News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skeptics discount science by casting doubts on scientist ... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:41PM (#1696552)
No they aren't. They are based on the laws of physics with all sorts of wild assumptions tacked on to make them tractable. For instance, water is typically modeled as having the consistency of molasses in the x-y directions, and some even more viscous material in the z-direction. Many important components of climate modelling are simply not derivable from simple physics (e.g., biological effects, cloud formation), and these are just made up to fit historical records, if not ignored.

Scale separation and statistical pseudoequilibrium (forget the exact term) are just assumed in order to "get results". I.e., if you didn't make those assumptions, simulations would require so many data points that they would be impossible. Nonphysical energy damping is added, since without it, most simulations blow up. Lots of important parameters are just picked roughly at random, just to calibrate the model to historical data.

Stock market predictions also tend to have one major advantage over GCM models - their proponents admit their limits.

There are no comments on this comment yet.