I've read numerous times that smokers are actually a net gain for a healthcare system, assuming the same system pays for the whole life of the patient.
The majority of medical costs are incurred by a small minority of patients, usually at the very end of their lives. Smokers die earlier and faster, usually without the slow and expensive deterioration many healthier patients will go through.
Of course at best this argument assumes that you are looking at cost for a comparable standard of care, not cost for comparable health outcomes.
To me, this deflects from the main question of whether it is true or not. Or in other words, whether those quoting the "costs" of smoking (as a justification for further anti-smoking measures) are using dishonest propaganda. Also known as lying.
It points out that the question the claim addresses is different then that addressed by the opposing claim (and different than the policy concern that is usually beoing addressed.)
Which means its truth is orthogonal, rather than opposed, to the truth of the other claim.
Who's suggesting this? A bit presumptuous to go from tracking "thing that definitely kills people [smoking]" to "things that are bad but not that bad [drinking, unhealthy eating]". Quite the slippery slope that thinking tracking smoking will lead to tracking everything.
Why would you track smoking? Because the company pays more for insurance. So, it makes sense to track other things that are indicators for worse health outcomes, also causing higher insurance payments.
What are you saying here? You've lost me. Seatbelts are good and the laws we have in place are there to keep ignorance about them from spreading (ie. if you've never gotten in an accident, why would you wear a seatbelt?). So I definitely agree that we slipped on this slope for a good reason.
They also passed so that the automakers wouldn't be forced to put airbags into cars.
I was all up with agreeing with you until this point - but I honestly find it quite incredible that there are still people that think seatbelts are a bad thing.
It's an example of one thing being tracked moving down the line to something that the majority of people opposed also being tracked and legislated.
28 days is probably a good measure.
The dystopian bit is that they give your personal data to your employer. Was this really unclear to you? I'm confused at why else you would try to derail that point.
In fact, yes, smokers do die sooner, which is why they actually cost less:
https://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/05/health/05iht-obese.1.9748...
I understand that people don't like smoking, but that doesn't excuse the loose way that organizations throw around numbers about this topic.
It's instructive to watch the way people reason when they're convinced they've got the moral high ground. There's almost nothing they won't say.
And they never give a source so a person can fact check the numbers.
Luckily, in this case we know we're reading dishonest propaganda, since they make no mention of the revenue side of it.
> It's instructive to watch the way people reason when they're convinced they've got the moral high ground. There's almost nothing they won't say.
Preach brother.
It is the largest single expense to employers and to the [Canadian] healthcare system. It is not dystopian to want to track smokers on their journey away from smoking - it's the only way we know if we're getting better at helping them quit.
28 days is a good measure of smoke free. By that time, you are through the nicotine withdrawal of about 72 hours, which I think is the biggest cause of relapse. After that, you need to resist the social and habitual pressures, and that is wholly up to the individual. Some people can go 20 years resisting these pressures, others collapse in a few days. So 3 weeks is a fair balance, I think.
[1] http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/smoking-economic-cost-1.4357...