News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by autokad on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:20PM (#17139754)
its really hard. I imagine company hiring practices (their growing dependence on recruiting firms) also doesnt help.

For instance, the best way to go to a new geography would be to land a job there prior to moving there. Even in data science, supposedly hot job market, I wanted to get a job in san francisco or seattle, but I was living in philadelphia. you hear stories about people graduating from cali universities and companies jumping through windows to get to them, but even though I graduated with a masters in CIS from Upenn ... crickets. I think because most of them recruit through agencies which filter by geography. I had to reach out aggressively to the recruiters themselves, and bypass a lot of the blockers, which took 2 years. Had I not done that, my talent didn't mean as much as where I was.

Now, imagine a small towner trying to do the opposite, get a job after they make a move to say, one of the urban centers. most people dont have a lot of savings to begin with, and what would last them 6 months where they are would be depleted very quickly in one of the larger cities. even getting an apartment is harder, you dont have a job? reject.

its not impossible, its just really difficult.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by phil248 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:17PM (#17140116)
Yes, it is difficult to uproot your family, take a huge risk, and relocate to a place with better employment and educational opportunities.

Just ask the tens of million of immigrants in this country who have done exactly that.

In a sense, it's unfair that native-born Americans are forced to compete with people from all over the world who are highly motivated and have an extremely high tolerance for risk. But it's also what has actually made this country great.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by tenpies on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:27PM (#17140199)
Could you not make the argument that a willingness to stay in a "doomed" city is critical for the re-emergence of desirable cities?

Almost every great city in existence has had at least one awful moment at some point in its history. If everyone took the "times are tough, I'm going to migrate to X place which is doing better" approach, then our urban geography would look so much different.

Ultimately, what gets a city out of tough times is its ability to retain the motivated people you mention. By losing those people, it seems that it's just reinforcing a winner-take-all approach to talent demographics.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by lopmotr on Thursday May 24, 2018 @02:32AM (#17141550)
What's wrong with winner-takes-all for cities? They're not people so it doesn't necessarily matter if they fail, as long at the people who lived in them end up OK. Maybe the country would be more productive and people more employed (thus happy) if most small towns didn't exist and most people lived in higher density cities. Of course some like the quiet places, but there would always be somewhere left for unemployed, retired, or work-from-home people who want that.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by hardtke on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:17AM (#17141052)
“Will the last person leaving Seattle turns out the lights?” billboard went up after the founding of Microsoft.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by intopieces on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:54AM (#17143094)
It went up after the Boeing Bust, in 1971. Microsoft wasn't founded until 1975.

http://www.historylink.org/File/1287 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by atonse on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:23PM (#17140168)
I'd upvote this 10 times if I could.

Unless you're an immigrant yourself, it's hard to imagine how big of a deal it is to just uproot your family and go to a different country and start over, often from scratch with no real networks to build from.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by vfulco2 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:27PM (#17140532)
One of the greatest stories I ever heard was of my wife's grandfather. He was a Sikh Indian with a hugely prominent position running a 1,000 man unit in the Indian army. Because of weird US immigration laws in the 1970s and his family relations, if his sons wanted to move to the US for a better life, he had to go first. He gave up everything and "restarted" his career as a stockroom boy at a Buster Brown shoe store in NYC, later talking his way into an interview with the CEO of Met Life where he spent the rest of his career. In the interim, he pulled his son from India who became a successful accountant and consultant. I always looked at him with such admiration and said, "now there is the story of a hero". The Sikhs are an incredible people generally. Disclosure: I am 3rd gen Italian-American.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:05AM (#17143142)
It is the only thing harder than being a poor rural American. I agree.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by Fjolsvith on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:32PM (#17159335)
Being poor in rural America is a choice.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by TheRealWatson on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:23PM (#17140170)
Why is it unfair. Americans are highly motivated too. Or at least they should be. It's much less risky to have to get on the Greyhound back to your parent's house than back to the other side of the world. This is a great country and we are in the perfect industry to take risks.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by Broken_Hippo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:57AM (#17141971)
If you are lucky enough to have that sort of situation available and the money to do so... sure. That isn't all that risky.

