News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:43AM (#17083286)
What GNU politics are you referring to that makes you reconsider using guixsd?

EDIT: Also what's unsexy about GNU? I'm really curious.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by tremon on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:31PM (#17083736)
Its refusal to package firmware binaries, for one, even if that firmware is required to have a useful machine. I'm looking at AMD specifically here, where recent graphics cards (including APU's) don't even do text-mode without the firmware.

(edit: I understand the why of it, and even agree on principle, but it still prevents me from running linux-libre on most of my systems)

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by rekado on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:27PM (#17086972)
While Linux-libre is the default for Guix there are no limitations in place that would keep you from using vanilla Linux. In fact, Guix makes it extremely easy to build custom packages, and that includes custom kernel packages.

You can augment the package collection that comes with Guix with a simple environment variable, so the insistence on software libre on the side of the project should not represent a technical hurdle.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by Digital-Citizen on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:45AM (#17089037)
I think you're probably stating this incorrectly. Are you sure you don't mean to say that Linux-libre objects to distributing nonfree firmware?

I'd guess that GNU Linux-libre project maintainers have no objection to distributing free software firmware as part of Linux-libre.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by t0nt0n on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:03PM (#17084802)
Next time you build or choose a system, consider one that can run free software.

I did, and it makes most things quite a bit easier.

Edit: I did after struggling with hw requiring nonfree blobs of different shapes and size for a couple of years. Currently I was lucky to get my hands on a system that I can run using linux-libre and the only component I have "extra" is a usb wifi card.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by dragontamer on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:48PM (#17085278)
> Next time you build or choose a system, consider one that can run free software.

The only workstation that boots with entirely free software is like, the Talos II PowerPC, with a minimum cost of $5000.

Everyone else requires a binary blob somewhere. Either a UEFI blob, BIOS blob, some kind of driver somewhere, or whatnot. Raspberry Pi, AMD, Intel, everybody.

And before the Talos II, I don't think an "Open PC" devoid of proprietary binary blobs even existed. At least, something that is reasonably modern (ie: 64-bit, decent security, decent support with modern OSes)

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by namibj on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:55PM (#17087431)
What about pre-ME thinkpads, after replacing the wifi card with an ath9k/open source firmware one? Does the intel chipset graphic require a blob for simple framebuffer/textmode operation? Because I can't remember including any blobs in the libreboot I use there, and iirc I get output before a linux kernel is able to load device firmware.

It is 64bit, and runs pretty much anything from (from what I can tell, but not sure, due to CHMPXCHG16B) Windows 10, over FreeBSD to Android. Probably even something like QNX.

Yes, you might not call this reasonably modern, but according to the hard facts you listed as qualifiers for being reasonably modern, they tick off.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by TylerE on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:43PM (#17088547)
Pretty sure that has a BIOS
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by dragontamer on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:53PM (#17093643)
Unless it is running the "coreboot BIOS" (which very few things are), then it has a binary "non-free" blob booting it up.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by namibj on Thursday May 17, 2018 @02:38PM (#17094135)
I don't remember whether the video BIOS was extracted from the old binary or if it is the open-source replacement, but I'd tend towards the latter as I don't remember searching for the backup/dump of the original firmware.

And yes, it's running coreboot, and at least CLI/linux-framebuffer arch linux works. I didn't yet get to setting the rest of the system up, but considering I bought it specifically for high-security operation, as the ME can be physically removed without loosing more than the build-in Ethernet port, I'm not pressed to do it anytime soon.

Edit: I'm pretty sure I followed [0], which leads me to the new conclusion that I did use libreboot, a more strict version of coreboot (think coreboot=Archlinux, libreboot=GNU Guix), and had to fiddle with the question whether the open-source video bios would work. This confuses me a little, as I remembered buying an X61s, not an X60s, but from the fact that it booted after flashing, I deduce it had to be an X60.

[0]: https://libreboot.org/docs/hardware/#list-of-supported-think...

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pecg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:11PM (#17083519)
GNU stands for a philosophy of freedom, thus guixsd won't provide official repositories for installing proprietary software, some users don't like it, even though they might be interested in the technological approach of the system.

