News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Librem 5 design report by danShumway on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:44PM (#17044635)
I'm pretty excited about the Librem 5, if it comes out even halfway decent it'll be my next phone. I'm basically banking on my current phone lasting just up until their release day.

When they initially launched their campaign I was a little pessimistic about the whole thing. But since then I've realized a couple of things:

- I really dislike the current trend in phone hardware, and Librem will fix most of those problems (kill switches, replaceable battery, etc...)

- Most of the focus on the latest and greatest phone hardware is wasted on me, especially if I can control the entire software stack. Using Linux a lot has since taught me that high performance is often only necessary because large tech stacks with mandatory upgrades degrade heavily over time. And I don't really do heavy graphical work with my phone, so I just need good enough performance.

- Most of the focus on app compatibility is wasted on me. Android has a ton of apps, and theoretically I could learn Java and develop more of them... but, I don't like Java, and I don't like Android's development experience, and most of the apps I download are trying to hack support between my phone and my desktop anyway. Ironically, I would probably be able to get better integration and more useful software for a phone running Linux.

When their campaign was first announced I know a lot of people (myself kind of included) were thinking "well, it's never going to compete with Android." And at some point, something flipped in my brain and I realized, "I don't care."

It doesn't need market penetration, it just needs to be more useful for me. If they can build an experience of even just decent quality, then that'll be an improvement over my current Android situation.

I've grown more to realize that I really value controlling my own software stack, and that the more I control my own software stack, the less I care about stuff like 3rd-party compatibility, because... well, it feeds into itself. I don't want to run much of that 3rd-party stuff anyway because I can't control it.

Re:Librem 5 design report by flukus on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:00PM (#17044698)
> I could learn Java and develop more of them... but, I don't like Java, and I don't like Android's development experience

This is the big selling point for me, android is the most insane platform to build software for I've ever experienced, I want to make apps but there is just too much tooling involved. With this I (hopefully) just need main.c and a makefile to start throwing stuff together.

I also want a half way point between androids complete disregard for user privacy and apples walled garden. Give me a distro with safe vetted apps but let me out of that safe space when I want.

Re:Librem 5 design report by confounded on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:48AM (#17045022)
Yep! I’m pretty excited to be able to make my own crappy little apps with Python and GTK.
Re:Librem 5 design report by webkike on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:14AM (#17045503)
I'm going to be able to write mobile apps in rust.
Re:Librem 5 design report by seba_dos1 on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:53AM (#17047275)
That's how I felt ten years ago with Openmoko. Freerunner was my first smartphone. Best decision :)
Re:Librem 5 design report by Avshalom on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:06PM (#17044714)
>> "I don't care."

I realize that many people love their various apps and in some cases depend on them (I imagine any one using square) but all I want is a web browser, sms and if I have to: phone calls.

Though I'm very much in the ~200$/3yr range for phones so I probably can't afford one anytime soon.

Re:Librem 5 design report by seba_dos1 on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:58AM (#17047308)
Decent, modern web browser and web apps that don't consume all of the device's RAM are the only things that I would need to make my Nokia N900 perfect again.
Re:Librem 5 design report by tfha on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:29AM (#17044973)
Calendar, email, signal. And music to play in the car.

I can live without the web browser.

Re:Librem 5 design report by jsilence on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:46AM (#17045207)
maps and navigation?
Re:Librem 5 design report by danShumway on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:59AM (#17047313)
I realize that I'm very much not typical here, but I use a dedicated GPS in my car back from before I had a smartphone. I like Garmin maps a lot better than I like Google Maps; their interface is more functional and their routing sends me down fewer side streets.

For walking around, Google Maps works fairly well in a browser, and it will not take long for someone (possibly even me) to build a dedicated app. Worst case scenario, stick Google Maps inside Electron.

Again, not arguing that would be sufficient for everyone. Just that it would be sufficient for me, and that's good enough. I don't need to care about a general solution if I'm buying a device for myself.

Re:Librem 5 design report by nikolaplejic on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:58AM (#17045850)
These all work fairly well in modern web browsers.
Re:Librem 5 design report by drdaeman on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:07AM (#17046077)
Navigation in a browser? Like, typing a destination and getting proper driving directions - like, a lane info, real-time route updates in case of known road accidents ahead, etc?

I beg your pardon, but I think this is something yet non-existent with webapps - the best you can get is a prepared list of directions, and maybe you can set the tab to auto-update once in a while. And this is something any half-decent navigation app does.

Re:Librem 5 design report by konraditurbe on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:30AM (#17045764)
> but, I don't like Java, and I don't like Android's development experience

Android now has Kotlin officially supported. Kotlin is easier to learn than Java IMO.

Re:Librem 5 design report by girvo on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:59AM (#17046049)
It’s not the language I personally can’t stand, but the whole tooling and build experience. Horrid. Also Maven/Gradle/JVM package and build management in general frustrates me.
Re:Librem 5 design report by vorg on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:23PM (#17051153)
Perhaps Google and Jetbrains will replace Gradle with Bazel in Android Studio sometime soon.
Re:Librem 5 design report by coolg54321 on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:50AM (#17045828)
The whole java/kotlin (jvm/dvm experience) is a big turn off. I really wish for go/swift first-class android development experience.
Re:Librem 5 design report by pjmlp on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:29AM (#17057901)
That would never happen.

Go team's efforts for NDK deployment were always on their own without any major support from Android team.

Unless you are targeting pre-5.0 devices Dalvik is history, ART is the new runtime system for JVM based languages.

Which even if they would drop them, it is quite clear they would either be replaced by the Web stack (PWA/WebAssembly) or be based on their Flutter ongoing experiments with Dart.

Re:Librem 5 design report by bisby on Sunday May 13, 2018 @12:29AM (#17057358)
I need to have slack and a few other apps when I'm on call... well, i dont REALLY. all the on call apps we use have SMS/phone fallbacks, but having some native tools for handling these things is definitely a lot more convenient.

But other than that, using matrix as the default messaging app sounds great. Maybe I can pull some people off of hangouts. And I can't imagine a world where a phone like this doesnt have an OTP generator.

Web browser, chat client, OTP... I really don't use my phone for much.

Pretty sure this will also be my next phone assuming it turns out even half decent (i had backed the Ubuntu Edge back in the day, but I haven't backed this, I've given up on kickstarting/indie-go-go'ing things)

Re:Librem 5 design report by thaumasiotes on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:18AM (#17045518)
Unfortunately, my primary use case for my phone is pleco and wechat. Pleco might be persuaded to release something for linux. It seems pretty clear that wechat won't (though there is a web interface to it...).

The other nasty implication to wechat being the primary use case is that a phone without notifications is essentially worthless to me.

I'll get the Librem 5 anyway assuming it's halfway decent; if they can make this work at all, the project needs support.