Re:When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a ...
by dredmorbius on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @02:13PM
(#17032302)
Risk arbitrage.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a ...
by Retric on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @02:17PM
(#17032341)
Banks have an odd relationship with risk. It's vastly safer to have a large number of banks than to have a much smaller number of banks. The problem is downsides vastly outweigh upside so you increase risk when you join two smaller but reasonably stable entities.
Re:When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a ...
by dredmorbius on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @02:35PM
(#17032539)
Right, though large banks have other affordances: more leverage from both information systems and relationships, as well as control over assets such as real estate and loans access.
What I was pointing out was the arbitrage of collecting cash locally (low risk) whilst seeking low-risk lending opportunities elsewhere. This actually extracts cash from the local community without providing offsetting borrowing opportunities. The community is net worse off.
Rational from the bank's perspective.
Re:When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a ...
by clairity on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @02:50PM
(#17032685)
arbitrage has a more precise meaning than just "you can make money by buying here and then selling there" (otherwise any commerce could be called arbitrage).
the defining characteristic of arbitrage is that it is risk-free. taking deposits and loaning out money is not risk-free (because someone might not pay you back in full), so it's not arbitrage.
using dollars to buy yen cheaply and then selling it back for more dollars in the same transaction is an example of arbitrage.
Re:When banks abandoned American Samoa, the islands found a ...
by pishpash on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:51PM
(#17034979)
That doesn't make sense. Both deposit and borrowing opportunities exist at some price. Low risk deposits can be sold at a low price and high risk loans can be bought at a high price. If anything, what a bank naturally would want to do is to sell low risk local deposits, taking the cash to buy high risk loans elsewhere in order to collect the risk premium. The same happens in reverse. There is no inherent reason for money to move net-net, unless there is unequal demand for deposits and borrowing. For a place like Samoa, they probably need more borrowing, so banks wouldn't be extracting any cash, but rather bringing it in.