News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by kodablah on Sunday May 13, 2018 @09:30AM (#17058792)
> despite efforts from Microsoft to move on to the more modern Edge.

Then allow me to use Edge as a Windows control a la MSHTML in a non-UWP app. It's like if Chrome were suddenly made close source and non-embeddable and then Google complaining about insecure Electron apps.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by chrismorgan on Sunday May 13, 2018 @09:55AM (#17058905)
Your analogy is imperfect; for MSHTML and EdgeHTML are first-party, while Electron is third-party; and it’s not just MSHTML that Microsoft are pushing people away from, but the entire Win32 API—Microsoft’s been saying, use WinRT instead, and you can have EdgeHTML there. Notably, Microsoft has been steadily stepping back from this vision in the last few years, and EdgeHTML is expected to be exposed to Win32 apps at some point (the impression I have is that it is expected sooner rather than later).

It’s a nuisance that it isn’t already there, but it is coming.

Note also that Chromium isn’t embeddable on its own; it’s only because it’s open source that anything has been able to embed it at all. It has no stable API, so CEF has to wrap it and shed some functionality to ensure it’ll keep working across more than just a few releases of Chromium, as changes are made therein. The Electron project basically builds itself inside Chromium instead, see https://electronjs.org/blog/electron-internals-building-chro....

But really, IE has enough things needing it that removing it outright isn’t an option yet, and won’t be for quite a few years. I can imagine in a few years’ time not installing IE by default, and making the MSHTML widget actually be EdgeHTML instead if IE’s not installed, but even that I expect would break quite a bit of software. And Microsoft cares a lot about not breaking compatibility. It’ll be interesting to see what they do about it.

(You may well know these points already, kodablah; I’m providing them as much for background for others reading as for you.)

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by kodablah on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:12AM (#17058971)
Sure the analogy is imperfect. I also don't have a perfect analogy for a browser vendor hobbling its newer product. But I'm just appealing to common sense wrt not addressing an extremely common use of something yet wanting that something to stop being used.

I personally don't think they should implement the MSHTML/COM APIs with Edge any more than I think they should implement ActiveX on Edge. The old tech can die its slow death, so long as there is a viable replacement.

Selfishly, I want this for https://github.com/zserge/webview to watch Electron adoption decrease or even an API-compat version using shared libs already on the system.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by cptskippy on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:01AM (#17059232)
It's less about hobbling Edge and more about compelling you to not use Win32 while keeping you stuck in Windows. Win32 needs to die and Microsoft is doing everything it can to kill it while not completely pissing off those that rely upon it.

Part of the problem is that if they force everyone to rewrite Win32 native apps then what's stopping them from just going to MacOS or something else?

They want everyone off Win32 but still locked into Windows.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by userbinator on Sunday May 13, 2018 @12:17PM (#17059655)
I'm pretty sure it's not going away, especially because the newer more bloated stuff they're trying to push is built on top of it, and that's not going to change unless MS decides to start officially documenting the native NTAPI.

They day they get rid of Win32 is the day I switch completely to Linux+WINE or even ReactOS.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by cptskippy on Sunday May 13, 2018 @01:54PM (#17060069)
Such as? Products like Office have undergone significant refactoring to remove reliance on Win32. They have something like over 90% code reuse between Office apps on MacOS, OSX, Android, Win32, and Xaml.

With every release of Windows 10, more and more GDI and Win32 is replaced.

Part of the MinWin project was to extricate Win32 from the kernel and have a true separation.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by userbinator on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:58PM (#17061253)
For example, .NET framework calls into Win32 CreateFile when opening a file:

https://referencesource.microsoft.com/#mscorlib/microsoft/wi...

Products like Office have undergone significant refactoring to remove reliance on Win32.

Then what are they using instead? Whatever it is, how does it provide the basic functions? Does it call into native NT API directly?

Part of the MinWin project was to extricate Win32 from the kernel and have a true separation.

What? Win32 is not part of the kernel, it's a layer on top of the native NT API (or VMM32, if you remember Win9x...)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Architecture_of_Windows_NT

https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/X86_Disassembly/Microsoft_Wind...

