News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by nickbauman on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @09:36PM (#16982676)
It has never been "it has value because you say so" by itself. It has value because it has a huge war machine behind it. Why does the gold coin of the realm have the king's face on it? Why didn't the king just keep the gold instead of using it to pay his soldiers and demand the coin be used to pay him his taxes from the formerly free peasants?

Money _is_ trust. I really wonder if people trust a traditional banking system less than an algorthm implemented by a group of programmers whose code they either can't read or can't understand or both.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by stevenwoo on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @10:11PM (#16982844)
Cryptocurrency seems to have struck a chord with those who do not see much chance for advancement in the current state of affairs and perceive it as a way out - this seems to be common among all the people involved I've seen interviewed from South Korea to Eastern Europe. There's little discussion of the advantage of system of traditional money versus cryptocurrency, though that may be a function of how short the quotes used in the article are.

https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2018/04/23/597780405/...

http://money.cnn.com/2017/12/12/technology/south-korea-bitco...

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by freeflight on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:39AM (#16983582)
> I really wonder if people trust a traditional banking system less than an algorthm implemented by a group of programmers whose code they either can't read or can't understand or both.

To be fair: How many people do actually understand the fiat money system that's going on, with all of its finer points and at scale?

I wouldn't be too surprised if quite many people only understand the "Government prints money" part but nothing else about it, which is pretty much my extent of understanding.

Compared to that something like BC seems actually rather simple and straightforward to wrap your head around (at least for me): A finite amount of coins, coins need to be farmed, once they are all farmed people will make money through transaction fees.

Don't need to understand all of the math to understand the basic principles at work. Just like you don't need to understand everything about the fiat money system to use it.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by rtpg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @05:03AM (#16984400)
Simplicity is kinda nice, but it's not very indicative of a good solution all the time.

Especially given the counterintuitive results behind fiat currencies and the relatively low correlation between all the moving parts, it's difficult to even say if the simpler model is better because the complicated model has so many side effects.

I don't understand how my car works but it sure works better than my easy to understand bike.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by freeflight on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:05PM (#16990419)
> I don't understand how my car works but it sure works better than my easy to understand bike.

That's an interesting comparison:

- The car might work better by certain metrics (speed, distance, force) but the bike can still outperform it in some situations (high traffic, cost efficiency on shorter distances, terrain)

- If the car breaks I'd need help fixing it, with the bike, I could probably fix most issues myself.

That's why both, cars and bikes, do coexist as each of them fills a specific need/niche. Trying to apply this to monetary systems sure seems difficult to imagine, but maybe something like that might be the actual solution?

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by rtpg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:49PM (#16991334)
Yeah after posting I thought about this too. It's not that a car is "better", but it's better in certain instances.

A simpler solution is better in cases where you want many participants to operate the "backend" (the printing of money/distribution of money, so to speak). The biggest issue is that if your model is too simple there could be an easy way to game the system.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by stale2002 on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:31PM (#16983152)
A single person working at bank can flip a switch and take my money. A developer can't do that with my Bitcoin.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lern_too_spel on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:46PM (#16983207)
The government can ban anybody from converting those bitcoins into something useful. The value of your digital baubles is now zero.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by stale2002 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:05PM (#16987708)
And then I transfer that to a different country and convert it their.

You don't need 1 government to do this. You need EVERY government to do this.

This is useful, in the sense that someone in venezuela is at serious risk of the government taking their money if it is in a bank, but they really couldn't do that to their Bitcoin.

Yes, if it is the US government doing the banning, you are significantly less likely to get around the ban.

But the world is not US centric. There are many governments would try to oppress their population by using the power of the banks, but would be significantly less effective against crypto transactions.

People are using crypto right NOW to get around many currency control laws implemented by governments. So they are successful getting around financial censorship that is already happening.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:31PM (#16989653)
So now you have currency in another country. As long as your country doesn't allow you to repatriate, you still have nothing. It's the same as holding US dollars in a US bank while living in another country that regulates getting the money out (except worse because fewer people will accept BTC vs. USD). As long as you cannot spend it, it is worthless.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mythrwy on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:22PM (#16991752)
They are still spendable. Or sellable to private party.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lern_too_spel on Friday May 04, 2018 @10:43AM (#16994924)
Who will accept them if they cannot be converted back to usable currency?
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mythrwy on Friday May 04, 2018 @04:19PM (#16997935)
If they are spendable they are usable currency. Perhaps of more limited use though to your point.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:50AM (#16983622)
When was the last time this happened? Was the bank uninsured or unregulated? What did the police think of the matter?
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by stale2002 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:08PM (#16987735)
Well, this literally effected me back in 2010 when I tried to donate to Wikileaks.

