News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by hennsen on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:14AM (#17052894)
How is nuclear power „clean“ with all the radioactive waste that needs to go somewhere when burnt down?
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by krastanov on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:22AM (#17052913)
When the used fuel rods are properly stored, even the primitive nuclear reactors we use today release quite a bit less radiation than burning coal (not event mentioning CO2 and so on). Even after including all major nuclear accidents, nuclear plants have saved lives compared to coal plants (and they have pretty good track record when compared against even renewable sources).

However, storing the fuel rods properly is borderline impossible due to politics, so your questions probably still stands.

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by hennsen on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:57AM (#17052982)
I admit i don’t know much about the coal burning radiation output. And im even further away from knowing the perfect solution to the worlds energy needs. So i have many questions, driven by the wish to live in a intact environment and leaving it to those who come in a good state.

Where and how exactly is the radiation release of coal plants happening? I can imagine its maybe a difference if a smaller dose of radiation is put out slowly and spread more (in time and space terms)than if it’s concentrated on one point? Radiaton is anywhere thats clear... but we rarely get strong radiation caused illnesses from just catching cosmic radiation do we?

And how exactly are politics preventing proper storage?

I definitely don’t wanna promote coal, but where are these numbers proving coal killed and harmed more people than Fukushima and Tchernobyl and the many smaller incidents?

Also i often wonder - where could science of reusable energy and reduced consumption be if the billions invested in nuclear research were invested there instead?

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by sjwright on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:24AM (#17053050)
> numbers proving coal killed and harmed more people than Fukushima

The number of people who died from the radiation which escaped during the Fukishima nuclear disaster is currently zero.[0] Even factoring in the worst-case projections for every nuclear energy disaster, nuclear power is still the safest—or certainly one of the safest—forms of utility-scale electricity generation.

If you're looking for a form of energy which is normally safe but kills thousands in a disaster scenario, the answer is hydro. In one instance, a dam failure killed 171,000 people.

Solar panel installers and wind turbine workers occasionally die from falls. (Also, solar panel manufacturing can be a dirty/toxic process.)

Fossil fuels (coal, oil, gas, biomass) kill because miners, workers and citizens breathe in coal dust and smoke particulates belched into the atmosphere.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by jabl on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:53AM (#17053115)
> Where and how exactly is the radiation release of coal plants happening?

Coal plants don't burn pure elemental carbon, the black stuff that is dug up from the ground contains a lot of other stuff as well, such as sulphur (acid rain, etc.), and, yes, various radionuclides. So when the coal is burned, part of the radionuclides go up the smokestack, others are left in the ash.

Realistically, compared to all the other environmental destruction associated with coal power, the radioactivity release is a non-issue. At the same time, it's good to keep in mind that except for major disasters like Chernobyl, an operating coal plant releases orders of magnitude more radioactivity to the environment than an operating nuclear plant.

> I definitely don’t wanna promote coal, but where are these numbers proving coal killed and harmed more people than Fukushima and Tchernobyl and the many smaller incidents?

You cannot usually say that person X died due to coal power production (except for things like coal mining accidents (which are quite common), maintenance worker falling etc.), but at a population level coal pollution causes an increase in respiratory illnesses, strokes, etc. which, again, at population level kills people. If you want to learn more, you can start e.g. at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents

> Also i often wonder - where could science of reusable energy and reduced consumption be if the billions invested in nuclear research were invested there instead?

I'm not sure what "reusable energy" is supposed to mean, but yeah, sure, energy efficiency would probably be better than it is now. Would it be better enough to cover the loss of nuclear energy, and it's partial replacement by fossil power such as coal? I doubt it.

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by sjwright on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:51AM (#17053109)
Mortality rate in deaths per trillion kilowatt hours:

  Source       Rate
  -----------------
  Coal      100,000
  Oil        36,000
  Biofuel    24,000
  Gas         4,000 
  Hydro       1,400
  Solar         440
  Wind          150 
  Nuclear        90
  -----------------
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d...
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by zeristor on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:01AM (#17053137)
How are people being killed by Solar?