Of course, you might not be able to get that far. A greyhound ticket is expensive when you don't have work and are trying to feed children. Or your parents live in the same area. Or they are dead. Or maybe greyhound doesn't serve your area well enough for you to get transportation to the bus stop. and these are just shallow things. Anyone who doesn't have a parent or friend to stay with in an area with jobs is just out of luck.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by throwaway5752 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:09AM (#17141020)
Not everyone has the money for the bus trip, parents that would have them back, or parents that have a house. A lot of the people on HN come from a background of privilege (nothing wrong with that) but it effects how one perceives risk.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by cafard on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:30AM (#17143271)
Not everyone has parents that own a house, not everyone has parents that can shelter them. However, a quick check on the Greyhound site shows that bus fare from Washington, DC, to Topeka, Kansas, could be about $120, and from Washington to Los Angeles can be done for $180 to $280.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by romwell on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:04PM (#17159203)
Yeah right, because the bus ticket is the most expensive cost of relocation.

That's why when a company pays for relocation, they typically pay in the ballpark of $500 to account for the expenses associated with an interstate move for one person.

...which would be a nice narrative if it wasn't an order of magnitude off.

Someone relocating has to pay for:

-transportation of themselves (that's your Greyhound)

-transportation of their goods OR re-purchases of all the basic necessities (something to sleep on, something to cook with, etc) - $1000 conservatively

-transportation or purchase of a vehicle (because you really can't live and work without a car in most of the US), so in fact, let's forget about Greyhound. Throw in vehicle registration fees, increase in insurance (going from Podunk, MN to SF Bay Area will cost you $1000 just there, not accounting for gas/mileage).

Of course, you can save by moving to an area with extensive public transportation networks, but that means you'll pay way more in...

-security deposit AND first month's rent (which, spoiler! is usually going to be much higher in the city that people are relocating to). Again, for the Bay Rea, assuming you are a 20-something single who can live with room-mates (and not someone with a family who needs an apartment), that's around $1000 + $1000 if you are lucky. Add more for NYC where 2x rent is standard for a deposit (remember how you were going to save by going car-less? Put all that money here)

-perhaps you don't have a job offer waiting for you, so a month's worth of expenses while you're looking for a job. Let's say you are frugal, so that's $500, assuming you don't want health insurance and your jalopy made it across the country without needing repairs.

So somewhere around $5K for a single person for interstate relocation, assuming one finds a job within a month.

(I moved with a job offer; typical tech relocation packages are around $5-10K)

To all those looking at Greyhound costs, I need to ask: have you ever actually moved somewhere, tallying your expenses?

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by throwaway5752 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:07AM (#17144705)
I know they sound cheap, but I think you're underestimating how hard an extra $250 can be for a lot of people and how little savings the bulk of the US has (particularly lower income areas/populations, since we're talking in the context of "when their town has no future"). You are also assuming 1 ticket, and if my memory's right then there's a negative correlation between income and family size/age of having first child.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by TheCoelacanth on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:15PM (#17147284)
$280 is more than a week's worth of take home pay for a minimum wage worker.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:07AM (#17143149)
HAHA Parents house. Bus. What! I guess you can beg in the streets for bus money, but nothing can make you have a place to stay.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by kamaal on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:22AM (#17141780)
Sometimes its hard to understand the value of something until you see something much worse.

For an immigrant the contrast is very clear. For some one born and used to privilege not so much.

There is reason why so many new millionaires are made, but existing heirs of all those millionaires don't become billionaires. Without any real pressure, a persons efforts will juts wax and wane over time.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by mark-r on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:59AM (#17141208)
The way to make immigration seem less risky is to have others who have done it before you. Minneapolis has a large population of Somalis because word got around that it was a good community for them. The same could happen for groups coming from a disadvantaged area of the US.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by forapurpose on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:23AM (#17141078)
> it's unfair that native-born Americans are forced to compete with people from all over the world who are highly motivated

Why is it unfair? Are Americans incapable and need protection? I thought America was built on opportunity, and free, fair competition.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by vilmosi on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:39AM (#17141363)
> Just ask the tens of million of immigrants in this country who have done exactly that

You're not really disproving his/her point as you're ignoring the many millions more who fail to move in the first place.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by IloveHN84 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:33AM (#17141344)
Hey, someone calls it "comfort zone".. the longer you sit in, the harder coming out of it is.

Changing town/country is never easy and it has its own risks, but no pain, no gain

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by patrickg_zill on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:12PM (#17140790)
You're contrasting the people whose forefathers built the country, with the people who came later, after it was already built and there was no risk to be taken.

