I'm saying the number didn't make sense because you have to look at the marginal cost of servicing those customers. The rent didn't go up because more people were coming in. Extra employees were only necessary if the place was already busy, etc.
Retail is all about generating enough volume to cover fixed expenses.
The tipping is a legitimate issue, however, I bet there are people that spent less than the full value of the coupon, tipping the scales back in the other direction, so I believe my back of the napkin analysis stands.
Now lets assume that some people didn't redeem the coupon and that her COGS is a bit lower, so COGS = revenue. As labor and overhead are 'fixed', she shouldn't have lost any money as long as these weren't existing customers who decided to use the coupon.
If 100% of her existing customers used the coupon she certainly would have seen her profits hurt. If 100% of these people were new to the business, she wouldn't have made/lost any money on each transaction, but she would have obtained a lot more exposure.
So before deciding to do one of these deals a business owner needs to have a clear handle on their costs, the expected mix of new/existing customers, and the expected revenue from the new customers over some reasonable length of time.
$8,000 in losses is an $8 loss per customer. With $3 of revenue. So they're claiming $11 in variable costs to service each customer, for $13 worth of product. No way that is correct - if it is, Groupon is merely the straw that broke the camel's back. Their markup on product should be way higher.
Also, that's assuming no increase in follow on transactions, and that all coupons were cashed.
I don't buy it. Although it definitely could have been a net loss, it wasn't of that magnitude.