GNU utilities, are not only unsexy, they are bloated and messy, and prone to failure; the GNU implementations (coreutils: grep, cat, tail, etc) of standard UNIX tools are not done with simplicity in mind.

But hey, after all GNU is Not Unix. For those of us, who really appreciate the UNIX philosophy still have OpenBSD, which is the only light in a world of chaos, in my opinion.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @03:08PM (#17085468)
> GNU utilities, are not only unsexy, they are bloated and messy, and prone to failure; the GNU implementations (coreutils: grep, cat, tail, etc) of standard UNIX tools are not done with simplicity in mind.

I've heard people say how GNU code is bloated and messy many times before, but never that they're prone to failure. I've never had any failure myself with any GNU code. Can you give some examples of failures you've experienced?

Also, I'm looking at the coreutils source right now, and it's not as messy as I was expecting. true.c is only a pageful with 80 lines, many of which are simply because of the license comment and the usage() function for --help. cat.c and tail.c also seem reasonably understandable. Biggest complaint I can make is that there's cases where spaces and tabs are mixed in the indentation, but I've long resigned myself to expect that in projects that have more than 1 major contributor.

I do, however, think that glibc and gcc are pretty messy. I tried looking for the definition of fopen() in openbsd's libc and found it in less than 30 seconds by grepping. I still haven't found glibc's. gcc seems to rely heavily on its own extensions, because I don't understand what's going on here:

    int
    main (int argc, char **argv)
    {
      toplev toplev (NULL, /* external_timer */
                     true /* init_signals */);

      return toplev.main (argc, argv);
    }
That looks like a function prototype in a function definition, but it seems to mean an assignment going by the next line. Then in toplev.c, we have:

    int
    toplev::main (int argc, char **argv)
    {
That looks like C++, but the file extension is ".c"...

You know what? Nevermind. Comparing the code for true.c and cat.c between glibc and openbsd's libc, I do rather like how clear openbsd is in its code. Damn. Sexy is a good word. Now I understand why people speak so well of it. I don't even need grep, the source file hierarchy is so clear. Looking back at GNU's true.c, I don't even understand half of what's going on there in those 80 lines, and it turns out that true.c is also the source for false.c, it just #include "true.c".

TL;DR I agree that GNU utilities are messy. I'm not sure of the bloated aspect, because I do like that utilities have internationalized documentation built-in, but that seems to be bloat by openbsd's standards. And I wouldn't know of them being prone to failure, because I never had one with them.

EDIT: Huh. I wanted to reply to Hello71, but there's no reply link under his post. Anyone know why? Anyway, yeah, I saw a comment in the file mentioning that over a line that referred to stdout. Can't check now because I'm away from the computer. I didn't really understand the reason though.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pasabagi on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @03:43PM (#17085774)
I love your post. It's really nice to watch somebody go through an honest and curious appraisal of a position.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by int0x80 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:12PM (#17086030)
It is c++. The file is .c but whatever. They use a lot of c++.

I agree with you however. Having worked with the code gnu relies a lot on macros & a lot of auto generated code. The code is a big mess, imposible to tackle if you dont spend a huge amount of time on it.

A lot of symbols are generated through #defines and pastting (X macros) so you cant grep shit for one.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by voxadam on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:46PM (#17086311)
That reminds me; I wonder how the uutils project[1] is doing. While I still haven't gotten around to giving Rust a shot I think their idea of reimplementing coreutils in the language has merit.

[1] https://github.com/uutils/coreutils

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by vthriller on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:46PM (#17086769)
> I've heard people say how GNU code is bloated and messy many times before, but never that they're prone to failure.

Just have a look at changelog for coreutils [0]. Sure it's very long, especially if you're not following its releases, sure it's full of weird edge cases that you might've never encountered (I'm certainly way too lazy to go as far as to look for those rare bugs that I stumbled upon years and years ago but there definitely were some), but this, IMO, is a great illustration of how GNU (or, rather, GNU coreutils) code is "prone to failure"—mainly because it sometimes tries to do way too much.