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by cptskippy on Sunday May 13, 2018 @08:11PM (#17061781)
> Then what are they using instead? Whatever it is, how does it provide the basic functions? Does it call into native NT API directly?

They use a PAL, each platform has it's own PAL and the Windows Kernel as two (WinRT and Win32).

https://www.zdnet.com/article/how-microsoft-is-taking-on-the...

> What? Win32 is not part of the kernel, it's a layer on top of the native NT API (or VMM32, if you remember Win9x...)

It wasn't. When WinNT hit the scene in the 90s there was definitely a distinction between Userland and Kernel space but by XP there was so much encroachment. MinWin was the creation of horizontal layers of separation.

https://betanews.com/2009/12/02/mark-russinovich-on-minwin-t...

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by userbinator on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:16PM (#17062223)
Both those articles are heavy on marketing and light on detail, but if the PAL they're talking about is anything like the one described here...

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/12/how-a...

...the "PAL" is basically the Win32 libraries with a different interface on the other side (in some ways, like WINE), so no, Win32 is not going away.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by cptskippy on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:31AM (#17065850)
> Both those articles are heavy on marketing and light on detail

And? Does that somehow invalidate my arguement? The Betanews article is an interview with Mark Russinovich, the Chief Technology Officer for Azure at Microsoft. And as the article says, Microsoft has been making a concerted effort to extricate Win32 from the Kernel and making it an isolated Subsystem as it originally was.

> The principal division of labor in Win32 has historically been vertical, not horizontal, dividing core system kernel functions from "user" input and interactive functions, from graphics and display functions. Even though Windows architecture has evolved to the point where the whole graphics part is essentially deprecated for modern apps, GDI32.DLL is presumed to be present.

The zdnet article is based off a presentation that Microsoft gave at CppCon talking about how they made Microsoft Office Cross Platform. The PAL concept is similar to the HAL in Windows but specific to Office. They very well could have created different PALs that implemented the Win32 API but they didn't.

There are two versions of Office for Windows, one implemented using Win32 and one using WinRT/UWP. The former is mostly around because Microsoft is still supporting versions of Windows prior to 8.

WinRT on Windows 8 actually is a wrapper on top of Win32 but what does that matter?

> if the PAL they're talking about is anything like the one described here... > ...the "PAL" is basically the Win32 libraries with a different interface on the other side (in some ways, like WINE), so no, Win32 is not going away.

So you ask if Drawbridge is the PAL used in Office and then you state that it is in fact the same thus proving that Win32 isn't going away? Drawbridge was born out of a Microsoft Research project in 2011, the talk about Office's PAL is from 2007 and describes something different.

You also didn't bother to read your own article because it states that SQL's PAL emulates about 1% of Win32 API, just enough to run SQL Server and their goal is to remove internal abstractions and merge down all code just above the host extension layer. In other words, get rid of Win32 emulation and the SQLOS abstractions.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by chrismorgan on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:19PM (#17062232)
Amusingly, I’m the one that filed https://github.com/zserge/webview/issues/85!
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by ngold on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:25PM (#17061128)
So are you pro or anti open source? It seems both have their challenges. But only one can be addressed by outsiders.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by pjc50 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:37PM (#17061175)
This isn't all that relevant on Windows.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by microcolonel on Monday May 14, 2018 @02:54AM (#17063324)
Well, that's true if the problems aren't with the platform's browser, though in this case you would probably just ship a CEF or WebKit2-based runtime to replace MSHTML/EdgeHTML.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by setquk on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:58AM (#17059220)
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by kodablah on Sunday May 13, 2018 @12:09PM (#17059612)
Looking for a dead simple cpp example if anyone knows of one.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by bartread on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:54AM (#17059198)
Not to mention, Microsft, please fix the keyboard event latency in Edge[1]. It makes anything vaguely interactive, especially games, nigh on unusable, unless you particularly enjoy dying on a regular basis because the browser took 300ms to notice you'd pressed a key.

