News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by asynchrony on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @08:17PM (#16982290)
I don't think there's that much disagreement over the effectiveness of blockchain for managing decentralized ledgers (cryptocurrencies). There's rather more contention about the applicability of blockchain to other spaces.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by dnautics on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @10:41PM (#16982977)
> I don't think there's that much disagreement over the effectiveness of blockchain for managing decentralized ledgers (cryptocurrencies)

Agreed. A lot of people have forgotten to ask the question - do I really need a decentralized and trustless ledger?

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by novalis78 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:05AM (#16985159)
An >immutable< ledger helped me wrap my head around it better. The immutability makes software chip away at arenas that traditionally are the providence of law/contract/social/administrative/governance institutions. It allows for replacing middle men and automate processes that were locked up in the only form of "trust" that we knew how to facilitate (via layers of humans).
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by dnautics on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:56PM (#16988173)
all ledgers imply relative immutability, with the security of the immutability having a cost that is dependent on the security level. There's a really large cost to having the immutability level of the blockchain. Is it worth it? Probably not in most cases.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mirimir on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:38AM (#16984061)
Fundamentally, so it can't be taken down or pwned.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by asynchrony on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:51AM (#16984126)
Do I need a ledger? Do I need to other people to trust what I write on the ledger? Do I need to trust what other people write on the ledger? Is it possible to trust what is written on the ledger in relation to what I actually care about?

I haven't heard any convincing yes answers to all of these questions outside of financial instruments.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by SuoDuanDao on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:18AM (#16984923)
The bulk of what any country's civil service does is keep trustworthy records. Court documents, property records, tax receipts... all require a civil service being paid well enough that accepting a bribe is a bad value proposition.

I find it telling that places where the government is bullish on cryptocurrencies (Venezuela, Moscow) have reputations as places with high amounts of graft.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mirimir on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:05AM (#16984178)
For decentralized payment systems, it's obviously essential.

But there is no general answer. It depends on the circumstances.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by rtpg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:59AM (#16984385)
Cash is a decentralized payment system for most intents. So the question becomes: Do I need a digital decentralized payment system? Does one need them?

One fairly strong legitimate use case is people who are consistently shunned by credit card networks. Lots of people working in adult industries, weed (in states where it's legal), certain high risk spaces... though _even then_ it's not about decentralization, just abut needing some form of competition (debit card network?)

Meanwhile there are real costs to the decentralized networks

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mirimir on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:52AM (#16984776)
You don't need a digital decentralized payment system for cash. At least, if cash transactions are all in person. But once you start mailing cash around, and having agents transport cash, a decentralized distributed-trust leger might be useful.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by rtpg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:46AM (#16985452)
Yes, that's a good point. If you have a certain number of trust points you could use a decentralized ledger to effectively build a banking system where you still get cash out of it.

Suffice to say that this would likely be very against a bunch of KYC money laundering laws, but it's a decent trick

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mirimir on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:28PM (#16990597)
Such as hawala. I have no clue how it manages trust.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by mateuszf on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:06AM (#16984859)
> Cash is a decentralized payment system for most intents. So the question becomes: Do I need a digital decentralized payment system? Does one need them?

Cash is not decentralized. Governments can print as much as they want.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by rtpg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:44AM (#16985440)
It's decentralized for most purposes. It would be very hard for the gov't to revoke any transaction, or to blacklist money you have (except in very specific cases where the stars align and they can list serial numbers to block).

The fact that gov't can print money has roughly the same effect as speculation has on cryptocurrencies

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by luckydata on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @10:58PM (#16983041)
I think the real question nobody has managed to answer successfully is "what do I need a decentralized ledger for?".
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by passwordreset on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:32PM (#16983157)
I think that's been greatly covered. Consensus.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by jonny_eh on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:48PM (#16983212)
That's like saying that a fladger is clearly valuable… for fladging!
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by sp527 on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @08:44PM (#16982414)
I think this should be rephrased as: the disagreement is entirely over what happens when you introduce humans (and, even more specifically, human behavior).

The math is theoretically sound. Anyone disagreeing with that is a fool.

A good example is the argument over network control. The mathematics of blockchain very precisely describe what percentage of accumulated mining power introduces the opportunity to defeat distributed consensus. But it's the fact that there is a human behavioral incentive to try and accumulate that aggregate mining power that might be a real problem, not the math. Granted that's a low likelihood event.