How much risk is an immigrant really taking on, when there is a safety net in terms of social services available to them, that pays multiples of their yearly earnings back in "the old country"?

Meanwhile, the native-born Americans have too much assets (even if in a crappy location, it still disqualifies them) to qualify for that same assistance...

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by forapurpose on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:17AM (#17141053)
> no risk to be taken

I can't believe the parent means that literally.

> people whose forefathers built the country

You don't get credit for what some ancestor did; you get credit for what you do. I'd say that trying to lean on your ancestors is 'un-American'; earn your own way.

Also, the U.S. has been 'built' continuously and it continues today. The work and progress didn't stop in 1776 or 1930 or whatever date the parent is assuming. The question is, what are you going to leave for the next generation?

> How much risk is an immigrant really taking on, when there is a safety net in terms of social services available to them, that pays multiples of their yearly earnings back in "the old country"?

This comment ignores the great burden of most immigrants: Leaving your home, moving to a foreign culture where you don't speak the language, where you have no contacts or network, and bringing few resources. I'd like to see most Americans pick up and move to a non-English speaking, completely foreign culture, with no money and no contacts.

It also assumes a decent quality of life in the U.S. 'social safety net', which is pretty awful, especially compared to other first world nations. No health care and terrible education, for one thing. Even people with jobs have a tough time, and need several of them just to get by.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by patrickg_zill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:40AM (#17141149)
Although the USA has problems, it is a "no-risk" to "little-risk" proposition provided you make it to the USA. (I am talking about the legal routes.)

I can't quite articulate it, but I have a serious problem with the attitude that seems to say "well yes, your family for 5 generations struggled to clear the land, make it productive, worked in factories, sent sons off to die in wars, but, if you aren't being 100% economically productive RIGHT THIS MINUTE, just get out of the way already and let immigrants take your place..."

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by forapurpose on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:05AM (#17141236)
> it is a "no-risk" to "little-risk" proposition provided you make it to the USA. (I am talking about the legal routes.)

That's just absurd. People who were born in the U.S. face many risks.

> get out of the way already and let immigrants take your place

Nobody is taking anybody's place. Economics is not zero sum; the better your neighbor does, the better you do. Your successful neighbors are your employers, customers, taxpayers, etc.

> if you aren't being 100% economically productive RIGHT THIS MINUTE, just get out of the way already ...

That's not a problem with immigration; it's a problem with U.S. government policy that doesn't educate, provide health care for, feed, or house its citizens, and concentrates economic opportunity in the hands of a very few. Those things are clearly doable, because almost every other wealthy country does them much better. And the political leaders who oppose such things, and continually try to 'shrink' government, try to distract attention from their responsibility (and the responsibility of their wealthy constituents who try to avoid paying taxes) by blaming immigrants.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dakna on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:12AM (#17143606)
Which social services to use as a safety net are you talking about? Because it is not Medicaid:

"In order to get Medicaid and CHIP coverage, many qualified non-citizens (such as many LPRs or green card holders) have a 5-year waiting period. This means they must wait 5 years after receiving "qualified" immigration status before they can get Medicaid and CHIP coverage. There are exceptions. For example, refugees, asylees, or LPRs who used to be refugees or asylees don’t have to wait 5 years."

https://www.healthcare.gov/immigrants/lawfully-present-immig...

Unemployment benefits? You have to pay into it to get money out of it. Same as everyone else.

Emergency treatment at a hospital? I don't see a difference between citizens and immigrants.

I would really like to know where that free money is I hear so much about.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by verelo on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:54PM (#17140962)
I find this pretty upsetting to read. Moving country has significant risk and difficulty, have you tried it? I have. The challenges today are not about finding clean water or basic shelter no, but if you have ever had to figure out healthcare, ID cards, banks, tax and find a job while managing a family? I’m sure you would might consider that it’s not easy after trying it.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by patrickg_zill on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:56PM (#17140970)
I grew up in 1 country and moved to USA (though both were English speaking 1st world countries). I didn't have to move a family, however.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by verelo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:23AM (#17144228)
That is great, so you should be able to somewhat relate! I think we should just all have a little more empathy. There is a lot of hate going around and somewhat like in the tech systems many of us work on daily, even problems that seem simple are very difficult in complex systems. Countries, the US in particular, are very complex systems and the issues that are imposed on those moving around western nations are not simple to navigate. I'm not a visible minority, but i still ran into many roadblocks, I'd hate to be easily singled out visually or have a language barrier, and have to deal with the issues I had to deal with.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by derefr on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:21PM (#17140830)
Off-the-wall idea: pay out Unemployment in multiples of the cost-of-living of whatever area you’re in, rather than in multiples of your previous wage/salary. Worked at a factory in small-town Michigan and qualify for six months’ “runway”? Move to SF and now it’s six months of SF-cost-of-living “runway” instead.

