News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by thisisit on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:21PM (#17127095)
On Tesla's viability, stock price and debt, I think there can't be better quote than this:

Tesla’s current price is arguably fair if most cars are powered by electricity in 10 years, if most of these cars are made by Tesla, if Tesla can make those cars with sufficient margin and quality control and can service the cars properly, and if Tesla can raise additional capital sufficient to cover a $3 billion annual cash drain and another billion to service its debt.

https://www.researchaffiliates.com/en_us/publications/articl...

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by martythemaniak on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:35PM (#17127788)
I don't think you'll find a financially literate person who'll agree with the statement "Tesla's current $50B market cap in 2018 is fair given their current financial situation". Of course it doesn't make sense, nobody, neither Musk, bulls or bears believe that statement.

Tesla's current price has high expectations built into the price, so the game is that Musk and the bulls have to demonstrate that they're meeting those expectations, while the bears have to portray everything as a failure. Unlike normal companies though, there are A LOT of bears and they have a shit-ton of money riding on Tesla stumbling and they will go to absurd, surreal lengths. I mean, in what reality is "Mid-level Executive Takes Vacation" a major news story?![1]

And no, there can in fact be a far better quote, because it doesn't even begin to describe the upside of Tesla, even though they have plainly stated their intentions to pursue those upsides. They're merely comparing them to Ford (same market cap), but Ford does not:

- Intend to take on Uber

- Intend to compete on price with rail cargo shipping

- Intend to make and sell batteries.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/teslas-engineering-chief-takes-...

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:46PM (#17127897)
How does "taking on Uber", which currently has problems by its own and is not profitable either, help?
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by martythemaniak on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:03PM (#17128041)
Well, Uber is worth something, or rather, "Ride Sharing Company" is worth something. We don't have to agree (or discuss) what that number is, as long as we agree that it's not trivial (say, in the 10s of billions). If Tesla executes on its plan and are successful, they will have some percentage of that business and their market cap will then become justified on financials, rather than expectations as it is today.

So yeah, they have stated their intentions simply and plainly. If they succeed, they're price will be justified and could grow. Which side of the story you choose to believe is up to you, but that's true of any growing company.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:13PM (#17128122)
I see what you mean, but I think the problem is kind of self-referential: Uber has this value (as a ride-sharing company) because the bulls believe that it sometimes will be highly profitable and can defend it's position. If Tesla can take on Uber, Uber did not defend it's position, and much of that value will go away. Not sure there would be 10s of billions left. How many people are there that Tesla could defend it's position in that market, if uber couldn't against Tesla?

Or in other words: Those people who value Tesla higher because of their ride-share potential, should at the same time rate Uber lower.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by martythemaniak on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:44PM (#17128384)
That's right, although what position you take on the market also depends on what you're after. To go all-in on Tesla, you have to believe that LIDAR is a crutch and that Level 4 autonomy is possible with primarily visual sensors.

Or maybe you're not so sure and want something safer / lower return. In that case, you'd buy into both of them, say 50-50. If one goes bust, but the other goes 5x, you're still good.

In reality, you can't buy into Uber, so it's largely theoretical. Also, Waymo and GM are vying for the same market and they all have different strategies - ie Alphanet will finance Waymo's fleet with Google's earnings, while Tesla will finance theirs with their customer's money (and share the profits). Hard to say what will happen.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by clomond on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:05PM (#17127472)
Let me be devils advocate here for a second...

Let's first assume that Tesla succeeds in their production volumes and positive gross margins in the next few quarters, and is able to solidify and stabilize their financial situation this year. What this article misses is the scope of upside that is what I believe the Tesla bulls are seeing (Disclaimer: I am a Tesla bull).

In looking at the next 10 years I see:

- Batteries being the primary constraint in progress in volumes of electric cars for automakers (which positions Tesla and vertically integrated companies like BYD well, but traditional automakers without a tight grip on battery production at this point not as much).

- By looking at Tesla instead as a battery company, you can see how the vertical integration and scale (with the addition of plans for additional gigafactories in China and Europe) can be a unique competitive advantage against other auto companies. The more expertise Tesla gains by making better, cheaper batteries, the better.

- The article you linked and many Tesla bears do not consider the opportunity with trucks, and different segments in the within logistics / transportation market (Tesla could release different truck sizes and modes). Again, we are looking 10 years out, right?