This dichotomy emerges in countless different facets of blockchain, and I think is the simplest way of delineating the line between believers and naysayers.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by asynchrony on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @09:51PM (#16982751)
In my mind the main contention is the difference between assets that exist entirely within the ledger (BTC, ETH, CryptoKitties) and assets that purport to reliably track some physical asset. Mathematical certainties about cryptographic security don't help reconcile the reality of meatspace with the state of the ledger.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by ThomPete on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:44PM (#16983202)
Networked consencus. You want to have a 2ndhand market for digital assets, this is perfect for that, you want to build truly denctralized digital identity, this is perfect. Its basically a history layer on top of TCP/IP.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by sanderjd on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:37AM (#16983578)
> You want to have a 2ndhand market for digital assets, this is perfect for that

Why do I want that?

> you want to build truly denctralized digital identity, this is perfect

That sounds useful. The technique of using a blockchain for distributed consensus has been around a long time now; why hasn't this killer app identity system emerged yet?

> Its basically a history layer on top of TCP/IP

That doesn't seem accurate. Do you mean that it could be that? Is there any chance of scaling a blockchain to that level of activity?

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by ThomPete on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:28AM (#16984976)
Why do people do Pokemon cards?

Why do you expect digital identity to be solved by blockchain in just 10 years with only the last 3 of them having had any serious investments. Not sure what universal rule it is you think it's not following.

It's accurate in perspective of both 2nd hand market and digital identity. The network is the concensus model that validates the history of the transactions and allow you to claim if something is historically an ebook owned by Bill-Gates or not. If you don't think that's valuable you haven't spend enough time in the artmarket to understand how humans apply value to things of basically no actual value (other than what other humans apply to it)

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by sanderjd on Thursday May 03, 2018 @12:38PM (#16987482)
The thing I find odd (and unexciting) about the second-hand market thing is that appears to be to be fighting technology rather than innovating. We already have scarcity in the real world. One of the most interesting and powerful things about the digital world is that it scarcity does not exist. If I squint hard enough I can see this sort of thing being successful, but it seems like a step backward instead of forward.

My question in the identity system was actually an honest one (though I don't blame you for having me pegged as a skeptic and answering as such): why isn't this a thing yet? 10 years seems like a long time; 3 years seems like long enough for me to have heard of at least one promising work in progress system. What are the challenges?

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by ThomPete on Thursday May 03, 2018 @02:02PM (#16988219)
Not sure if I have a stalker who just downvote everything I say or what's going but with the danger of yet another downvote for having an opinion:

You need scarcity in a digital world because you need things to be unique sometimes or have a unique history and because we need a way to establish "experience points" and to leave a trail that is uniquely yours and so that we can transfer that from one domain to another. That doesn't mean everything have to have a history or that we shouldn't take advantage of the Copy/Paste abilities digital gives us but there are plenty of areas where it's important to have scarcity.

Some exampels are:

Voting

Intellectual Property

Currency

Contracts

Documentation

Som even more interesting although more speculative areas IMO are: As a base for AI (there should be a cost associated with everything AI do the closer we come to Generalized AI) The ability for the individual to own their own data while still making it available to others (This can apply to everything from healthcare to buyer data)

I am of the belief that you want more fluidity in those areas the more digital our interactions become. Because that actually increases the need for "micro" agreements and history trails across organisationer or between humans. In other words I want a world where it's very easy for two or more parties to make agreements in the digital domain without being hooked up to some specific organisations interest. Just like I can freely trade my old book with the person next door.

If you have a secondhand market you have the ability to freely move between organizations and people without any need for a middle man who

With regards to the challenges for a Identity system it actually goes hand in hand with the second hand market in the sense that you want the ability to be able to know that a person/digital entity is what she/he/it say claim they are. The best way IMO is to create a unique finger print through our accumulated behaviors.

I wrote an essay about this a while back:

http://000fff.org/the-ghost-protocol-digital-identity-for-im...

But it will take time because it has to be a bottom up approach and it will require a lot more accumulation of our behavior plus perhaps some large player like FB, Google or Amazon to start accepting it. But that's why the second hand market is interesting in that it could allow for it to happen without big players.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by sanderjd on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:02PM (#16991392)
I'm certainly not the one downvoting you :) I think your comments in this thread have been very interesting!