News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by gameswithgo on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:16AM (#17047888)
In the absence of big government, big corporate will become defacto government even more easily.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by mschuster91 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:21AM (#17047931)
Actually, we see this with the social media giants live in action: they may decide to terminate your account at any time for arbitrary (or none at all) reasons for your whole life, and you have no way of legal recourse.

There have been way too many stories alone on HN about people losing e.g. their entire mail archives or Youtube deleting evidence videos of war crimes, to let this situation continue for any longer.

Government needs to finally recognize the importance of social media to modern society... after all, telcos are not allowed to arbitrarily cut you off (especially not for life!). Why should social media be treated differently?

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by seanp2k2 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:32AM (#17048050)
Telcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can. I guess dial up is potentially still an option, but internet access is much more relevant than telephone access in 2018.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by mschuster91 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:43AM (#17048187)
> Telcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can.

Well, ISPs are replaceable (okay, they will offer different speeds). Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data).

A telco is not easily replaceable though, as the phone number is your unique handle that often cannot be changed easily (which is why you have the right to keep your number in Europe across providers)...

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by xg15 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:52AM (#17048283)
> Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data).

Comcast customers would like to have a word with you.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by sli on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:58PM (#17049466)
Yeah, that particular point is technically true, but in reality it is absolutely false. Far too many people simply do not have competing options. ADSL and satellite are not really competing options if your third option is fiber.

I'd say it's reasonable these days to expect regular people (especially the 18-34 demo) to actually rely on the speeds you get with fiber. ADSL and satellite, by comparison, are slow as molasses.

A number of those folks could probably survive with a mobile data hotspot, but that is really not ideal for a house or apartment.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by hrasyid on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:58PM (#17050395)
Yes as a comcast customer I'd like to know where to find this magical "another ISP"
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by icebraining on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:52AM (#17048285)
"Too many" is subjective, but I would say they are quite few. Gmail has over 1 billion users. We hear stories like that, what, once year? Sometimes twice?

I'm not opposed to government regulation (I support the GDPR, for example), but I really don't see Gmail bans as a problem needing intervention.

YouTube banning videos is more concerning, but how would you regulate that? And which government decides what rules apply, considering that YouTube is international?

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by brobdingnagians on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:43AM (#17048180)
As one of the other posters mentioned, big government _helps_ create big corporations. Even the legal idea of a "corporation" with the corporate veil to protect employees & those who control it from direct liability enables mega-corporations. If we simply eliminated corporate legal entities, we might have more careful business dealings. In the absence of this idea, you'd be free to take legal action against someone who harms you.

It is a similar thing with the EPA and FDA, if a corporation meets their requirements, you can't sue them, even if they are polluting your town. It actually _enables_ a legal limit that they can pollute rather than strictly reducing pollution. The most effective anti-littering campaign was the Keep America Beautiful, Crying Indian campaign, not really the EPA.

A lot of this has to do with culture, if people aren't okay with big corporations and corruption, then they would do something different. But on a certain level, people don't really care or believe that corporate entities somehow help the economy. Two-hundred years ago, the culture was different and people made things go a bit differently; the culture we have now generally supports corporate and governmental power.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by acdha on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:53AM (#17048298)
> It is a similar thing with the EPA and FDA, if a corporation meets their requirements, you can't sue them, even if they are polluting your town.

Do you have a citation for that? States, cities, and individuals sue all the time. Saying you met the federal standards may be part of the defense but it’s not immunity.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by mindcrime on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:27AM (#17047985)
Not necessarily. Big corporations actually depend on the State for their very existence, and leverage corruption, regulatory capture, etc., to grow larger and more powerful than they would naturally.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by rayiner on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:37AM (#17048114)
That's a common view, but I don't think the evidence supports it. What "corruption" and "regulatory capture" did Amazon or Google leverage in coming to dominate multiple verticals?