[0] http://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/coreutils.git/plain/NEWS

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by maskros on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:45AM (#17090819)
Since you mention 'true' ... I can't help but think of Rob Pike's diatribe https://twitter.com/rob_pike/status/966896123548872705
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pecg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:41PM (#17086742)
The most "iconic" example of failure most be the shellshock bug in bash, though the time in which it was fixed should be applauded.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by Hello71 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:02PM (#17085948)
speaking of true --help, did you know that GNU true can exit non-zero? the exact way is left as an exercise to the reader :)

(if you're actually trying it at home, remember that "true" is virtually always a builtin. AFAIK there is no legitimate way to have shell builtin true return non-zero. (overwriting the command doesn't count :P))

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:30PM (#17086187)
Huh. The reply link appeared.

Anyway, yeah, there's a commented line mentioning that:

    /* Note true(1) will return EXIT_FAILURE in the
       edge case where writes fail with GNU specific options.  */
    atexit (close_stdout);
Makes sense. If you:

    $ /bin/true --version >& -
it fails because it was not able to write what you asked it to stdout.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by josefx on Thursday May 17, 2018 @03:25AM (#17089457)
By specification it should not print anything or fail in any way http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/utilities/tr... .
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by JdeBP on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:37AM (#17090435)
You'll find that the FreeBSD and NetBSD codebases (for base) are similarly structured and similarly written.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jcoffland on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:06PM (#17083479)
It's not currently cool to like Richard Stallman because he has opinions that run contrary to Silicon Valley.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @01:07PM (#17084142)
It's because he's a dick, and not in the good way.

It's not about his opinions, it's about his ineffective and misguided leadership. Why is GNU still fighting the same battles from thirty years ago when new ones have emerged that they're not even paying attention to?

GNU is becoming the PETA of software, and it's not a good look.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by rekado on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:44PM (#17087063)
> GNU is becoming the PETA of software, and it's not a good look.

As a GNU hacker (and co-maintainer of GNU Guix) statements like this make me sad. It is very unfortunate that Richard Stallman's personality is casting a shadow on the GNU project, which was started by him but is really a loose connection of projects that share ideas that were outlined in the GNU Manifesto.

I see GNU Guix in the tradition of other GNU software like Emacs or the Hurd that aim to give users more power and to remove arbitrary limitations. Emacs is probably the epitome of a hackable system that lets the user shape the software according to their own needs to an extend that is extreme and rarely found in any other system.

The Hurd aims to allow regular users to do things that in traditional Unices requires super-user privileges. It aims to remove arbitrary obstacles to free users from the unhealthy power dynamics of the user/admin division.

Guix gives users powerful tools to manage their software environments without having to beg admins, and to easily package software variants without having to depend on professional distributors. At the same time no user can harm another user on shared systems. Guix gives users the ability to take advantage of software freedom, by making it really easy to hack on software in a user-controlled reliable system.

When seen from this perspective, the GNU system that individual software projects are contributing to is a collection of tools that liberate users from helplessness due to unnecessary restrictions. This common goal defines the modern GNU project these days, and I think it is very unfortunate to overlook this because of Richard Stallman and his quirks, his sometimes dictatorial style, or his harmful attitudes towards important social aspects of free software.

I appreciate Richard's past work immensely, but I do not consider him representative of the GNU project that I work on, nor do I think his leadership style is benefiting the project.

Give GNU a chance based on the project's merits and its goals. Long live Free Software --- copyleft and non-copyleft alike!

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Thursday May 17, 2018 @02:21PM (#17093957)
I've got some simple advice: Get rid of RMS. Get rid of him now.

The longer he's the figurehead of GNU, the longer he has any say in your projects, the longer he'll poison the well. This "joke" fiasco touched off a firestorm of commentary from people that are quite clear that he's been highly problematic for decades now.

You don't want someone toxic running GNU. Microsoft managed to shed their sweaty gorilla and look what's happened to them. They're not fully redeemed, but they stopped fighting and destroying.

Just as the early FSF cared not for tradition, for history, for the investment of time and energy on the part of others, they should not care today if they want to be a radical force for change. Keep that spirit. Tear down anything worth destroying because it gets in the way of what's right.

