News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by elygre on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:25PM (#17108789)
Well, maybe. From the article, the judge argued that allowing the swap would enable strategizing:

> So to allow trading would be to enable strategic behavior in future years. This would make the workings of the lottery system less clear. But it could also give an unfair advantage to students that are better at strategizing — and to students that have more resources to make good strategic decisions.

I would argue that there is a "greater good" at play, and that while this particular instance would not change anything, allowing it would open the door for future problems.

I then believe that Europeans are more willing to accept that consequence than Americans are. (YMMV, not science, just a feeling, etc) (edit: formatting the quote)

Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by lobotryas on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:31PM (#17109071)
I just don't see the judge's argument. By that logic we should only allow people who pass a rigorous certification to invest on the stock market. Casual investors should be banned because they will just lose money and that's (somehow) unfair.
Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by Tijdreiziger on Saturday May 19, 2018 @06:42PM (#17110124)
The point of the stock market is to speculate. The point of the educational system is not.
Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by IncRnd on Saturday May 19, 2018 @07:37PM (#17110333)
Exactly! So why not let more students go to the schools that are their choices (and their parents)?

From the article, "...not all schools are the same. Some schools offer music and dance classes, others offer more sports classes."

How could forcing students to speculate at non-core subjects that don't interest them (and lie beyond their talents) be better for them or for the common good?

Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by chrisbennet on Sunday May 20, 2018 @06:09AM (#17112091)
The answer to your question is in the article.
Re:Why a Dutch court stopped high school students from swapp... by IncRnd on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:26PM (#17120535)
Not an answer, a dismissal, of that question is in the article. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. It is an extraordinary claim to say that disadvantaging many is for the common good.