I'm not panicked by this issue, but I think there's something there. I play cards with a bunch of neurosurgeons - every one of them has professional concerns about cellular and bluetooth usage, and 4/6 expressed those concerns to me individually about my AirPods.
I don't need a brain surgeon to tell me they're seeing lots of people with brain tumour. I need a public health statistician telling what my risk is with and without a cellphone.
I sure have my phone adjacent to those parts of my body a whole lot more than my head.
Is there risk from holding a transmitting phone in the hand for an hour, or adjacent to one part of body tissue, during an extended call?
How about frequencies, e.g. will 5G alter the risk to local tissue? Is WiFi lower power & risk?
I was surprised these guys were worried about it. They all use wired earbuds, which says enough for me.
The hammer makes me aware of nails.
TBH it’s a reasonable assumption in every developed country except one.
Having worked in the UK and in the US health systems, in general in the UK you have more of a risk of something that could be done, not being done (to save the government money).
Meanwhile, in the US, if you have good insurance, you are more at risk of over-testing and over-treatment (because it reduces the doctor’s perceived legal and complaint risk, and sometimes makes the doctor or hospital more money)
If this is true (and I think you're likely to be right) then we should see longer survival with GBM thanks to lead-time bias.
If the cancer is basically inoperable, or if there isn't a big difference in outcome based on time of detection, then there wouldn't be an appreciable change in survival rates
Lead time bias tells you that even if there is no effective treatment, you will appear to live longer thanks to earlier discovery of the disease. It was a hot topic with regard to prostate cancer a few years ago.
2) The article is vague and short but "cases of GBM in England have increased from around 1,250 a year in 1995 to just under 3,000" almost certainly refers to diagnosed cases of GBM, not including incidentals found in autopsies.
Glioblastomas are associated with Alzheimer's disease. Its entirely possible that 20 years ago the symptoms of a brain tumor would be attributed to Alzheimer's when the patient was already dying of Alzheimer's, or other terminal illness for that matter. With better awareness and detection we may pick up new diagnoses in the sick and dying.
If this chart is accurate, 3.5 years older: https://www.statista.com/statistics/275394/median-age-of-the...
They really should have looked at rates by a given age.
2. Because these sensationalized risks are the ones that get coverage more than the true risks
There is plenty of coverage of the risks of smoking, bad diet and lack of exercise. It's in schools, it's in government materials, it's in posters, on packs of cigarettes, TED talks. There are non-profits dedicated to this causes creating propaganda. There are even national fitness and stop smoking days. No one in the world can claim, "Oh really? smoking isn't healthy? damn, I wish I'd known that!" They're making choices for themselves (modulo addiction and cognitive difficulties). I don't know how much more coverage would personally satisfy you.
Calling the article about cell phone risk sensationalized is out of proportion and not just a cute exaggeration. This is simply another article in a newspaper that runs hundreds of articles a day. If it were on a billboard, if television was interrupted, if a national holiday were declared, these kinds of things might render it sensational. However, it's simply a news article on a web page between an ad for women's clothing an a breast cancer medicine ad.
Maybe you think information about new health risks should be stowed further in favor of improving the health of people in general. If you feel strongly about that and you're not just trolling, I urge you to take some action and attempt to change peoples' minds about smoking, diet and exercise yourself, because you haven't changed my mind at all about the importance of researching and publishing the potential risks of cell phones.
Smoking kills. But I think people overestimate stuff. Unless you are smoking 60-100 cigs per day, I'd not be worried. When I worked in the cardiology department, those who suffered from pulmonary diseases were heavy smokers. Like 3-4 packets a day for 25 years. Now that kills.
But what if stress was the cause for your smoking and drinking habit. What if stress and anger reduced your concentration and led to that traffic accident.
Research focus on headlines, funding, and fame. It is another thing that is wrong with our world.
Smokers, as in all smokers not just the heaviest, have a life expectancy 10 years less than non smokers.
10s of thousands die annually just from cancers/complications from secondhand smoke.
https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/heal...
http://news.mit.edu/2017/volkswagen-emissions-premature-deat...
If this was a story about brain tumors going undetected because of deliberate misdiagnosis, it would get a ton more press still.
So even if this isn't a story about brain tumors going undetected because of deliberate mis-diagnosis there has been a large effort to make it seem as though there is no effect at all. And that effort was also quite deliberate.
The electromagnetic radiation that cell phones actually do produce is similar to say a radio or even more aptly a microwave and anyone who has ever nuked a spud knows what too much of it looks like and knows that your phones radio falls far short of what anyone would consider too much in the traditional sense.
Further large scale analysis has repeatedly failed to find a correlation between the introduction of cell phones and an uptick of brain cancer.
So in summary we are talking about a theory that has been repeatedly debunked by scientists and promoted by idiots if it turns out there is some novel mechanism by which it promotes brain tumors it will be a harder than average sell and it will be novel science not vindication of all the idiots who believed cell tower = plutonium.
Why don't we see a similar uptick everywhere for example instead of just in england?
That's what the article is about.
> a plausible mechanism for harm
The plausible mechanism is that EM radiation causes tissue to warm up, which can damage it. This is well documented, and will happen already at frequencies far below what a mobile phone uses.
> All we have at the moment is an uptick in a particular kind of cancer without a plausible mechanism how do we assign that to cell phones?
Because of the location of the tumors.
> Why don't we see a similar uptick everywhere for example instead of just in england?
Because that's where this research was done.
Look, no matter what this is a very subtle affair. The only thing that this research has done - according to me - is to move the needle from 'instant dismiss' to 'maybe more and more careful research should be done' to determine the exact magnitude of the effect.
1.5 months of life is huge, this is only ~1 order of magnitude more than the smoking takes nationwide, and only a few times more than the drinking does. Probably more than any illegal drug does, taken separately.
So if this study is true, it will definitely put mobile phones among top 10 preventable causes of death.
Humans (or at least this human) are not good at dealing with slow problems. We like to fixate on immediate, discrete threats.
Also there's a global industry that profit s from people being addicted to cheaply produced unhealthy food.
You're comparing "most people"'s long-term, chosen, known unhealthy habits against a new phenomenon which has less flexibility and more unknowns. It's form a of whataboutism.
Same with headset, I prefer the sound quality.
So none of these choices are made to avoid cancers.
BTW, exercise kills as well. There are also known cases of heavy smokers/drinkers that made it to 100.
Outliers, not in any way related to the general trend and a bad argument in general.
Numbers please.
worst case, average case is more than an order of magnitude lower for cardiac related death:
2/100.000 for cardiac related death by excercise.
1278.9/100.000 normal
1879.4/100.000 obese (combined, so about 1.5 increase)
So yes, outliers. Though the numbers are difficult to compare since the timespan of the research is different and the age groups could be off. But you asked for numbers.
One is just implicit.
Some of the longest living people in the world (e.g. in the island of Icaria) drink and smoke like it's 1977 and they have always been.
https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/28/magazine/the-island-where...
Perhaps less stress and better lifestyle (quality of life) is the key to fewer cancers and such, as opposed to cutting smoking and drinking -- even with the increased burden on the lungs and such.
~2000 new cases per year in a country with 53 million people? I'll take my chances.
I'm fascinated how people obsess over the unproven and ultimately minuscule health risks associated with using a cell phone or drinking a glass of wine or eating chocolate or whatever. We know for a fact that smoking, overeating, and not exercising kill literally tens of millions of people each year, but it seems like most people can't be bothered to take those health risks seriously...