News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:47AM (#16984329)
It's a particularly bad week to make that argument - many TSB customers have no access to their money right now as we speak. (No doubt in the fullness of time those people will be repaid, a regulatory investigation will occur, and a scapegoat will be found, but that's cold comfort to those people right now).
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by acdha on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:49AM (#16985978)
That seems to make the argument stronger: TSB customers will get full compensation and there will be legal penalties for the incompetent management. That seems a lot better than “everything is irreversibly gone” failure mode of Bitcoin which hopes that the victims will successfully track down and sue the culprits, as seen in the many failures so far.

It also sounds completely unlike the naive framing above alleging that bank employees are able to take your money

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:58AM (#16986065)
> That seems to make the argument stronger: TSB customers will get full compensation and there will be legal penalties for the incompetent management.

Customers will get "full compensation" of what was in their accounts, eventually but their consequential losses for not having money in the meantime are unlikely to be covered.

> That seems a lot better than “everything is irreversibly gone” failure mode of Bitcoin which hopes that the victims will successfully track down and sue the culprits, as seen in the many failures so far.

I don't really disagree, but bitcoin does give you more control over your own destiny. If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely, you can do so, and no-one can take it away from you.

> It also sounds completely unlike the naive framing above alleging that bank employees are able to take your money

That was those customers' experience - someone at the bank pressed a button, and now they can't exchange their money for goods and services. Eventually the wheels of law will grind away the bank and return those people's money, but that doesn't necessarily help them right now.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:01AM (#16986099)
> I don't really disagree, but bitcoin does give you more control over your own destiny. If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely,

Which is so far beyond what normal people will ever be capable of doing!

> That was those customers' experience - someone at the bank pressed a button, and now they can't exchange their money for goods and services.

No, the claim was that it was 'gone', it's not.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by lmm on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:12AM (#16986729)
> No, the claim was that it was 'gone', it's not.

If their balance is showing negative and they try to withdraw money and fail, I think it's fair to say their money is gone in every meaningful sense. Likely they'll get it back sooner or later, but at the moment it's gone.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:26AM (#16986837)
I don't, sorry, I think that's a false and very self serving equivocation.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by acdha on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:58AM (#16987109)
> If you're smart and hardworking enough to store your own bitcoin securely, you can do so, and no-one can take it away from you.

It seems very unrealistic to assume to 0.5% security and operational expertise for anything pitched as a general solution.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by Nursie on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:00AM (#16986085)
They have a problem accessing their cash right now, sure. It's not 'gone'.

And any number of developers have done exactly what the other poster said with bitcoin - exchanges have gone bust or just scammed an 'exit', wallet services get compromised or scammed, people's computers get infected, all sorts of stuff.

Tell me honestly, should I prefer a system where if it's gone, it's really gone forever and completely unrecoverable? One where the security advice tells me to keep multiple computers, one of which has never been networked, and perform laborious procedures with USB keys to use my money? And one in which the community will tell me I was wrong, sorry for my loss, and move on?

Yeah, they're in a bad place right now, they won't be forever. This is better than Bitcoin.