News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by bgribble on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:32AM (#17101269)
At my startup we pay interviewees a decent hourly consulting rate for take-home problems or full-day followup onsites (after the first interview).

We only do them when we are pretty excited about a candidate but need more information to make a hiring decision.

It's cheap, really, considering the cost of sourcing candidates and the cost of making a bad hiring decision.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by scarface74 on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:07AM (#17102049)
When I'm looking for a job, I usually have 3 or 4 strong prospects and looking back on my spreadsheets that I keep when I am looking, it usually takes about 2 weeks from the time I reach out to my network of recruiters and I have an offer (the shortest was 4 days from looking to having an offer from what was then a top 10 Fortune 500 company).

Why would I go through that trouble? I have 20+ years of experience that I can explain how I architected and developed from the website, to the middle tier, to the database to multiple VPCs on AWS and dev ops. I'm not going to do homework.

When I was first starting out I might, but living in a major metro area that's not on the west coast, there are more openings for senior devs/architects than people to fill them.

If a company wants to try me out, I'm more than willing to do a contract to perm, but my hourly rate is going to be enough to cover self employment taxes, make up for not getting paid for time off and at least two or three weeks between employment.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by danpalmer on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:15PM (#17105003)
Just to provide another perspective...

We have a take home test. It is an obviously fake problem, but we review it to the grade we would for our production code.

We don't find that candidates turn down taking the test - it's capped at 3 hours so that it can't take up lots of time. We do find that we have a low pass rate, and even among candidates with 10+ years experience, we still find candidates who write code that is just not good, and who haven't read the spec.

I'm not at all suggesting that you might be in this category, and if you can find jobs you want that don't require tests that's great.

However, there are people with plenty of experience, who can architect things brilliantly, and who can't write a ~300 line program in Python in a way that satisfies a spec or in a way that anyone would be able to maintain. That's important for many companies, and so I think tests can be one useful part of an interviewing process.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by noahc on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:54PM (#17102961)
> If a company wants to try me out, I'm more than willing to do a contract to perm, but my hourly rate is going to be enough to cover self employment taxes, make up for not getting paid for time off and at least two or three weeks between employment.

What does that number look like? 10k a week?

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by scarface74 on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:07PM (#17103071)
For a 1099 contract where I'm responsible for my own self employment taxes....

2080 - hours in a work year

-80 Paid Holidays

-120 Paid Time off

-120 Gap between employment (based on my history)

= 1760 work hours per year

FTE Salary * .028 (Employer Medicare Contribution) + $7967 (maximum social security amount - 128500*.062) = minimum salary

minimum salary/1720 hours = pay rate.

Take a reasonable salary for my market as $140,000, that is about $152000/1720 = $88.37/hour minimum.

Adjust the number based on market, skill set, and the amount of time you estimate between jobs. I'm also not taking into account health benefits that you would need to pay yourself because I'm covered under my wife, or 401K matching. I would add 4% to the hourly rate to cover 401K matching.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by walshemj on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:39PM (#17104343)
A good rule of thumb is 3x the rate you would get as a full time employee this might not be enough in the US given the high cost of health cover for a self employed person.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @10:22AM (#17101674)
I'd recommend dropping the full day onsite. I mean what the hell do you talk about for a full day? The small talk must be unbearable after the first 30 minutes.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by doorbumper on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:00AM (#17101994)
So you want a company to hire somebody after talking them for 30 minutes? Based off of what? You honestly can't imagine talking about technical software problems for more than 30 minutes? That's a pretty big red flag to me.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:03AM (#17102016)
I'm assuming you are technical yourself, otherwise please disregard. What you are unintentionally implying is that you can't spot a fraud by talking to them about your chosen profession within 30 minutes. If you can't, you shouldn't be doing the interviewing. If you can, why waste 5.5 hours of the company's time per candidate?
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by varjag on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:52PM (#17103963)
Plenty of people are great talkers about profession, big picture, architecture blabble and so on. It does not correlate with coding ability.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by taurath on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:46PM (#17104811)
Its not causation, but I'd say it correlates to being a thoughtful person. Drilling down on the architecture blabble to see how deep their understand goes will absolutely tell you whether they could code a solution.

Is there a person who claims to be a coder that has configured and launched a multi-environment microservice with several attached artifacts like DBs and queues, that knows in depth what each is doing, that can't code? At that point you're just testing whether someone has memorized syntax details that they might usually get from an IDE or a 3 second google search in regular development. I have been writing production JS for years but still have to occasionally look up Array.slice vs Array.splice parameters, especially if I haven't done a lot of data munging in a while. That may indicate to a person giving an interview that somehow I'm "faking" it, when in reality its just a momentary stall-out in my brain's lookup tables.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by varjag on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:49PM (#17105227)
> Is there a person who claims to be a coder that has configured and launched a multi-environment microservice with several attached artifacts like DBs and queues, that knows in depth what each is doing, that can't code?

Funny that you mention it. I know a person who can't shut up about microservices, Kubernetes and CI and can't code their way out of paper bag. They had no problem passing one of those interviews.