- Tesla Energy, which is about grid storage (hint: requires batteries here too) will become a significantly larger market as certain grids around the world increase their share of intermittent energy sources. Grid scale battery systems are already becoming competitive alternatives to natural gas peaker plants.

- And don't forget about SolarCity. They could do a lot with SolarCity, and make progress in various segments within rooftop solar, as costs of solar cells continue to decrease in the next decade.

Not saying that Tesla is not without immense risk and that they do not have a very challenging few quarters ahead of them - but saying the upper bound of their upside is related to capturing the entire automobile market is not fully putting into account their long term plan and strategy.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by s2g on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:45PM (#17127884)
> - Batteries being the primary constraint in progress in volumes of electric cars for automakers (which positions Tesla and vertically integrated companies like BYD well, but traditional automakers without a tight grip on battery production at this point not as much).

https://techcrunch.com/2018/03/13/volkswagen-has-locked-down...

> Again, we are looking 10 years out, right?

The question is if Tesla can survive 10 years.

> And don't forget about SolarCity

Oh please don't. Don't ever forget that Musk spent company money to bail out family from this shitty company.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by slg on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:40PM (#17127838)
You are also forgetting Tesla's eventual ride sharing platform. Uber's valuation is currently higher than Tesla's. I don't know if Tesla is any closer to self driving taxis than Uber, but their is at least some potential there.

Tesla's stock is certainly overvalued compared with their current financials and current competitors. However I wouldn't be surprised if 20 years down the line we think comparing Tesla to Ford was like comparing Netflix's mailing DVDs business to Blockbuster. That potential is what you are paying for when you purchase Tesla stock.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by maxerickson on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:08PM (#17127504)
But why do you expect batteries to be anything other than a boring commodity business?

Boring commodity businesses are a fine place to make money, but they aren't so likely to go to the moon.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by croddin on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:16PM (#17127598)
Was oil a "boring commodity business"? Many oil companies made very high profits.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xkjkls on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:28PM (#17127718)
It's really about moats. What is the major moat you have around a battery production business? If batteries produced from Tesla versus any other competitor are almost indistinguishable, what is unique about Tesla that those market forces wouldn't suck out all of its profit?

In oil, even though it is a "commodity", in that one barrel of crude oil is mostly indistinguishable from another, oil companies can have huge competitive moats by having integrated refining, the ability to distribute, or the fact they can have large monopolies on the resources of very specific areas. Batteries don't have quite the same sort of easy complementary businesses.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:50PM (#17127934)
To add to your argument, there is a relevant probability that batteries in 10 years will be based on different chemistry. I don't think Tesla is in basic battery research, so there is a chance that whoever who comes up with a better mouse trap makes Tesla's battery knowledge obsolete quickly.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xapata on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:38PM (#17127813)
> What is the major moat you have around a battery production business?

https://www.tesla.com/gigafactory

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xkjkls on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:15PM (#17128131)
Is that really going to be competitive against Panasonic, LG, or Samsung? All of those are in countries with better access to Lithium and cheaper engineering resources? I'd bet on those guys producing way more batteries.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by bllguo on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:33PM (#17128283)
In fact, a lot of the gigafactory tech is Panasonic's. They lead the battery cell manufacturing at the factory.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by maxerickson on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:00PM (#17128019)
Oil companies make large profits by operating huge businesses. They don't make particularly outstanding profits as a percentage of revenue.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by w0m on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:15PM (#17127576)
but the backbone of moonshots tend to be 'boring commodity businesses' o.0
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by nkoren on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:46PM (#17127904)
That quote actually seems quite unfair to me. If "most" cars are to be electric in 10 years, and "most" of those are to be made by Tesla, then Tesla would have captured more than a quarter of the world's auto sales, and thus should be worth 25% as much as the entire auto industry. Less some appropriate discount rate, but plus the value of any suppliers that Tesla's greater degree of vertical integration has taken out of their supply chain, and plus the value of any non-automotive profits they make (grid storage etc.).

If one truly believes that Tesla will capture 1/4 of the world's automotive market as well as find success in non-automotive applications, then the current stock price is woefully undervalued. To merely believe that their current price is justified requires much less bullishness than that.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by pwinnski on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:49PM (#17128428)
I think the point is that the chance of all of those IF conditionals being true is close to nil, which means that Tesla is currently over-valued.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by nkoren on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @03:32PM (#17128735)
No, it says that for the present valuation to be fair, then all those conditions must be true. But if all those conditions were true, then Tesla would control at least a quarter of the global automotive market, and its valuation would be considerably higher.