The important question, the only question, for an organization that promotes actual change is what can he do to improve things tomorrow.

Sadly we've lost Aaron Swartz, but that's the caliber of person you need today. Fearless, energetic, passionate, and fighting the right fights from the front lines. Aaron will be missed, but the FSF and GNU should be looking for, encouraging, motivating the next Aarons no matter what their background is.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:15PM (#17088177)
They're fighting the same battle, because it's still on and they haven't won.

I'm still wishing for a world where all electronics hardware and software is open source. Can't really visualize an industry like that be economically functional, but I hope someone does. My hope is with GNU.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Thursday May 17, 2018 @02:30PM (#17094036)
Imagine if we were still fighting battles from the 19th century, that Prussia was still exchanging musket fire with France.

That's what GNU is doing today with their stubborn fights about licensing when there's far bigger problems emerging.

How about a right to privacy? How about a right to timely patches for their Linux-based phones? How about a right to repair hardware running GPL software? How about a right to know if your device has security faults?

I can make software that mines the personal emails of dissidents, runs facial recognition on hacked webcams, and ruins lives, and that's all fine as far as GNU's concerned so long as I give out the source code to anyone who asks.

That seems...problematic.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by JdeBP on Friday May 18, 2018 @07:57AM (#17100679)
Richard Stallman on privacy, surveillance, corporate abuse of technology, and Android.

* https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/03/facebo...

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/surveillance-testimony.html

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/surveillance-vs-democracy.htm...

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/judge-internet-usage.html

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/the-danger-of-ebooks.html

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/stallmans-law.html

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/android-and-users-freedom.htm...

So your position is that GNU should both get rid of Richard Stallman and start addressing this stuff. Clearly, you are not basing this upon Richard Stallman addressing these very things for quite a few years now via the GNU WWW site.

* https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/essays-and-articles.html

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:05PM (#17121824)
He presents these in the most tin-foil hat manner possible and doesn't build a bridge to people trying to live ordinary lives.

Destroying your phone, not using a web browser, and eating vegan or whatever isn't something everyone can or should do.

If he wants to be some obscure mountain-top philosopher, that's fine, but being the GNU head at the same time is problematic.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by t0nt0n on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @01:56PM (#17084730)
What new battles have emerged that GNU and FSF are not paying attention to?

Also, GNU is not RMS, and RMS is not GNU.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pasabagi on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @03:53PM (#17085875)
I know that RMS is not GNU, but the man is a raging egomaniac - and the way he talks takes credit for basically everything he's come into contact with. Unless I'm underestimating the bounds of possibility for one person's contributions, he uses 'I' in a lot of places it would be fair to say 'we'.

(Note, I came to this conclusion after reading about a bunch of his technical accomplishments, which I can see are awesome, even if the obvious megalomania evidently occasionally dampens their effects.

I think his work is fantastic, his politics are largely reasonable - but I think his self-obsession is often the driver behind a large amount of damaging and counterproductive behaviour.

Politics is the art of compromise - not convincing everybody you're a saint while alienating your natural allies.)

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by rauhl on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:11AM (#17090314)
In fairness, he’s correct that Linux is better called GNU/Linux: a Linux kernel really is useless without the GNU userland.

I’m not a fan of him personally, and many of his technical decisions have been questionable, but he’s achieved a lot, and the world is better for the FSF’s existence.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pasabagi on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:26AM (#17090378)
I'm not sure. Isn't Android proof of a sort that Linux is still worth something without GNU?

I wouldn't have any problem with the 'GNU/Linux' idea if it wasn't so obviously part of a greater pattern - when he talks about it, he talks about GNU being the primary contributor - but he typically uses the singular, even when the plural would refer to GNU, and the singular refers to himself.

I also think the world is better for the FSF, but I cant help but wonder, what would the world be like if the FSF was headed by somebody who felt it more natural to think in terms of 'we', as opposed to 'I'? Even somebody not nearly as technically accomplished, charismatic, and intelligent? I think ultimately, it's the ideas, of knowledge as the common wealth of humankind, rather than the curious personality of RMS, that gave the GNU project its power - and ultimately, it's the limitations of RMS that hold it back.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jcoffland on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:36PM (#17092880)
> Isn't Android proof of a sort that Linux is still worth something without GNU?