[1] Notably not a problem that affects Internet Explorer, nor (obviously) Firefox, Chrome or Safari.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by setquk on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:56AM (#17059210)
They just did this. Latest release is actually usable as of the April 2018 windows 10 build (1803). Was quite surprised.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by bartread on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:59AM (#17059223)
Thanks - will give it another go! Would be amazing to have that work properly since, otherwise, Edge performs and works well.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by setquk on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:00AM (#17059230)
Yep. I’ve decided to give it a try for a couple of weeks. I think I lasted a day on the last release before quitting.

The new one also has reasonably sized UI elements ie smaller.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by jnxx on Sunday May 13, 2018 @02:16PM (#17060167)
Modern computers have about five times more latency as an Apple IIe:

https://danluu.com/input-lag/

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by pcf on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:05AM (#17059258)
As a Mac user – how on earth could MS have a keyboard latency for so long? Seems very unprofessional.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by zeusk on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:49AM (#17059520)
> As a Mac user – how on earth could MS have a keyboard latency for so long? Seems very unprofessional.

A) It doesn't matter you're a "mac user".

B) It's a technical fault, not "unprofessional"

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by bartread on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:17AM (#17059322)
It's certainly been in there for as long as I've been using Windows 10; not sure about before that. It was super-frustrating because it affected both keyDown and keyUp, and it was also completely inconsistent.

I can, however, if I squint, just about see the argument for why it's taken so long to fix: I suspect it probably wasn't seen as that valuable for the kind of apps and sites that Microsoft think people mostly use the web for. Thing is, get off the beaten path slightly, and you find people using the web for all kinds of interesting and creative things: demos, games, music players and editors, emulators, synthesizers and instruments, image and video manipulation.

And there is a school of thought (to which I don't belong) that says all apps should run in the browser. But if that's ever going to happen, massive and inconsistent input latency of any kind is not something that can be tolerated. Even if we don't go that far, and I suspect we won't, there are still a wide range of web apps for which unpredictable input latency is not acceptable.

So I suppose what I'm saying in a very long winded-way, is that I agree it shouldn't have been there for so long, although I don't think I'd call it unprofessional.

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by poizan42 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:27AM (#17059048)
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by kodablah on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:36AM (#17059097)
I saw this as part of https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/cpp-and-winrt-a... (and the previous cppwinrt github project) but I haven't dug too deeply. I wonder if the restrictions are too limiting. Any bare-bones win32 example of using it in a simple cpp file? I plan on doing a poc myself soon.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by mastax on Sunday May 13, 2018 @02:04PM (#17060118)
Using WinRT stuff in a Win32 app is quite simple. Add windowsapp.lib, #include "winrt/Windows.Foundation.h", and call winrt::init_apartment();. There's no easy way to embed Xaml controls, though. I think the only option would be to have a separate Xaml window, get its HWND, and SetWindowLong+SetParent to force it to be a child window.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by poizan42 on Monday May 14, 2018 @02:41AM (#17063252)
There's this: Walkthrough: Hosting WPF Content in Win32[0]

That does use C++/CLI though, but I'm sure you can play around with the embedded api if you really want a pure C++ solution.

[0] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/framework/wpf/advanc...

Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by mastax on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:50AM (#17074868)
WPF ≠ UWP XAML, which is what the EdgeHTML control is.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by poizan42 on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:14AM (#17099870)
Well, the controls in question here are WPF and WinForms hosts for UWP controls, so if you can host WPF then you can use the UWP host control to host UWP content. Yeah, its a bit roundabouts, but I think it is the only supported way right now.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by userbinator on Sunday May 13, 2018 @12:13PM (#17059635)
As a long-time IE (and Chromium, Firefox, and Opera --- I don't really have any particular "allegiance" with browsers --- I have two of those open at the moment with different sites) user, what really makes me refuse to use Edge the most is the dumbed-down UI. I'd be perfectly happy if they took its rendering engine and put it in the "normal" IE UI, and kept all the configurability too.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by pjc50 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:41PM (#17061190)
Edge has a number of deficiencies (font rendering, failure to take tabs seriously) that make it unsatisfactory.
Re:Internet Explorer zero-day by hb3b on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:30AM (#17059400)
And allow it to be installed on Server for purposes of RDS.