Back when I did it, I had two friends that did it with me. One of them got cognitive benefits like I did while the other did not. It might be that we were deficient in or sensitive to something else. In fact the energy was so boundless at the 2-week mark that we actually had a hard time falling asleep at night.
It worked well over couple of months. Actually, I found the chart I made then:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/vdlgazsfjjbqkox/weight-2012.png?dl...
(Measurements are blue, running average (of AFAIR a week) is green. I used the running average as an indicator of progress, to eliminate measurement noise / daily variations.)
That ~8-10kg drop in 3 months is when I was on ketogenic diet. I carried it a bit longer, then I guess at some point I just decided I miss pizza too much. One permanent change this caused though, that I have to this day, is that I switched from sugar to artificial sweeteners in my tea/coffee, and always opt for sugarfree coke/pepsi instead of the regular one.
Following your conversation I have a wild guess...you likely were not exercising and therein likely was.
First, I’ve never meet anyone who did some form of working out/exercising who couldn’t tell if they were in ketosis (good or bad).
If I am right, this may also explain the feeling of mental clarity therein experiences that you didn’t. Glucose is fuel for the brain, but fat isn’t...ketones are which are a by product of fat burning, so the more fat burning/ketones the more fuel for the brain.
Interesting if you both chime in on my theory.
> Glucose is fuel for the brain, but fat isn’t...ketones are which are a by product of fat burning, so the more fat burning/ketones the more fuel for the brain.
That definitely makes sense to me and would even to a certain extent explain the difference between individual experiences with ketogenic diet.