(Would this be abused for nice vacations? Almost certainly. But maybe there’s a better version of this which couldn’t.)

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by paulddraper on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:28AM (#17144285)
A high cost of living is a market signal that "too many" people live there.

If unemployment/basic income adjusts for cost of living, you wind up with a positive feedback loop that ignores these messages.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by derefr on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:04PM (#17145313)
Hmm, you're right. I didn't mean to suggest that basic income should be based entirely on cost-of-living, though. My thinking was something more like:

    NewUI = OldUI * (CostOfLiving[NewJobMarketLocation] / CostOfLiving[PrevEmploymentLocation])
Thus, if you got paid the going rate for a factory-worker in Michigan, and you moved to SF, then you'd now be getting the UI that a factory-worker in SF would be receiving if they had been getting paid the going rate for factory-workers in SF. So you could afford to "switch" to the SF jobs market, or any other jobs market, and compete for jobs with the unemployed factory-workers currently living in the SF area: you'd be able to afford to live roughly where they live, feed the family you moved with to the same standard they were used to back home while you're job-hunting, show up in clothes of the same quality they show up in, maintain your car as well as they do to get to interviews at roughly the same time they do, etc.

But that assumes that there are factory workers in SF. There aren't—running a factory in SF is an unprofitable proposition. Whether or not you could come to the area and job-hunt, supply of your job (or any job at your pay-grade) might just not be there to meet your demand.

And that's not even accounting for the second-order effects: decreasing friction of movement between jobs markets would cause everyone else who ever wanted to live in SF to also come there to job-hunt. So, even if there were some factory-worker openings right at the beginning of this policy, they'd quickly be filled, and the markets in cities like SF would come to resemble Hollywood: a place where you have to put up with unreasonable amounts of shit to get anywhere, because there's so much more talent who has come from all over to vye for attention, than there are productions needing talent, that the productions take absolutely no care in how they treat their talent.

In other words, at equilibrium, you'd just be back to where you started as far as "number of people employed" goes, at most levels†; and you'd also not see any change in the population density, demand for gentrification, or any other such thing in these cities, because Unemployment only lasts a fixed amount of time—you can't afford to stay if you don't succeed in finding a job. The one thing that would change is that companies the nation over would be seeing far more "talent liquidity", and thus thinking of employees as even more fungible/replaceable than they do now. (But, the flip-side of that statement: an individual new hire at an SF company would now have much more even probability of having originated anywhere in the country.)

---

† Maybe you'd get more startups, from several people coming to SF (or other expensive cities) and deciding to spend their UI as initial runway to form a company together. But that'd be the exception, not the rule, I think. (Might still have nice knock-on effects for employment if those companies need to grow by hiring later on, though.)

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by me_again on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:36AM (#17143806)
Most US immigrant visas (h-1b etc) are conditional on not becoming "a burden to the state" so you would be deported if you tried to claim unemployment etc.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dragonwriter on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:55AM (#17143973)
> Most US immigrant visas (h-1b etc)

H-1B is a non-immigrant work visa.

The only relation it had to immigrant visas is that, as a dual intent non-immigrant visa, it's not illegal for you to enter on an H-1B with the intent of applying for an immigrant visa without departing in between.

> are conditional on not becoming "a burden to the state"

That's not exactly true. The condition that actually exists in law relates mostly to the future likelihood at time of admission of becoming a “public charge”.

> so you would be deported if you tried to claim unemployment etc.

No, but your I-864 sponsors (whose income and assets are considered in making the public charge decision at admission) will have to pay back any payments you get from certain federally-funded public benefit programs. You can be deported for you not paying back your debts for certain other benefit programs in a specified time period, but very few benefit programs create the kind of debts that relate to that.

Unemployment, as an earned benefit, isn't actually an issue at all.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dakna on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:41AM (#17143844)
H-1B is a temporary (nonimmigrant!) visa category.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by bwb on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:56PM (#17140385)
Very well said.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by jefurii on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:38PM (#17140596)
> Just ask the tens of million of immigrants in this country who have done exactly that.

