News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by gruez on Friday May 04, 2018 @07:58AM (#16993839)
>Incelgate

can someone explain what this is?

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by speeder on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:03AM (#16993859)
Seemly after the canadian guy killed people with a van, a witchunt for Involuntary Celibates started...

For example: https://twitter.com/ekp/status/991817194987114496

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by Dylan16807 on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:05AM (#16993875)
I wouldn't use "witch hunt" for a community that toxic, though wow using -gate is obnoxious.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by J-dawg on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:40AM (#16994073)
Agh, that's scary. What is she expecting them to do about it?

Is she asking them to fire people for being sexually unattractive?

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by cimmanom on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:49AM (#16994134)
I think there's a distinction to be made between "people who are unable to find sexual partners" and "people who self-identify with and participate in communities that spew hatred and encourage violence over the fact that they can't find sexual partners".

Sort of like the difference between "white people" and "white supremacists". Except that currently we don't have separate (reasonably brief) terms for the above categories.

There's nothing wrong with having employees who are unattractive / can't find sexual partners, and I agree that that would be just as ridiculous a criterion to fire someone over as being caucasian. However, if you have people in your company who are filled with vitriol or considering violence (be it because they hate women who won't sleep with them or because they hate people with a different skin color), that's a problem waiting to happen.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by J-dawg on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:19AM (#16994351)
I think this "intolerance of intolerance" is becoming terrifying.

I personally find "people who hate people with a different skin colour" and "people who hate women" to be repulsive. I'd prefer not to work with those people, if possible. But I accept that in a free society, I might have to. I have no special right to be protected from opinions I don't like, and nor should I.

Nobody should be excluded from employment because of an opinion. And in a free society, it should never be illegal to state an opinion.

We are crossing the line into thought crime here, and it's frightening to see powerful people like Ellen Pao being ok with that.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by extra88 on Friday May 04, 2018 @11:10AM (#16995130)
I also prefer not to work with people with such bad views but I think I could. However, I also want to work with women and PoC and as the object of someone's hatred, it would presumably be harder for them; their absence would be worse for the organization, themselves, and me personally.

My starting point is I don't think what you say or do outside the workplace should have bearing on your employment. Lots of people have bad, crazy ideas that don't significantly affect their performance.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by cimmanom on Friday May 04, 2018 @10:04AM (#16994680)
It is the rare person who can prevent their hate from leaking out into their day to day interactions and making their coworkers uncomfortable - thus interfering with morale and the company's viability.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by daxorid on Friday May 04, 2018 @04:32PM (#16998049)
If we remove the ideological aspect of this argument entirely, what we're left with is the notion that employment is supposed to be 100% comfortable. But...

In any given employment environment: chairs may be less than form-fitting; different people will have different tolerances for the thermostat setting; some employees may heat fish and durian fruit in the microwave; one may be asked to load or unload 40 foot shipping containers; being under pressure to meet a deadline is fairly normal; a boss or coworker may have an unpleasant personality, possibly even a personality disorder.

In general, we expect that in many ways, employment will be uncomfortable. In general, we accept this as a nominal cost of earning a living.

But once various ideologies are introduced, there is a sudden expectation that a small and specific subset of workplace interactions ought to be 100% pleasant and comfortable. Why is this?

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by cimmanom on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:02PM (#16999668)
If I have the choice between working somewhere where my colleague thinks he has the right to rape me if I don't sleep with him vs a place where my colleagues are respectful and have my back, where do you think I'll choose to work? And if I don't have a choice of where to work, do you think I'll be able to do my best work with that sort of threat present?

It's not just about comfort (though personally I do think people have a right to a workplace where there coworkers would defend them against bodily harm rather than claim a right to inflict it). It's also about what's best for the business.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:17AM (#16994333)
> There's nothing wrong with having employees who are unattractive / can't find sexual partners, and I agree that that would be just as ridiculous a criterion to fire someone over as being caucasian.

On an unrelated note: the "firing" time hasn't arrived yet, but not being hired just because you're Caucasian isn't that uncommon nowadays.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by DanBC on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:45AM (#16994109)
Incel doesn't mean "someone who is unable to have sex". We need to have some esympathy and empathy for that group, and many places are trying to fix lonliness. This group may benefit from legalisation of sex work. Pao is not talking about this group.

