News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by mschuster91 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:21AM (#17047931)
Actually, we see this with the social media giants live in action: they may decide to terminate your account at any time for arbitrary (or none at all) reasons for your whole life, and you have no way of legal recourse.

There have been way too many stories alone on HN about people losing e.g. their entire mail archives or Youtube deleting evidence videos of war crimes, to let this situation continue for any longer.

Government needs to finally recognize the importance of social media to modern society... after all, telcos are not allowed to arbitrarily cut you off (especially not for life!). Why should social media be treated differently?

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by seanp2k2 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:32AM (#17048050)
Telcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can. I guess dial up is potentially still an option, but internet access is much more relevant than telephone access in 2018.
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by mschuster91 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:43AM (#17048187)
> Telcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can.

Well, ISPs are replaceable (okay, they will offer different speeds). Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data).

A telco is not easily replaceable though, as the phone number is your unique handle that often cannot be changed easily (which is why you have the right to keep your number in Europe across providers)...

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by xg15 on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:52AM (#17048283)
> Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data).

Comcast customers would like to have a word with you.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by sli on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:58PM (#17049466)
Yeah, that particular point is technically true, but in reality it is absolutely false. Far too many people simply do not have competing options. ADSL and satellite are not really competing options if your third option is fiber.

I'd say it's reasonable these days to expect regular people (especially the 18-34 demo) to actually rely on the speeds you get with fiber. ADSL and satellite, by comparison, are slow as molasses.

A number of those folks could probably survive with a mobile data hotspot, but that is really not ideal for a house or apartment.

Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by hrasyid on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:58PM (#17050395)
Yes as a comcast customer I'd like to know where to find this magical "another ISP"
Re:Is capitalism a threat to democracy? by icebraining on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:52AM (#17048285)
"Too many" is subjective, but I would say they are quite few. Gmail has over 1 billion users. We hear stories like that, what, once year? Sometimes twice?

I'm not opposed to government regulation (I support the GDPR, for example), but I really don't see Gmail bans as a problem needing intervention.

YouTube banning videos is more concerning, but how would you regulate that? And which government decides what rules apply, considering that YouTube is international?