News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by thaumaturgy on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:37AM (#17039198)
In case it wasn't clear from my comment, I'm less willing to argue for the innocence of a person who was at .07, or .075, or .0799, because of the potentially serious consequences of their decisions and the number of convenient alternatives they had available.

That's my personal position on this. It's consistent with my own moral framework. I get that there's a valid counterargument from a position of law-and-order morality.

But I've also had friends who were first responders to a horrifying drunk driver collision. Trying to keep innocent people from bleeding out on the side of the road messes you up for a while. It's not a victimless crime.

You can get from .08 to .06 by walking around for an hour. If you think you might be close enough to borderline, go take a walk.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by ironjunkie on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:46AM (#17039280)
We are in a state of law. you cannot argue that a person is innocent but "not innocent enough" because they came too close to the fixed limit. A person is over it and guilty or under it and innocent.

As said above, if you think this limit is too high, fight to have it lowered but please don't blur the lines of the law based on your personal convictions.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by lolsal on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:16AM (#17039595)
> In case it wasn't clear from my comment, I'm less willing to argue for the innocence of a person who was at .07, or .075, or .0799, because of the potentially serious consequences of their decisions and the number of convenient alternatives they had available.

Do you feel the same way about getting ticketed for Speeding when going 55mph in a 55mph zone? Going 56mph is technically speeding you know and 55mph is very close to 56 mpg. 55mph and 56mph are arguably equivalently dangerous.

A limit is a limit. It's a discrete, unchanging, unambiguous, line in the sand that once crossed warrants consequences. That's why we codify these things into laws.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by driverdan on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:34PM (#17040444)
Your moral framework and personal position is not what should be used to determine guilt.

One issue is that some places set a very low standard, one lower than evidence shows to effect driving ability. Being borderline with unnecessarily low limits means the person is not impaired.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by camgunz on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:49PM (#17040570)
> You can get from .08 to .06 by walking around for an hour. If you think you might be close enough to borderline, go take a walk.

This isn't what the science says, and you can't "think you might be close enough to borderline" because you don't have an internal BAC meter. All in all this is extremely bad advice.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by djrogers on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:54PM (#17040631)
> This isn't what the science says

Umm yeah - science and personal experience say it really is. Do you have a source for your claim?

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 10, 2018 @02:14PM (#17041536)
Science says that when you start walking, your body stops absorbing alcohol from your digestive tract?

What if that walk takes you from .6 to .8? Oops.

Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by djrogers on Thursday May 10, 2018 @03:12PM (#17042048)
Citation please? That's not supported by any of the studies I've read or personal experience with BAC testing. In fact, pretty much everything points to walking having no affect on alcohol metabolism at all, so what you've done is spent an additional hour metabolising the alcohol, and lowering your BAC.
Re:Researchers say a breathalyzer has flaws, casting doubt o... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 10, 2018 @03:56PM (#17042409)
https://mcwell.nd.edu/your-well-being/physical-well-being/al...

"A person who has not eaten will hit a peak BAC typically between 1/2 hour to two hours of drinking. A person who has eaten will hit a peak BAC typically between 1 and 6 hours, depending on the amount of alcohol consumed."

Walking does nothing, but giving the alcohol more time to absorb can take you from safe to unsafe.