Incel means "someone who is a member of a group who have a pathological hatred of women and men who have sex with women, who think that they have a right to demand sex, and that if it's not provided they have a right to take it by force by rape". Pao is talking about this group.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by J-dawg on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:10AM (#16994286)
Incel was a label that these people gave to themselves, simply meaning "involuntarily celibate".

Sure these communities are incredibly toxic, but I don't think it's fair to say that every member of them has all of the beliefs you describe. Most of these people are probably mentally ill, they need compassion and empathy, not to be purged from society.

How much more bitter and angry are they going to be if they start to feel like they're also excluded from having a job?

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by whalesalad on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:06AM (#16993881)
There is a subculture of men who refer to themselves as 'incels' – urban dictionary has a good explanation: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=incel
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by Avamander on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:01AM (#16993849)
Some new scandal, I guess, that has "gate" slapped to it, even though it has nothing to do with watergate.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by Yaggo on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:01AM (#16993848)
Woman haters are not getting laid.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by cimmanom on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:40AM (#16994076)
More precisely, "women haters are not getting laid and start killing people over it".
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by ebbv on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:01AM (#16993856)
A bunch of truly awful people nobody wants to be around blaming women for their lives instead of taking some personal responsibility.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by Avamander on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:04AM (#16993871)
And a witchhunt of those people is somehow going to help?! When has that ever helped. People like that are to some extent mentally ill and need professional help instead.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by vinceguidry on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:13AM (#16993916)
There are always going to be more people that need professional assistance than there are resources to give them said assistance. A normative solution is better than no solution.
Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by Avamander on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:15AM (#16993931)
> A normative solution is better than no solution.

Please explain how. I think it's literally the worst idea to go poking people already on the edge with their hate and misery.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by vinceguidry on Friday May 04, 2018 @08:25AM (#16993990)
No solution means not telling these people at all that their ideas aren't going to get them anywhere and letting them fester in their hatred. I agree that it could be done without the vitriol. Not entirely sure how, but I agree in theory that it's possible.

But objectively speaking, the incel viewpoint is more caustic than the common reaction to it. I'm not saying that people who identify as incels deserve it, but they really oughta know better.

This is essentially modern heresy in action. Social cohesion is far more important than both your obstinacy and your problems, and if you persist, we will burn your ass at the stake. It's ugly, it's sad, we wish we didn't have to do it, but it reflects the reality of society.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by gus_massa on Friday May 04, 2018 @10:34AM (#16994861)
> This is essentially modern heresy in action. Social cohesion is far more important than both your obstinacy and your problems, and if you persist, we will burn your ass at the stake. It's ugly, it's sad, we wish we didn't have to do it, but it reflects the reality of society.

The "social cohesion" argument is too wide. It could have been applied in the past for example to suppress the women suffrage movement. What was more important the women suffrage or the social cohesion of the 1900 society? I like the women suffrage and I dislike the incel viewpoint, but I don't understand how can you apply the self censorship or get burn argument only to the things that you dislike.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by vinceguidry on Friday May 04, 2018 @10:57AM (#16995004)
There's no ultimate morality here, only people fighting to make their views the orthodox ones. Heretics fight against a force much bigger than them. If they want to be taken seriously, they need to take the next step and form a rebellion, get other people on their side.

This is even more serious than heresy, this is called apostasy. Apostates don't get stoned by their peers, they get crucified by the army. But sometimes civil war is necessary to improve the morality of society. Suffrage was one of those times.

It's the common people that adhere to the orthodoxy that does the burning. Not the censors or the inquisition, who had bigger fish to fry. You won't find me out there tarring and feathering incels.

I'm actually somewhat sympathetic to their viewpoint. What I'm not sympathetic at all to is their stubborn obstinacy. Feminism is more important than your sexual satisfaction.

The answer to the incel situation is sex positivism. There is no holy war needed here. Sex positivism is an orthodox solution. The heretics just need to come back to Jesus.

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by GCU-Empiricist on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:08AM (#16994269)
>Social cohesion is far more important than both your obstinacy and your problems, and if you persist, we will burn your ass at the stake. It's ugly, it's sad, we wish we didn't have to do it, but it reflects the reality of society.

Wow, How do I make sure I never interact with your "society"? To me this attitude is strait out of Orwell and Huxley?

Re:OkCupid Deletes Post “Your Looks and Your Inbox” by vinceguidry on Friday May 04, 2018 @09:13AM (#16994310)
You realize I didn't invent society, right? And never need interact with it if you don't preach heresy.