Yes, few informed people would disagree. The problem, however, is with how the debate is presented to the public. Watching CNN or MSNBC someone would come away with the impression that the debate is between the political conservative position (either wait and see, or it's not a problem), and the IPCC.
In reality, the scientific debate is centered around the IPCC[1], with some scientists being more conservative in future projections, and some being more dire. The scientific uncertainty that you speak of cuts both ways, and could also end up revealing a nightmare scenario of climate feedbacks. See:http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2009/roulette-0519.html
[1] http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2010/06/04/1003187107.full...
However, the _predictive_ claims of climate scientists only follow from the historical facts through the means of statistical, computerized models that are, AFAIK, essentially unproven. In fact, exact quantitative predictions have consistently failed for the last two decades. There is no more science in _predictive_ climatology, I believe, than there is in forecasting the stock market (where the same kind of computer models are also used extensively).
Scale separation and statistical pseudoequilibrium (forget the exact term) are just assumed in order to "get results". I.e., if you didn't make those assumptions, simulations would require so many data points that they would be impossible. Nonphysical energy damping is added, since without it, most simulations blow up. Lots of important parameters are just picked roughly at random, just to calibrate the model to historical data.
Stock market predictions also tend to have one major advantage over GCM models - their proponents admit their limits.
If you'd like to see a chart summarizing the various climate forcings, then look at page 4 of this link: http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-spm...
I'm not going to track down all the literature behind those numbers here, but there are published, falsifiable arguments supporting them. Climate models aren't similar to Wall Street voodoo.
And this is simply the measurement part. _Predicting_ what will happen is a thousand times more difficult. If you want predictive science based on the laws of physics, look at astronomy. 4000 years ago, the Babylonians could predict astronomical events with much more precision than anything today's climatologists can predict about average temperatures.
YC = Young Earth Creationist
PC = Progressive Creationist
TE = Theistic Evolutionist
NE = Naturalistic Evolutionist
ID = Intelligent Design
- -
| | Selection pressure drives changes in balance of genetic traits
| | in a population over time
| |
| YC Trivial, yet novel, beneficial mutations happen
| |
| | Some mutations permanently change populations
| |
| ... Trivial speciation occurs via natural means
|
| | Species within a 'kind' of animal (e.g., dogs and wolves) may
| | share a common ancestor
| |
| | Earth and universe are billions of years old
| |
| PC Different species have arisen over millions of years of history
| |
ID | Some classes of creatures not mentioned in Genesis (e.g., bacteria,
| | algae) may share a common ancestor
| |
| ... Fossil record accurately reflects biological diversity over time
| |
| | 'Kinds' of animals are not necessarily uniquely created; some may have
| | been the result of external genetic tinkering
| |
| | Some types of creatures may have been created *ex nihilo*, some may
| | have been genetically engineered, some may have evolved from others;
| | no ideological preference, it is a purely scientific question.
| |
| | All life may have a common ancestor
| |
| | Biological diversity is explained entirely via mutation and natural
| TE selection, but some mutations may be of 'hidden' supernatural origin
| | (e.g., God orchestrates cosmic rays to make unlikely things happen)
| |
| | Any creative influence exerted by God on evolution occured in
| | the setup of the universe; biological diversity in history is solely
| | a result of the operation of natural laws.
- |
| The origin of life itself has a purely naturalistic explanation.
-
|
NE The origin and diversity of life, including the suitability of the
| universe to life, is explicable solely in terms of natural laws.
-
On the other hand, anthropogenic global warming is a matter of degree. Scientists largely agree that there has been some AGW (although it's not settled to nearly the confidence of evolution). What people object to is the constant bombardment with doomsday scenarios. The magnitude and implications of AGW are NOT settled and yet it's often claimed that hugely invasive and costly public policy initiatives must be enacted to combat worst case outcomes. Scientists and activists who carry the science further than its legs undermine their credibility and make it tough to discuss the issues fairly. It's pretty sneaky to suggest that if you don't toe the popular line on AGW, you're probably a Creationist.