>Obviously a completely locked down subreddit that rejects and deletes all posts and comments would be useless,
Not necessarily. Reddit used to have some of those as running jokes. /r/blackfathers and such. Disagreeable uses are still uses.
Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:23PM
(#17137881)
Sure, but that's more of an art installation. Duchamp's Fountains is a neat work of art, but I can't really use it for its intended purpose.
Nobody's arguing for an excess of anything. Obviously a completely locked down subreddit that rejects and deletes all posts and comments would be useless, but so would one that's completely unmoderated.