Back when I did it, I had two friends that did it with me. One of them got cognitive benefits like I did while the other did not. It might be that we were deficient in or sensitive to something else. In fact the energy was so boundless at the 2-week mark that we actually had a hard time falling asleep at night.
It worked well over couple of months. Actually, I found the chart I made then:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/vdlgazsfjjbqkox/weight-2012.png?dl...
(Measurements are blue, running average (of AFAIR a week) is green. I used the running average as an indicator of progress, to eliminate measurement noise / daily variations.)
That ~8-10kg drop in 3 months is when I was on ketogenic diet. I carried it a bit longer, then I guess at some point I just decided I miss pizza too much. One permanent change this caused though, that I have to this day, is that I switched from sugar to artificial sweeteners in my tea/coffee, and always opt for sugarfree coke/pepsi instead of the regular one.
Following your conversation I have a wild guess...you likely were not exercising and therein likely was.
First, I’ve never meet anyone who did some form of working out/exercising who couldn’t tell if they were in ketosis (good or bad).
If I am right, this may also explain the feeling of mental clarity therein experiences that you didn’t. Glucose is fuel for the brain, but fat isn’t...ketones are which are a by product of fat burning, so the more fat burning/ketones the more fuel for the brain.
Interesting if you both chime in on my theory.
> Glucose is fuel for the brain, but fat isn’t...ketones are which are a by product of fat burning, so the more fat burning/ketones the more fuel for the brain.
That definitely makes sense to me and would even to a certain extent explain the difference between individual experiences with ketogenic diet.
No. You are hungry, not necessarily for carb or protein or fat, you're just hungry. If you wait long enough, your body will switch to burn body fat.
Even after knowing that my body has switched to primarily using ketones via Ketone Measurement Strips used on urine daily, I would find myself wanting to eat something, but once I realized all I had at home that I could eat was food full of fat and protein but not carbs, my craving would disappear or I would become disinterested.
And even after eating, I could still feel that it didn't hit the right spot at satisfying my cravings. I would be really full, and really full of energy-dense food but I would still be dreaming of a slice of bread or even a sip of lemonade next to whatever dish I am eating. I realized what I craved wasn't food but that spike in blood sugar.
It made me realize, often when we say we are hungry and we are craving something, it's not that we are hungry, it's that we are craving carbs.