Re:QuitGenius (YC W18) raises $2M to help people quit smoking
by jbob2000 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:57PM
(#17129744)
> seatbelt laws
What are you saying here? You've lost me. Seatbelts are good and the laws we have in place are there to keep ignorance about them from spreading (ie. if you've never gotten in an accident, why would you wear a seatbelt?). So I definitely agree that we slipped on this slope for a good reason.
Re:QuitGenius (YC W18) raises $2M to help people quit smoking
by ameister14 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @06:20PM
(#17129896)
The reason seatbelt laws exist is not because they are intrinsically good, or to prevent ignorance. They exist because it is expensive to pay for someone that has slammed through a windshield and requires intensive care. They passed in large part through the argument that putting them in place would lower insurance rates. That's where a lot of the money lobbying for their use came from.
They also passed so that the automakers wouldn't be forced to put airbags into cars.
Re:QuitGenius (YC W18) raises $2M to help people quit smoking
by GordonS on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @06:09PM
(#17129818)
> seatbelt laws, for example
I was all up with agreeing with you until this point - but I honestly find it quite incredible that there are still people that think seatbelts are a bad thing.
Re:QuitGenius (YC W18) raises $2M to help people quit smoking
by ameister14 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @06:24PM
(#17129917)
I'm not saying seatbelts are bad, I'm saying the reason the laws exist is in part based on a combination of NHTS data opened up with Reagan's move to regulate federal drinking laws and the idea that mandatory seatbelts would lower insurance costs.
It's an example of one thing being tracked moving down the line to something that the majority of people opposed also being tracked and legislated.
Why would you track smoking? Because the company pays more for insurance. So, it makes sense to track other things that are indicators for worse health outcomes, also causing higher insurance payments.