Panels dropped on heads? Pollutants from production? A proportion of deaths from mining and refining silicon?

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by klondike_ on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:11AM (#17053169)
I believe it is mostly from people installing solar panels. It's pretty easy to fall off a roof if you're not careful
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by sjwright on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:15AM (#17053182)
And given the comparatively modest energy output per unit, it wouldn't take many rooftop falls to put a substantial dent into the deaths per trillion kilowatt hours number.

Put it another way, if California produced 0.0004 trillion kilowatt hours of solar power every year, that would put the death rate of solar installers at one every five to six years. Sounds plausible.

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by majewsky on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:08AM (#17053160)
Why is this downvoted? I have the same question.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by hennsen on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:22AM (#17053199)
I’ve been told not to discuss downvoting (see faq). That said i think too there should be a proposal to comment what you don’t like on downvoting as it is in stackoverflow... otherwise people neber know how to change their behavior.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by zeristor on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:12AM (#17053173)
I like to think the up button is small, and it was an accidental downvote, its happened to me a few times.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by majewsky on Saturday May 12, 2018 @08:47AM (#17053809)
I don't know, there's the "unvote"/"undown" buttons to correct these kinds of mistakes, but I guess most people won't double-check.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by the8472 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:10AM (#17053165)
falling from roofs
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by danmaz74 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:09AM (#17053010)
> And how exactly are politics preventing proper storage?

Basically, NIMBY. Even if it's perfectly safe, some people will always worry about "but what if all physicists, seismologists etc. etc. are wrong (or lying)"?

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by codingminds on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:27AM (#17053210)
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by makomk on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:35AM (#17053238)
I'm not sure they actually do. The highest figure nuclear proponents have come up with for radiation exposure from coal is about three times nuclear power plants, if you only count the source of radiation exposure that coal and nuclear have in common, and that's for very polluting 1970s-era coal power plants of a type that probably wouldn't be allowed to operate today. Besides, coal power is dying out in the US anyway.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by Lazare on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:09AM (#17053009)
By that logic, solar, wind, and hydro aren't clean either; they all generate some amount of pollution and environmental side effects. And since nothing is truly "clean", I guess we can all just use coal, right?

Sarcasm aside, "clean" in this context has a very specific meaning, which nuclear meets. The fact that it isn't an entirely magical source of side-effect free power is not relevant.

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by TheRealPomax on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:43AM (#17053086)
solar, wind, and hydro don't leave a persistent waste product that takes hundreds of thousands of years to become safe to stand next to. Nuclear has a special class of unclean all on its own - it's both much cleaner than coal on the immediate term, and way less clean on the "beyond timescales that humans can understand" scale.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by Ygg2 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:57AM (#17053125)
Sure they do. It's called buildings.

Some nuclear waste can be recycled to lower lifetime waste that degrades on sensible timescales, but let's hate on all nuclear power because it's not magical.

Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by TheRealPomax on Saturday May 12, 2018 @12:37PM (#17054804)
yes, let's confused my statement for hate on nuclear, despite being pro nuclear. Makes sense to me.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:29AM (#17053221)
You do realise those “beyond timescales humans understand” substances are already in the Earth’s crust? And the longer something takes to decay, the safer it is. Long time scales are a plus.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by TheRealPomax on Saturday May 12, 2018 @12:36PM (#17054801)
Let's not fall for the "why are you worried about coal waste, there are layers and layers of soot in the crust already, and no one's bothered by those" excuse.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 12, 2018 @12:49PM (#17054857)
Pumping chemicals in the ground into the air is different from taking things in the ground from many places and hiding them away in one place.
Re:Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of Americ... by TomMarius on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:30AM (#17053063)
It's possible to easily take the whole waste and safely store it until it breaks down (it takes a while, though) - that makes it clean as opposed to other kinds of plants that pollute the air.