News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by dang on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @07:20PM (#16982008)
We'd never penalize anyone for editing. The world could use more of it.
Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by noir_lord on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @07:36PM (#16982100)
Maybe widen the edit window?

There are times I’d like broaden a comment.

Reddit has a visual indicator for edited posts, I’ve often thought a git diff style view would be interesting.

Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by codetrotter on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @08:40PM (#16982403)
> I’ve often thought a git diff style view would be interesting.

I used to think so to but I no longer think having the history of a comment has much value.

If someone is consistently making dishonest edits people will call them out on it without needing to point to an integrated version history.

Mist edits are made probably to fix grammatical and factual mistakes. Who cares about the history for that.

What I do wish for instead would be that you could request deletion of a response to your comment after you’d remedied some error that they pointed out because once fixed that comment is no longer needed. So A writes a comment, B corrects them. A fixed their comment and attributes B then sends a deletion request to B.

However at that point perhaps full collaborative editing would be useful, like they have on the Stack Exchange sites and Wikipedia. Then comment history would be useful so that you could inspect individual comments and revert them.

I have a specific type of collaborative editing in mind for sites like HN, and Reddit, namely that threads of multiple comments would be summarized and condensed into single comments so that they are fast to read through for people that visit the thread in the future. Again, contributors would be attributed and would get a share of the karma when the summary is upvoted corresponding to how much information they contributed.

Of course that is a nice idea in theory but probably not realistically doable. It would be impossible to find enough people that are both willing to do this work and at the same time do so with an “objective” eye, and to not even get paid for it.

Encyclopedic articles and Q&A sites are a good fit as we’ve seen with Wikipedia and the Stack Exchange sites. For general discussions I think it would not.

Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by nordsieck on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @09:42PM (#16982705)
> If someone is consistently making dishonest edits people will call them out on it without needing to point to an integrated version history.

I've gotten into the habit of quoting the previous comment to prevent just that. Seems to work pretty well.

Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by soperj on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @11:02PM (#16983056)
>Mist edits are made probably to fix grammatical and factual mistakes

Doubt it was on purpose, but enjoyed it none hte less. ;)

Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by mseebach on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:13AM (#16984894)
I actually assumed that it was a term I hadn't heard yet for a ghost edit that doesn't change the substance. Not a ghost, just a little mist.
Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by codetrotter on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:12AM (#16983949)
Whoops lol
Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by Already__Taken on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:15AM (#16984204)
Edit has a tamper seal which I thought was cool. If you edit your comment under some time (maybe 5 min) you won't get that edit Astrix
Re:Tesla beats expectations with $3.4B in revenue by chollida1 on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @07:59PM (#16982205)
Ahh, I was under the assumption that multiple edits get "deprioritized" in the rankings.

Thanks for the clarification.