And sure rote API memorization isn't the point. But if a candidate can't code say bubblesort (or any kind of sort) in 30 minutes they are not very good at coding - and it doesn't matter if they can quote their architecture patterns by heart.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by taurath on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:10PM (#17105871)
> But if a candidate can't code say bubblesort (or any kind of sort) in 30 minutes they are not very good at coding

Thats bullshit. Sorry. Most developers will NEVER implement a generic sorting algorithm except in a code interview. You say you don't want rote API memorization, but you do want rote sort method implementation memorization. Yes you can be a system or tools developer and maybe have a higher chance of doing it, but its 99% likely even then that you just use a library for it for the language you're using, or copypastaing it from someone who's studied the specific implementation for your lang.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:28PM (#17104267)
I disagree. You aren't asking the right questions or probing enough.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by varjag on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:32PM (#17104299)
When you start probing enough it quickly becomes practical/coding interview we all come to detest. Sure enough, that way you might not even need 30 minutes. But shop talk alone doesn't cut it.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by phendrenad2 on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:25PM (#17104684)
Maybe your “shop talk” is different from mine, but I can suss out fakes from the first sentence usually. You’re correct in that they go straight for the broad architecture strokes, and they speak in vague terms. Trying to get a solid grounded answer is like trying to nail jelly to a tree. That’s when you know they just read some wikipedia articles and don’t know the practical applications of the words they’re using.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by varjag on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:54PM (#17105261)
Those have to be really clumsy then.

There's a number of people with CS or SW engineering degrees who can't actually code. Those can often quote you Gang of Four patterns, discuss broad slices of tech and draw architecture diagrams on the board. But still can't code.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by phendrenad2 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:38AM (#17106687)
I know, I work with several. I’m pretty good at spotting them because I studied them while working with them. Fun fact: if you poke in the right places, you’ll see that they don’t even understand GoF and architecture, they just regurgitate the what they memorized.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:46PM (#17106180)
I find that highly dubious. CS degrees from where?
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by rrdharan on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:43AM (#17101355)
Interesting and the first I’ve heard of this and the first confirmation I’ve heard that cost-wise it’s not egregious to do so.

It still seems strange to me to pay for throwaway work but I can also see how that’s really just my personal sentiment / bias and this is probably a pretty good and balanced approach.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by pc86 on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:59AM (#17101484)
Except some of us already have full-time jobs and don't want to spend the weekend working on quizzes, whether it's paid or not. And unless you're very generous with timing taking a day off of work can be a logistical issue, not just a pay issue.

This type of interview self-selects for people with fewer family/non-work obligations, who are willing and able to spend their free time still programming.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by pault on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:09AM (#17102063)
Sometimes you might have to inconvenience yourself to improve your career.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:56PM (#17103992)
Ya, if you paid double market rates, I'd do it. I suspect most people who do this sort of thing probably pay market or worse.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by dfee on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:17AM (#17102142)
Cost of doing business. Not willing to put in your free time? No need to worry about getting a new job.

Are you also job hunting at work, doing interviews on your employers time, etc?

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by gamblor956 on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:01PM (#17103025)
You're ignoring the context of the comment you're replying to.

That guy already has a good job. Another company is trying to poach him. Why would he, or any other qualified and gainfully employed candidate go through that unnecessary homework bullshit for a company that's trying to recruit them? The company has its priorities misplaced. They should be trying to convince the candidate to join them, not putting up barriers to their most qualified candidates.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by ryandrake on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:52PM (#17103457)
I would totally do homework bullshit for a company/opportunity/compensation that I saw as “better” than what I have currently, but would not do so for anything else.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:57PM (#17104000)
So your salary + $1? How much better? I'm curious. I'd probably go through this for maybe 50% above market rates.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by dfee on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:02PM (#17104931)
Insane. Let’s say it’s half that and you make $100k a year. You wouldn’t put in 2 hours for an extra 25k/yr?

I mean this isn’t a lottery, and hopefully you’ve reasoned there will be a high probability of getting hired; say 50%. So then the expected value of your time is $6.25k/hr.

Go, take the moral high ground, and don’t do the homework. That helps rational minded folk achieve an even higher hit rate.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by Clubber on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:01PM (#17105838)
I'm already at top dollar in my area and have been for years. Maybe that's why I despise it so, I have nothing to gain from the trouble. I haven't had to do a cold interview since 1999.

There are much better and less humiliating ways to get top dollar. Work your ass off and build reputation is the biggest one.

If you are a company and you have to call a recruiter, you're already behind. Putting people through that stuff just makes it worse.

Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by ryandrake on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:57PM (#17104505)
Not sure! I guess it depends on how much homework.
Re:Show HN: Whiteboardfree – Developer Jobs at Companies Tha... by bgribble on Friday May 18, 2018 @10:14AM (#17101616)
We aren't paying for the work-product, we're paying for the time and inconvenience. It's more to show respect for the candidate's time than to actually "hire" them to do an interview.

I mean, even "discount" recruiting platforms like Hired and Vettery will cost 5-figures when we make a hire through them, and traditional recruiters often charge 20% or more of the new-hire's first year salary. A few hundred bucks to get some more information about a prospective coworker is cheap.