Visa and mastercard and all the banks banned transactions to Wikileaks even though no laws were broken.

They successfully censored transactions to them, without going through the court system.

The police did not force visa and mastercard to allow transactions to these places.

It is worse then that actually. The police PARTICIPATE in taking away money from people who haven't been convinced of any crimes.

Did you know is that if the police merely suspect you of "money laundering" or drug crimes or whatever, that they can just take your assets? They don't need a court order. They can just take the money that you are carrying, and in order to get it back you have to prove your innocence.

It is literally guilty until proven innocent with regards to police asset forfeiture. It is possible that you will never get that money back, even if you are never charged with a crime.

This is just one example though. The banks censor financial transactions ALL the time, even though no laws are being broken. You know, private company that can do whatever they want, and all that.

Or for other examples, just Google PayPal horror stories, of some administrator arbitrarily freezing people's money.

And I am talking about people who have broken zero laws, or have been convicted of anything in a court.

Someone at PayPal can just freeze your money, and who knows when or if you will get it back, without a court order. And this really does happen to people all the time.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @02:01PM (#16988213)
> Well, this literally effected me back in 2010 when I tried to donate to Wikileaks.

Clearly it didn't because someone at the bank didn't press a button and make your money disappear, which was the original claim.

> Did you know is that if the police merely suspect you of

US problems, you need to sort out your laws.

> This is just one example though. The banks censor...

I don't know what you're involved in, I've never, ever had this issue, and it wasn't the issue we were talking about either.

> PayPal horror stories

Also not what we were talking about.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:47AM (#16984329)
It's a particularly bad week to make that argument - many TSB customers have no access to their money right now as we speak. (No doubt in the fullness of time those people will be repaid, a regulatory investigation will occur, and a scapegoat will be found, but that's cold comfort to those people right now).
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by acdha on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:49AM (#16985978)
That seems to make the argument stronger: TSB customers will get full compensation and there will be legal penalties for the incompetent management. That seems a lot better than “everything is irreversibly gone” failure mode of Bitcoin which hopes that the victims will successfully track down and sue the culprits, as seen in the many failures so far.

It also sounds completely unlike the naive framing above alleging that bank employees are able to take your money

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:58AM (#16986065)
> That seems to make the argument stronger: TSB customers will get full compensation and there will be legal penalties for the incompetent management.

Customers will get "full compensation" of what was in their accounts, eventually but their consequential losses for not having money in the meantime are unlikely to be covered.

> That seems a lot better than “everything is irreversibly gone” failure mode of Bitcoin which hopes that the victims will successfully track down and sue the culprits, as seen in the many failures so far.

I don't really disagree, but bitcoin does give you more control over your own destiny. If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely, you can do so, and no-one can take it away from you.

> It also sounds completely unlike the naive framing above alleging that bank employees are able to take your money

That was those customers' experience - someone at the bank pressed a button, and now they can't exchange their money for goods and services. Eventually the wheels of law will grind away the bank and return those people's money, but that doesn't necessarily help them right now.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:01AM (#16986099)
> I don't really disagree, but bitcoin does give you more control over your own destiny. If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely,

Which is so far beyond what normal people will ever be capable of doing!

> That was those customers' experience - someone at the bank pressed a button, and now they can't exchange their money for goods and services.

No, the claim was that it was 'gone', it's not.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:12AM (#16986729)
> No, the claim was that it was 'gone', it's not.

If their balance is showing negative and they try to withdraw money and fail, I think it's fair to say their money is gone in every meaningful sense. Likely they'll get it back sooner or later, but at the moment it's gone.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:26AM (#16986837)
I don't, sorry, I think that's a false and very self serving equivocation.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by acdha on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:58AM (#16987109)
> If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely, you can do so, and no-one can take it away from you.

It seems very unrealistic to assume to 0.5% security and operational expertise for anything pitched as a general solution.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:00AM (#16986085)
They have a problem accessing their cash right now, sure. It's not 'gone'.

And any number of developers have done exactly what the other poster said with bitcoin - exchanges have gone bust or just scammed an 'exit', wallet services get compromised or scammed, people's computers get infected, all sorts of stuff.

Tell me honestly, should I prefer a system where if it's gone, it's really gone forever and completely unrecoverable? One where the security advice tells me to keep multiple computers, one of which has never been networked, and perform laborious procedures with USB keys to use my money? And one in which the community will tell me I was wrong, sorry for my loss, and move on?

Yeah, they're in a bad place right now, they won't be forever. This is better than Bitcoin.