Instead, I think technology is the culprit. Technology pushes out the boundary where economies of scale give way to diseconomies of scale. Mom & pops can't compete with Amazon not because Amazon has a few senators in its pocket. They can't do it because Amazon's immense scale (multiple robotic warehouses, in-house shipping and logistics expertise, etc.) makes it impossible to compete on price and quality.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by _jal on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:45AM (#17048215)
Capture and corruption doesn't help small startups become big[1]. They help big companies stay big.

I think you're right that Google and Amazon (and others) leveraged something new - the catalog-sales and cat-video dynamo we call the internet - to get where they are.

And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are.

[1] You might say 'Uber' in response; I'd say the company was corrupt and failed to find sufficient exploitable government levers to succeed in those efforts, because someone else got to those levers first.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by rayiner on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:57PM (#17048901)
How about Apple, Microsoft, Walmart, and IBM? Does Apple stay big due to regulatory capture, or because its massive size allows them to create a supply chain nobody else can match?
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by root_axis on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:14PM (#17048509)
> And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are.

IMO that's not a convincing argument. Your response to two specific counter-examples is "one day you'll see that those examples actually prove my point instead of yours"

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by _jal on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:32PM (#17048676)
That's nice. If you'd like to convince me I'm wrong, you'll have to explain why these companies, which are subject to the same pressures as others and hire from the same pool of execs, will behave differently than the rest of the herd of large public firms.

If you want to argue they'll lobby, manipulate and bribe less than average among peer-firms, well, that argument could be made.

But if you want to argue that there's something special about them that means they won't play all the same games, perhaps start with explaining how Amazon's begging-for-handouts HQ tour is different than the sports stadium scam.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by rayiner on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:59PM (#17048915)
> If you want to argue they'll lobby, manipulate and bribe less than average among peer-firms, well, that argument could be made.

You’re begging the question by assuming that this conduct is what keeps “peer firms” big. That’s the point in dispute.

I’d say that there is good reason to believe why that isn’t true. Walmart spent just $7 million on lobbying last year. It’s a company with $500 billion in revenue. Does it make logical sense to infer that the $7 million in lobbying is what keeps the $500 billion spigot flowing? Much smaller competitors could out-lobby Walmart, raising the market price of corruption. Why doesn’t that happen—with hundreds of billions of dollars on the line?

People take as a shibboleth that lobbying is corruption and corruption keeps big companies big. But that flies in the face of the actual data.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by _jal on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:31PM (#17051724)
This is obviously a pretty pointless back-and-forth.

You're attempting to treat lobbying as a binary. Does it make logical sense that Walmart would spend $7M if it didn't feel that investment had a return?

Of course large companies are buoyed by other factors. But as congress-critters famously pointed out a while back, Silicon Valley had to learn to lobby. And they did, otherwise Bad Things could happen.

Also,

> People take as a shibboleth

I don't know what tribe you're trying to make me a member of, but, uh, no.

> But that flies in the face of the actual data

If you're talking about the gap between $7m and $.5T, that dataoid demonstrates nothing other than that multinational retailers operate much larger firms than politicians do.

My question stands: how is AZON playing a different game than they various sportball leagues?

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by rayiner on Saturday May 12, 2018 @08:30AM (#17053749)
> You're attempting to treat lobbying as a binary. Does it make logical sense that Walmart would spend $7M if it didn't feel that investment had a return?

Would Walmart spend only $7 million on lobbying if the return was so crazy high as you’re assuming it is?

> If you're talking about the gap between $7m and $.5T, that dataoid demonstrates nothing other than that multinational retailers operate much larger firms than politicians do.

Price doesn’t relate to size of firm or cost, but rather supply and demand. Under your theory, where lobbying is instrumental in keeping a $500 billion business from being out competed, demand should be high. At the same time, with a very limited number of Congress critters, supply is limited. That should push up the price as other firms bid to secure the supposed benefits Walmart now gets.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by bantunes on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:40AM (#17048147)
One can consider that status quo as their infancy period. Once they're big enough, they'll be able to exist and thrive without corporate welfare. "Of the world's 100 largest economic entities, 51 are now corporations and 49 are countries." according to http://www.corporations.org/system/top100.html
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by nickik on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:36AM (#17048094)
We are not talking about an absence of govenremnt.

