Also think I found a good domain for it that I'll snag tonight as well.
Here are some more ideas: https://github.com/Kickball/awesome-selfhosted#social-networ...
Flarum looks like a worthwhile option: http://flarum.org/
There's also Talkyard. It's a bit like Discourse, and has Slack chat features (maybe nice with informal chat channels?) and StackOverflow like Q&A topics. I'm developing it. Open source & beta. https://www.talkyard.io/forum/
So HN doesn't count?
And if you come to the cafe an hour too late, because it was night in your time zone — then it's empty already.
(Explanation: 1) At HN, if you reply to someone a bit later, s/he will never notice, because there are no reply notifications, and in his/her comments & replies list, your comment will get buried far down below other comments s/he has posted, and others' replies. And 2) if you visit a topic that is some days old, and you post a comment — no one will ever see it. Because there's no way for other people, to find the most recent comments (your comment) that have appeared since they were there the last time. Here's a way to fix that?: https://www.talkyard.io/-32/how-hacker-news-can-be-improved-... )
Also, there are all the components of user profiles/messaging/signatures/etc that HN completely omits (which is totally fine, but something forums are known for that HN probably will never have).
This. This is the element the 'modern web' has forgotten in its rush to 'new', 'realtime' and 'current' content.
Just because a conversation happened weeks (or months, or years) ago doesn't mean it's not relevant now. Google search results appear to favour 'fresh' over 'stale'; yet it doesn't say the content is any better, or more useful to me.
Hacker news has some awesome threads and knowledgeable people, but the threads and comments are buried in the archive. Add a comment to an old thread and no one reads it or responds. Which is the HN community's loss.
Blog comments were another: I had discussions that spanned multiple years, as people found it of interest and joined in. Because I wrote for engagement, not for pageviews.
Unless people regain a sense of place in time and realise that immediate doesn't trump everything else, I don't see us going back to longer-term discussions.
I'll get a Show HN going tomorrow!
Usenet was like every HN, phpBB, digg, slashdot, and reddit in one. I await those days again.
I've tweaked it a bunch, but I'm sure there's a lot more to do. Please take a look if you're still following this HN thread...I'll post a Show HN in the morning for this.
I also have a post with my notes from setting this thing up...suffice to say that DigitalOcean's 1 click installer requires a few more clicks...
Unfortunately, without community features it feels like slipping notes into a bottle and tossing them into the sea.
HN is the restaurant at the end of the internet.
I'll post a Show HN when it's ready.
I'll get a Show HN going tomorrow!
BTW, I'd strongly, strongly discourage vBulletin.
Since we're reminiscing, unless I have you mistaken for someone else, I suspect that we both may have been a part of the same community way back when. Regardless, I look forward this; sounds like it could be fun.
Ninja edit: wording
I’ll announce it here when it’s ready!
Maybe it's because rhe demo instance was reset way to often or something but I've never really seen a really working discourse instance. (I think both Mozilla and Canonical (has?) run one but they weren't to active either IIRC.
Anyone has examples of a working discourse community?
But indeed I remember the days on vBulletin forums; all my remarks against ‘you cannot make friends over 30’ that I uttered here come from there: most my current friends and one of my best friends I met on forums. It just worked well.
Maybe except trolling.
Human moderation always wins out over technical solutions and elitism.
You can also have privileged threads/subforums that are read only if you don't meet some requierments.
You can even have an option to only show comments/posts for users with karma > N, if thats what you want.
Why don’t we just start a forum for the HN crowd? Not a new interpretation of the forum model or anything like that, literally any instance of vbulletin or phpbb or something comparable and “traditional”.
If people are genuinely interested in this, I would be up for spinning something up over the weekend.