Seemed like more of a thing when America was actually a land of opportunity.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by octorian on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:55PM (#17139989)
I feel like recruiters filtering by geography is a big issue at times. When I lived in Florida, I felt like I was invisible to potential employers. There were a handful of local options that didn't bite, and remote options never paid any attention to me.

The moment I relocated to Silicon Valley, I began getting bombarded by recruiters.

At my current job, I have a co-worker who told me that his classmates would often fake a Silicon Valley address (and stomach travel expenses for interviews), and it made a huge difference in the rate of companies contacting them back.

Of course most people who live in those dead towns aren't necessarily like us, and may not have degrees or experience in demanded fields. So I'm not sure our stories are applicable to the conversation.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by sytse on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:19PM (#17140142)
I think changing your LinkedIn location to San Francisco Bay area and explaining during the first call you intent to move there when you've found a job is acceptable to most companies. BTW we hire in 90% of the world at GitLab
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by ajeet_dhaliwal on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:30PM (#17140223)
I believe you that this is true for GitLab but I’d also imagine many companies getting somewhat pissed off about that disclosure on the first call. Interesting idea though, I may try it in the future just to see what happens.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by toomanybeersies on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:19PM (#17140500)
On the contrary, I've seen and heard of a lot of companies that will not hire if you're not in the same city. They specifically say that you need to be in the city for interviews. They get too many applicants fishing for positions when there is no guarantee that the applicant is actually committed to moving.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by sytse on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:50AM (#17143926)
I can see that colocated companies would require you to fly in for interviews. Maybe some are open to grouping the interviews on the same day.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dlopezgarsco on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:11AM (#17143596)
Offtopic: are developers with no ruby experience considered @gitlab? I've been thinking of applying for a long time but have no ruby experience at all.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by sytse on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:49AM (#17143908)
We have vancancies for site reliability engineers and Go programmers. We used to hire people without Ruby experience to work on the Ruby codebase but it took significantly longer for them to be effective so we stopped doing that.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by ryandrake on Thursday May 24, 2018 @02:30PM (#17146879)
The modern equivalent of getting a 408 area code in order to avoid that recruiting filter.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by sotojuan on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:22PM (#17140161)
The cynical side of me thinks that companies, particularly in populated areas, don't want to pay for relocation or travel for interviews.

Their attitude might be "well, why would we pay for relocation/travel for someone in PA when we can probably find people in SF who already live here".

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by closeparen on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:06PM (#17140434)
FWIW, my brand-name SF employer believes that essentially all feasible Bay Area candidates have already been through its pipeline, and that future headcount growth will have to be elsewhere. Unfortunately it’s still not willing to consider remote, or to look anywhere between the top 3 most expensive US cities and the third world. At least the worldwide offices are first-party and have essentially the same people as work in the US, minus visa-related stress.

You could say “pay more” but housing is a positional good - that strategy doesn’t scale.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by fapjacks on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:28PM (#17140535)
Well, it's the same thing it's always been about and always will be about as long as there is executive management: Trust is a one-way street.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by orbitur on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:13PM (#17147899)
Just anecdotal of course, but I live in a decent-sized-but-unimportant city and Bay Area recruiters have been hitting my LinkedIn inbox quite a bit in the last few months, when the last time I heard something from them was when I graduated university 6 years ago.

My LinkedIn page is just a straight up listing of previous jobs, no descriptions, so I've found that kinda interesting.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by octorian on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:43PM (#17140295)
And if they can't, somehow they'd rather recruit globally and play the visa lottery instead of simply recruiting from elsewhere in their own damn country.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by sbov on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:39PM (#17140904)
Then they can't complain about a tech shortage

I worked for a small self funded startup a decade ago. We flew interview candidates in from across the country.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by awat on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:06PM (#17140435)
Going through this myself at the moment. Would love to move from the small city I work in remotely now to a larger city for more tech opportunities. But even within the same large multinational I work for if there isnt a sufficient salary bump compared to cost of living with no relocation leaving my small suburb I come out worse off then I started.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:00PM (#17140013)
It’s a small industry driven by relationships. Half the recruiters probably think UPenn is some community college.

For a 40 something industrial worker? Forget it. You’re talking about a grind of temp jobs and shit pay.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by brownbat on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:44AM (#17142215)
I was struck by the family that moved back in the article. They had a good job in the new location. What they didn't have was extended family or a community.