A small government is perfectly able to regulated what is needed to regulate. It is an absolutle isllusion to believe that only a big government can correctly regulated cooperations.

In fact, I would argue there is little corrulation either way, both big and small govenrment sometimes have effective laws.

The ability to regulated derives from a monopoly on violence, not control of 50% of the economy.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by jcims on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:47AM (#17048231)
I think the confusion is conflating size, or maybe more precisely 'scope', with power.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by nickik on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:26PM (#17049180)
Exactly. I think its false to assume that a government that directly taxes 60% of all incomes is more effective law maker then a government who taxes 10% of all income is a flase assumtion.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by misja111 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:20AM (#17047924)
I guess you mean in the absence of any government. Neither big government nor anarchy is good for democracy, but there is a whole range in between.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by rjbwork on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:27AM (#17047994)
Along that logic could we say that absolute private property rights nor the complete absence of exclusive use of capital goods is good for democracy, but that there is a whole range in between?

It's not immediately obvious to me that either is true in terms of producing viable societies, but as these are the primary axes which determine how a society is going to function, it seems they ought to both be or neither be.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by erikpukinskis on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:42AM (#17048169)
You’re right it’s either/or at a given scale.

But if you think in terms of multiscale, the difference between systems stops looking so qualitative and looks more quantitative:

Either you have an absolute property law system, and a limited commons forms on top of that through land trusts, etc.

Or you have an absolute communist system, and a limited free market forms on top of that, within a system of exceptions and exemptions.

Technically you could implement identical 50/50 socialized/private systems in both of those schemes.

In practice scale matters so which system runs which scale will affect the outcome.

But the long term outcome will inevitably be “the right things are socialized and the right things are privatized”... the two systems each do experiments and make concessions when they lose. They’ll end up being quite the same, although in the short term they are quite different. And we need both to exist to run all the experiments.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by tomohawk on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:26PM (#17049178)
The trust busters in the early 20th century were not part of a big government. You need an effective government, not a big government to police corruption.

As the government has balooned in size, trust busting has become almost non existent. Corruption these days just gets a yawn.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by dragonwriter on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:06PM (#17048443)
Corporations are creatures of government; big corporate power is big government.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by panarky on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:34PM (#17048701)
A fish doesn't know it's in water because it never experienced anything else.

Can we imagine anything other than the system we live in?

I suppose we can imagine small adjustments like higher or lower taxation, more or less regulation, increasing or decreasing subsidies for different groups.

But that's like slightly changing the temperature or salinity of the water we're swimming in. It doesn't help us imagine what walking through air would be like.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by ryandrake on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:44PM (#17048808)
“We live in capitalism. Its power seems inescapable. So did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings.” - Ursula Le Guin
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by baddox on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:25AM (#17047965)
I don’t think that’s necessarily true. Government is unique because of its “social license” to govern, meaning that the vast majority of people recognize its authority to do things other people or groups cannot do (like make laws, imprison people, or collect taxes). Corporations don’t have that social license, which is why they need to cozy up with government to take advantage of that unique authority.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:37AM (#17048115)
Corporations are more than happy to take on that mantle if they are able. You saw that with the East India Company's full army and navy, you saw that with company mining towns that issued their own currency and controlled every aspect of their employees lives, you saw that with the Pinkertons investigating and dispatching extrajudicial punishment, and you see that today with Nestle paramilitaries.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by kahnpro on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:37AM (#17048113)
Without a government they can start to take this authority themselves in much the same way that local warlords do. Gradually by force, because they have power and you don't.

A small / weak government can't do anything to stop them.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:14PM (#17049074)
Small != weak. Did the US have a large government in 1900? Certainly not by the standards of today. Yet it was still able to take on Standard Oil.