Obviously not all of those conditions will be true, however -- only the craziest Tesla bulls would argue that. Conversely, if none of them are true, then Tesla is definitely over-valued. But I think you'd have to be a pretty crazy Tesla bear to make that argument. Finally, if those conditionals are a mix of true and false... well, that doesn't really doesn't tell you much about Tesla's fair market value, which is why I don't think this is a particularly useful analysis.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by twblalock on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:22PM (#17127652)
I like Tesla and I want it to succeed, but I don't see how it can possibly be justifiable for Tesla to have a market cap anywhere near that of Ford and GM. They manufacture and sell several million cars a year and could easily start cranking out electric cars if the consumer demand is there. I'm sure they'll be grateful to Elon for creating consumer demand for electric cars, but they, not Tesla, will be the ones who sell millions of them.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xigency on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:39PM (#17127826)
Uber basically makes a navigation app and has a higher valuation (not on the public market) than any of those companies. Why couldn't a car manufacturer have greater market value than another manufacturer even if they sell fewer cars?
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by martythemaniak on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:50PM (#17127939)
Simply put, Tesla has high expectations built into their current price. These expectations exist because they are several years ahead of their competitors in key components and they have lines of business available to them that are not available to GM or Ford.

TSLA is the most (or amongst the most) shorted stock on the market, so a lot of people have a lot of money riding on being able to convince people that they can never meet those expectations. So we hear a lot about Tesla having trouble ramping up to 20,000 units/month, but we don't hear very much about GM having trouble selling 2000 units per month.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by ericb on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:39PM (#17127825)
I think your prediction ignores the historical trend of incumbents ignoring incoming paradigm shifts to their peril.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by twblalock on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:56PM (#17127986)
In this case the incumbents are investing heavily in electric cars and various forms of autonomous driving.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by ericb on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:33PM (#17129185)
In terms of the electrification, in each case I keep seeing that the dealers are using it to check a box, but sales will push you away from them. They mostly seem to look like compliance cars. If you're seeing differently, I'm interested in links.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by twblalock on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @12:26AM (#17131469)
Most compliance cars are made by taking an existing model and shoving an electric motor under the hood and a battery in the trunk, e.g. the Fiat 500e, or those electric Toyota RAV4s that are owned by pretty much every public university's maintenance department in California. They generally have poor range and very attractive monthly lease payments.

The Chevy Bolt was designed from the ground up to be an electric car. It competes favorably with the Tesla Model 3 in most areas (except styling...) and you can go buy one today instead of joining a waiting list. The Honda Clarity and Nissan Leaf are other examples of cars specifically designed to be electric.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xapata on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:42PM (#17127857)
Where will they buy their batteries from? I'm sure Musk would like to get more focused on batteries and leave the mass-market cars to someone else.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by mhermher on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @07:47PM (#17130442)
Maybe from Panasonic, the same company Tesla gets theirs from.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Analemma_ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:46PM (#17127309)
I like this quote, because it seems to be something that TSLA bulls and bears can mostly agree on and thus gets to the heart of the actual empirical disagreements between them. For my part, I'm a Tesla skeptic because my evaluations on the likelihood of those clauses are:

> "most cars are powered by electricity in 10 years"

Unlikely. The average age of a car on the road is about 11.5 years (source: http://news.ihsmarkit.com/press-release/automotive/average-a...), so even if electric vehicle sales went to 100% tomorrow (and they won't), this wouldn't be true. It's possible fuel prices will skyrocket in the meantime and get people to scrap their ICEs, but with fracking and other deep extraction, I wouldn't bet on it.

> "most of these cars are made by Tesla"

Unlikely. Even if Tesla becomes a healthy and established carmarker, I can't imagine a situation where they are the only one selling electric cars in the late 2020's. Everyone else is getting their electric cars onto the road, and outside the HN bubble, most people are not so enamored with Tesla that they would refuse to even consider buying something else.

> "if Tesla can make those cars with sufficient margin and quality control"

Possible, but I think it's unlikely. Despite year after year of promises by Musk, Tesla still struggles with both margins and quality control, and I haven't seen any evidence that it's getting better (and there's every reason to believe it will get worse as they seem a bit desperate to scale up production)

> " if Tesla can raise additional capital sufficient to cover a $3 billion annual cash drain and another billion to service its debt."