The pure financial impact of extended family childcare can easily eat away a step up in earnings for those with young children. Then the intangibles of not getting them to know your parents or the close friends you grew up with, those don't even have an exact market substitute. Frequent travel I guess?

It's not easy.

From the econ perspective I can't help but think that greater labor mobility would make things so much better, but as a new parent it's becoming obvious these are not trivial behaviors to shift at all.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by toomanybeersies on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:26PM (#17140522)
It's not just the job market.

It's hard to move to a new city and leave your friends, and often family, behind. Not to mention the lifestyle change, from rural to city, which will often entail giving up hobbies and pastimes.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by gerdesj on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:29PM (#17139825)
I'm really trying hard to get inside your head! There is definitely an "Americanism" here somewhere, which you take for granted but I have to tease out. I will probably get it all a bit wrong (despite having a fair few US relos) but I will do my best.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:32PM (#17139841)
Try being poor.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:34PM (#17139863)
On top of being from a very different culture and trying not to say anything or have any mannerisms that may give the recruiter the impression that you're a back woods hick.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by busterarm on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:12PM (#17140099)
The tech industry as a whole has a really severe class problem. There is a really terrible negative attitude towards the poor and the rural. We as an industry focus a lot on race and gender (and not in that order), but the real taboo subject that makes everyone uncomfortable is talking about what it's like to be poor.

It's especially bad here on HN where often the conversation devolves into people telling me that I'm wrong about my childhood where I grew up poor...or how poor people are a blight on society.

The single topic that I find in my career people insist on secrecy is about poverty. I continue to be open about it so that others are willing to talk about it to someone, because otherwise you just can't.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by noxToken on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:32PM (#17140232)
That is so abundantly true on HN[0]. Nearly any thread about poverty, money, or credit will be full of examples of people who don't understand what it's like to not have money, and it is strange. It's not usually the "American Dream" types who claim that anyone who works hard enough will be able to escape poverty. It's usually the, "have you tried not being poor?" types. Who the hell has money to pay for a house, car, and higher education outright? Those people certainly exist, but it's not the majority.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17034131

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by closeparen on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:38PM (#17140598)
Essentially no one - and given that, it’s weird that the dialogue around debt is so moralizing.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by almost_usual on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:31PM (#17140556)
I grew up in nowhere Illinois with a blue collar family. Honestly the values my family had growing up align pretty spot on with blue collar workers I’ve met in the Bay Area.

The problem with tech is the self centered elitist culture. The job filtering is extremely narrow and you need a specific background to get in the door of most places.

Blue collar workers are suffering everywhere (cities, rural) and it’s obvious the rest of America doesn’t care. When these workers turn to alternatives they’re dismissed because they weren’t lucky enough to be born with more opportunities.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by busterarm on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:17PM (#17140119)
Also, if you ask me what it was like growing up poor in NYC in the 80s, I'm going to give you a very evasive and superficial answer, because it's better than talking about dozens of my childhood friends who are now dead or worse.

You're not prepared to talk about it and honestly neither am I.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by agoodthrowaway on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:03PM (#17140419)
I grew up poor in PA. People who have never been poor are not prepared to hear about it. My wife doesn’t even want to hear about it. She’ll roll her eyes when I talk about it. The fact is that people can’t relate to an empty refrigerator or to not having money to buy a gallon of milk.

Poverty is soul crushing.

I have had a very successful and influential engineering career but I can look back at single decisions I made that could have sent me the other direction. It’s easy for people to say that the decision I made was obvious but it absolutely wasn’t at the time. I took huge risk being the first in my family to go to a prestigious University and double major in physics and mathematics in the early 90s(I was no prodigy); let alone go to graduate school.

One decision different and I’d be driving trucks in West Virginia.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by jwhitlark on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:59PM (#17140719)
I think this thread overestimates how much people care. Social and virtue signaling mean people have to be sympathetic when it's brought up, but I don't think most people actually care. Anyone who struggles wants their struggles to mean something, but the world doesn't care.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by forapurpose on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:32AM (#17141116)
> I think this thread overestimates how much people care.

I think you have it backwards. People are not naturally sociopathic; psychologically healthy people naturally care about other people. They may have limited resources to act, but that's a different issue.