Not at all. Android depends on tons of GNU software.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by ChristianBundy on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:20PM (#17084998)
The FSF is (or seems to be) an extension of RMS, and the same argument could be made for GNU[0].

[0]: https://lwn.net/SubscriberLink/753646/a6ebb50040c5862c/

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:20PM (#17085003)
While they were harassing Linksys about GPL the whole IoT thing happened and now we're living in a world full of trashy Linux-based devices that are a hazard to society. Sure, you can get the source code to your internet-based webcam, but because it can't be easily patched, it can also be hijacked by a couple of high-school kids in Alaska so they can sabotage their Minecraft server hosting competitors.

So good job.

As long as RMS is such a prominent figure the GNU/FSF organization there's no separation.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by elago on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:46PM (#17085258)
"the whole IoT thing" was ever Stallman's responsibility to stop in the first place?

he wants to champion free software, not every just cause under the sun.

IoT devices shipping with insecure configurations is a "failure" of an infosec champion/thought-leader to step up and save us.

On the free software front, RMS contribution are mind blowing to me. I'd be proud if I can ever contribute a fraction of what he did.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:25PM (#17086634)
The contributions of the GNU team are considerable. RMS in particular? Eh.

The IoT thing was a perfect opportunity to step in, step up, and show some leadership. Billions of devices owned by tens or hundreds of millions of people, all running open-source software!

Instead we get this miserable hell because of his laser focus on licensing instead of responsible software.

Infosec, to their credit, were raising alarm bells from the beginning but nobody had to listen to them because they don't control anything.

GNU, however, does. If they'd extended GPL to include provisions for ensuring that the GPL software on it can be updated in a timely and secure manner, life would be a lot better for people.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by mindB on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @08:46PM (#17087678)
Isn't that exactly what v3 of the GPL does?
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:27PM (#17087928)
That just prevents the vendor from locking down the software. It doesn't force them to update it in a timely manner.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by pxc on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:48PM (#17088336)
And if the software weren't locked down, anyone (users, communities, other vendors) could step in to provide such updates. That's not some hypothetical, either— compare the rates of OS updates in projects like LineageOS to to the distributions of Android shipped with most phones. If vendors couldn't TiVo-ize, there would absolutely be communities and downstream vendors stepping in to provide devices with regular updates. Because the devices are locked down, that can't happen.

And what do you expect the FSF to do? Out-lobby consumer electronics manufacturers to pass laws requiring some kind of security update guarantee? Even if they succeeded, could we call the result empowerment? Getting out from under the thumb of the manufacturer and actually _owning_ the things you own is the point, not the theoretical promise of recourse if the party which practically retains all of their power over you can be proven in court to have misbehaved, only after the abuse has taken place.

This is absolutely the same fight, and if anything the approach you're arguing for is more conciliatory, not more ‘relevant’.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:24PM (#17096037)
Theoretically being able to update your device and actually being able to update your device are two different things.

There's going to be a billion variants on every little IoT device in the future and all the best intentions and enthusiasm on the part of the free software community will not be enough to provide patches to all of them.

This is something that's the responsibility of the vendor, and the GNU software license could make that a requirement for using the software.

It's not about laws, it's about licensing. If they don't like the license they're free to use someone else's software.

Having inexpensive operating system software you can dump on a cheap device without license fees is both a great thing, and also what got us into this IoT hot mess.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:52AM (#17091765)
Force them? It's a license. People use them to grant rights not give themselves obligations.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by orangeshark on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @03:27PM (#17085629)
Isn't that what GPL v3 is suppose to cover with what they call "tivoization"? They tried to get the Linux kernel to switch to the GPL v3 but that failed.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:21PM (#17092703)
How is that not purely, 1000% on the makers of the shitty webcams?
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:26PM (#17097106)
They're compelled to give out the source code, but apart from that they can do pretty much anything else they want with GNU's blessing.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by ronsor on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:10PM (#17083508)
Stallman is generally not a very... tactful person.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by seba_dos1 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:26PM (#17083676)
That's right, it might even hurt his mission, but it doesn't make him less right.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by astrodust on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @01:08PM (#17084163)
Was he right about abortion jokes?

