The "popularity" algorithm is potato chips.
Good moderation is vitamins.
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by dredmorbius on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:03PM
(#17147772)
I'd go for "good moderation is high-nutrition, well-prepared, real food", thogh I catch your drift.
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by thaumasiotes on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @02:13PM
(#17136522)
Excessive consumption of vitamins will cause much bigger problems than excessive consumption of potato chips.
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by tunesmith on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @02:30PM
(#17136690)
Are you just making a specious argument, or are you literally arguing that acting in accordance with one's values will cause bigger problems than engaging in addictive behavior?
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @02:34PM
(#17136745)
But in moderation (heh), eating vitamins is much, much better for you than eating potato chips.
Nobody's arguing for an excess of anything. Obviously a completely locked down subreddit that rejects and deletes all posts and comments would be useless, but so would one that's completely unmoderated.
>Obviously a completely locked down subreddit that rejects and deletes all posts and comments would be useless,
Not necessarily. Reddit used to have some of those as running jokes. /r/blackfathers and such. Disagreeable uses are still uses.
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:23PM
(#17137881)
Sure, but that's more of an art installation. Duchamp's Fountains is a neat work of art, but I can't really use it for its intended purpose.
Firstly, you probably could do what you mean for that specific piece, at least once or twice. But more importantly, that statement presupposes the wrong intended purpose.
The thing about metaphors is that they're just metaphors, not equalities.
There's a difference between what people say they want (as interpreted by views, clicks, eyeballs), and what they want to want (as interpreted by values, what feels rewarding in hindsight, what they're glad they did later). I wonder if these algorithms will ever evolve to start serving up metaphorical vitamins instead of potato chips.