As evidence of caring, people widely support social welfare programs. In most wealthy countries (and some others), everyone has healthcare on the taxpayer's dime, as well as other services such as housing. Even the U.S. spends vast amounts of money on these things. People also care about the rights and wellbeing of others worldwide; the trendy nationalism may try to argue against it, but Western democracies have been spending blood and treasure on others' freedom and prosperity for generations. (They spent those things on many sins too.)

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by busterarm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:20AM (#17142089)
People support social welfare programs, but they usually don't want it in their face. Given the opportunity to do something in person, most people crumble and go about their lives as usual. It's a very rare person that takes action.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by forapurpose on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:33AM (#17143782)
> they usually don't want it in their face.

We don't have a basis for talking about motives. I'd say people are scared and uncomfortable with what seems foreign to them.

> Given the opportunity to do something in person, most people crumble and go about their lives as usual. It's a very rare person that takes action.

Many people give money to those asking for it. Many will say that they are overwhelmed and feel like they can't help everyone (tip: don't let the great be enemy of the good: don't worry about helping everyone; if you can, help someone). Many have their own problems and reasons.

I can't remember speaking to someone who says they just don't care.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by kermittd on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:45PM (#17148252)
Yep completely agree. Had spent time "homeless" as a child, middle class as a teen, and then actually homeless during (very) early adulthood. Additionally some of my best friends parents are multi millionaires so I've seen the range.

Most peers talk a good game but they can't relate and don't truly care. Its hard for me to at times as well...

Of course I would never even bring any of this up IRL, not worth the conversation.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:25AM (#17141083)
They don't care. I'm going to destroy them and laugh. And then help them rebuild their lives because I'm a nice person. But sorry, they need to suffer, even just a little.

To clarify I'm only going to destroy them because they coast. You can't coast when you're working for that milk money. God having milk is so good.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:07AM (#17141242)
A nicer take: there should be mandatory class mixing. Rich kids should have to spend a few months being poor as part of their education. I'm not sure the other way around really helps anything but it'd be a nice break for the poor kid.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by freshhawk on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:25PM (#17140846)
One thing that is interesting is the whole hipster "lumbersexual" fad has made knowledge of "rural" things pretty cool in those circles.

Don't fall for the trap to think this means you can admit you were poor once too. That negative attitude will still turn towards you. You will be judged and it will be remembered. You'll get a little bit of "Other" on you and everything will get a little harder. Just consider yourself lucky that unlike most race and gender concerns you can pass very easily, so do it.

I'm impressed you are committed to being open about it, but I hope during that talk you tell them to start passing and help them learn how to if they need it.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by busterarm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:13AM (#17142064)
> I'm impressed you are committed to being open about it, but I hope during that talk you tell them to start passing and help them learn how to if they need it.

It comes with a social cost, but I'm enough of a "personality" that who I am is going to come out regardless. There's no point in being anything but honest, but it (being too different) has cost me my job two times. If you're at a good place around good people it's not a big deal.

As for the whole "lumbersexual" thing, it's sort of like putting on blackface, as far as I'm concerned.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by freshhawk on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:57AM (#17150731)
I'm conflicted about the appropriation aspect of it. This whole rural aesthetic fashion is obviously coming from modern young men being confused about how to be masculine now as well as a generic naivete about rural life and nature in general that make them see their escape from stressful office bullshit through rose colored glasses.

Mostly though, part of it is just a return to valuing the different types of skills necessary in that setting. This is great, and it is great for their perception of rural people in general, because they are bad at something that people who they look down on find easy - and it changes their mind.

It is a mixed bag, and seems like an overall good to me.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:21AM (#17141071)
If you admit living paycheck to paycheck to certain people you will be shunned and eventually pushed out. I've seen it happen so many times.
Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by busterarm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:03AM (#17142010)
Very true...

And it's funny, because I generally find that the truly wealthy, silver-spoon/old-money type of people do not do this and they generally don't care about it if they like you...

...it's the ones in the middle.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:50PM (#17140344)
> We as an industry focus a lot on race and gender (and not in that order)

As an aside, I've noticed that the American women in tech to be much more diverse in terms of background (including economic or social class) than the American men. Based on what I've learned through casual conversation I think that the various efforts to increase gender diversity have the positive side effect of catching a more diverse cross section of the population.

Re:Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future? by haskellandchill on Thursday May 24, 2018 @12:20AM (#17141063)
I came from the dirt. I worked hard to make it sure, but so did so many of my child hood friends. They didn't make it. It's sad. We can't all be top 10%, by definition.