I don't know enough about financial markets to make a solid guess here, but this seems iffy to me in light of all the other givens about Tesla, especially if markets tighten in the next few years (up until now, Tesla has had the good fortune to need cash-raising in an era of low interest rates, cheap money and bull markets. That may not be the case the next time they need capital)

Hence, I'm a bear. I don't necessarily think Tesla will go out of business, but I think their current valuation is absurd.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by durkie on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:18PM (#17127615)
>> "most cars are powered by electricity in 10 years"

> Unlikely. The average age of a car on the road is about 11.5 years (source: http://news.ihsmarkit.com/press-release/automotive/average-a...), so even if electric vehicle sales went to 100% tomorrow (and they won't), this wouldn't be true. It's possible fuel prices will skyrocket in the meantime and get people to scrap their ICEs, but with fracking and other deep extraction, I wouldn't bet on it.

I think this is extremely likely, but let's clarify: it might not be that most existing cars in 10 years will be powered by electricity, but I feel strongly that EVs will dominate new car sales. As a caveat, your 11.5 year number refers only to US cars. Oil price fluctuations are basically irrelevant at this point: EV battery pack prices are only decreasing, ranges are only increasing. Aside from that, EVs win on cost of ownership (maintenance, electricity costs), noise, and power.

>> "if Tesla can make those cars with sufficient margin and quality control"

>Possible, but I think it's unlikely. Despite year after year of promises by Musk, Tesla still struggles with both margins quality control, and I haven't seen any evidence that it's getting better (and there's every reason to believe it will get worse as they seem a bit desperate to scale up production)

Tesla's margins from Models S and X are healthy (mid 20%s). Their spending is almost entirely from capex -- which would be expected from scaling up a battery plant and new model line. Operating costs Q12018 were 1.05B (model 3 at 2k/week), operating costs Q12017 were 925M (model 3 not in production).

"Every reason to believe that [quality control] will get worse as they seem a bit desperate to scale up production" doesn't make sense?

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by pavs on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:52PM (#17127955)
Another point that I don't see that is often discussed. I think future of cars are autonomous cars that you pay monthly subscription fees to drive you around. Yes, autonomous cars still have some way to go. But since we are talking about the 10-year timeline here - it's not unreasonable to assume that fully autonomous cars will be ready by 10 years time.

If anyone, where to ask who are the top 10 autonomous carmakers, is, Tesla wouldn't be even on the top 10, because what they are selling is driver assist and ALL serious autonomous car project has LiDAR, except for Tesla. Elon is kinda hell-bent on LiDAR not needed, side of the argument.

At top of the autonomous car companies, Waymo is very far ahead of the rest of the crowd and most car companies have some kind of series side project and working on their own solutions.

There is a common consensus among (most) car manufacturers is that autonomous cars will kill the personal car industry - or at least severally constrain it. I actually think this to be true. Most car companies will find a way to adapt to this changing industry by deploying their own solution or partnering with the market leader (like Waymo). Car companies that are already struggling financially, like Tesla, will be severely affected when this change comes along.

Tesl's biggest selling point is their battery (EV), and there is nothing magical going on that other manufacturer cannot replicate a similar performance. The reason jumping on EV bandwagon right away (almost all of them have projects that are 2-3 years away if not more), is because the demand is minuscule compared to the overall market share.

There are more that one way that Tesla future doesn't look that good. They need a lot of things to go right for them to survive in the next 10 years.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by sliken on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @06:00PM (#17129766)
I don't see it mattering. Seems reasonably likely that 75% of the population will want to commute during rush hour, thus no large decrease in the number of cars needed.

So sure volume will go down, but duty cycle will go up. So instead of $35k cars that last 150k miles on average we will end up with $70k cars that last 300k or more miles.

You can be sure that in today's litigious society (at least in the USA) that unreasonable safety standards (think of the children) that will be very expensive to meet. Notice that every tesla crash is "news", yet tow trucks are quite busy with accidents of non-telsa, and ICE car fires are hardly rare.

I suspect even at 10x as safe as human drivers that people will be actively asking for more regulation and higher standards.

Seems strange that people will push for higher standards, which means higher prices, which means fewer cars, which means more road deaths. But that seems to be where we are today.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by simo7 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:02PM (#17127448)
> ...thus gets to the heart of the actual empirical disagreements between them.

I'm not sure the disagreement (between bears and bulls) is necessarily to be found in a different outlook on the future.

One can conclude all those conditions are likely to be met in the future and yet be bearish on the stock.

I'm overall optimistic on Tesla as a business, yet it seems my optimism is already fully factored in...no real upside, which is surprising given the risks.