David Bowie made predictions far more profound than Stallman, and they came from a place of genuine concern, not tin-foil hattery of the GNU variety: https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/11/10753158/david-bowie-inte...

I'd rather have people that cared and were on the right path, picking the right battles, than assholes who are technically correct but their observations are ultimately irrelevant to the larger fight.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by M_Bakhtiari on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:05AM (#17089839)
I don't get the abortion joke debacle. It was blatantly pro-abortion, yet it seems like it's only the pro-abortion people that are upset about it.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by JdeBP on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:46AM (#17090485)
That's because you erroneously think that the conflict was about abortion. It was actually about whether user reference manuals should properly contain jokes about such highly politically charged topics.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by kiriakasis on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:59PM (#17084047)
As an outside observer it looks like GNU is conducting an ideological battle that is decreasing in public relevance in the years and so, now, it looks like they are the one not being good neighbours.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by Digital-Citizen on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:59AM (#17089091)
It wouldn't have taken much more time for you to back your point with examples so we'd have some idea of what you're talking about. Please also explain the ideology of how proprietary software is not worth fighting with a practical implementation and ethical discussion.

Most of the time when people object to GNU or rms they fail to convey that they understand what software freedom is or how continually relevant software freedom is today. I'd bet that the majority of threads on these (overwhelmingly corporate) repeater sites are easily handled by stressing how important a user's software freedom is. Every DRM, proprietary software (Windows ignores user settings, this new device from $VENDOR spies on its users, etc.) is easily dismissed by getting into the same discussion about how software freedom would allow the user to alter the software, protect their privacy, treat their friends and neighbors better by sharing improved versions of the software, inspect and modify the software (or have someone they trust do it for them), and run the programs when they want (instead of losing access when a proprietor feels like ending "support"). Snowden readily credits free software for his success in leaking sensitive NSA documents to us all (docs which still make media stories years later). Three cheers for software freedom, rms, and Snowden!

Posts like the parent post tell me sites like these are the thing losing relevance by showing how ineffective public moderation is and how unacceptable it is to dare to say something not echoed in corporate tech media.

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by computerfriend on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:29PM (#17088245)
I'm not sure how anyone can honestly think that the ideological battle is decreasing in public relevance. It is massively more relevant now.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jpeg_hero on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:27PM (#17083693)
It starts with that weird ink drawing of a goat for a logo, it just screams “70’s green screen”

And this is coming from a genx open source / Linux guy. What it must look like to the current generation?!?!

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by keypress on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @03:42PM (#17085768)
Isn't it a gnu? I like the logo/art.
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:37PM (#17086241)
Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by peterwwillis on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:08PM (#17084863)
> Also what's unsexy about GNU?

"Gnu's Not Unix": A recursive acronym used as a pun about an operating system from the 1970s, existing solely as a reflection of an aging neckbearded hippie hacker's personal philosophy about software, that is pronounced "GUH-NEW".

Re:Tarballs, the ultimate container image format by jolmg on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:10PM (#17086534)
I don't think it's only his philosophy. In fact, before, I would have thought that personal philosophy to be common sense, but it then turns out it isn't. It still bewilders me how it's the status quo that when you buy an expensive piece of electronics, it's never really yours to use as you please. It's more like the companies are lending it to you for a one-time payment. They keep full control. If they want to remove features[1] or brick the product you bought from them[2] or place arbitrary restrictions on features that require no work from them and then charge extra for lifting the restrictions[3], it's totally ok. How does that make sense? Yet it's the dystopia the industry has been turning into day by day, and it's all made possible because of closed source software.

[1] - https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20100331/0128358800.shtml

[2] - https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150321/13350230396/while...

[3] - One example of this could be Amazon's ridiculous rental of digital books, since it can only work by downloading the file to your device and then charging you more for it to prevent your device from deleting it. Another example is YouTube Red, to be able to download videos the app already downloads for free anyway to be able to stream, and also so that it won't pause videos when you move the android app to the background.