News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skeptics discount science by casting doubts on scientist ... by Dove on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @08:56PM (#1696443)
They aren't. Here's the spectrum of beliefs as I understand it.

   YC = Young Earth Creationist
   PC = Progressive Creationist
   TE = Theistic Evolutionist
   NE = Naturalistic Evolutionist

   ID = Intelligent Design


    -  -       
    |  |  Selection pressure drives changes in balance of genetic traits
    |  |    in a population over time
    |  |   
    | YC  Trivial, yet novel, beneficial mutations happen 
    |  |   
    |  |  Some mutations permanently change populations
    |  |   
    | ... Trivial speciation occurs via natural means
    |     
    |  |  Species within a 'kind' of animal (e.g., dogs and wolves) may
    |  |    share a common ancestor
    |  |   
    |  |  Earth and universe are billions of years old
    |  |   
    | PC  Different species have arisen over millions of years of history
    |  |   
   ID  |  Some classes of creatures not mentioned in Genesis (e.g., bacteria,
    |  |    algae) may share a common ancestor
    |  |   
    | ... Fossil record accurately reflects biological diversity over time
    |  |
    |  |  'Kinds' of animals are not necessarily uniquely created; some may have
    |  |    been the result of external genetic tinkering 
    |  |
    |  |  Some types of creatures may have been created *ex nihilo*, some may
    |  |    have been genetically engineered, some may have evolved from others;
    |  |    no ideological preference, it is a purely scientific question.
    |  |   
    |  |  All life may have a common ancestor
    |  |   
    |  |  Biological diversity is explained entirely via mutation and natural
    | TE    selection, but some mutations may be of 'hidden' supernatural origin
    |  |    (e.g., God orchestrates cosmic rays to make unlikely things happen)
    |  |   
    |  |  Any creative influence exerted by God on evolution occured in 
    |  |    the setup of the universe; biological diversity in history is solely
    |  |    a result of the operation of natural laws. 
    -  |   
       |  The origin of life itself has a purely naturalistic explanation.
       -   
       |
      NE   The origin and diversity of life, including the suitability of the
       |    universe to life, is explicable solely in terms of natural laws. 
       -

There are no comments on this comment yet.