifically mention any technical examples, and is widely expected to be enforced 'spiritually' and not literally, makes it particularly hard for lots of organizations to know with reasonable certainty whether they're in compliance or not.