It won't take much of a change in the climate before we see significant conflict over access to water. India and Pakistan have a treaty they both signed in 1960 regarding access to water from 6 rivers they share (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Waters_Treaty). These are two nations that have nuclear weapons... if that treaty fails and results in a war, that'd almost certainly end up being World War III, and could very well result in the end of civilisation.
This isn't speculation on my part. We're already at the point where nations have civil wars over access to natural resources like water and agricultural land. It was a key factor in civil war in Sudan. Wars around the middle east between Israel and it's neighbours are rooted in religion but are often also about access to water from the Jordan basin.
Climate change isn't simply things getting hotter and sea levels rising. People literally go to war over resources. It really matters.
Climate change isn't the threat, the problem is that population growth is exponential. We don't have a reliable mechanism to shrink population apart from run out of resources and have a war. Claiming that climate change is making resources scarce isn't grappling with the fact that in 100 years at 2% population growth, resources are going to be scarce anyway.
In particular, population growth slows down where it matters, i.e. for those people that have the biggest carbon footprint.
And, in the short term, exponential may be a reasonable fit. Doesn't make it a long-term guarantee.
There's no real evidence yet in the stats for the next transition to a drop in the absolute growth numbers per year.
UN historical & projected data:
https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Graphs/1_Demographic%20Profiles/...
For a rich country like the United States, the climate change itself is survivable.
So Arizona becomes unsurvivable desert and Lousiana is lost to the sea; New York builds seawalls and subway pumps and Miami partly becomes Venice and partly Atlantis. The Great Sandhill Desert re-emerges from the plains.
Food prices increase; diets shift to accomodate -- less beef; more chicken; more vegetarianism. Diseases associated to warmer places spread: malaria and zika. Millions of people are forced to move. But civilisation itself isn't really threatened.
The civilisation-threatening problems happen in poorer countries. Population size, though growth has been slowing for decades, will not have peaked before climate change reduces carrying capacities. Waves of refugees from the resulting famines and wars will try to make their way inland and northward.
What will happen when India and Pakistan, nuclear powers both, are overwhelmed by mass displacement and food shortages? How many refugees will we accept, and how many will we turn our backs on? What will our role be in the wars?
So we are losing huge forests (which help to reduce carbon dioxide in the atmosphere by simply existing) at an unprecedented rate and we are producing more emissions by developing this land for agricultural use.
Secondly, what evidence do you have that fuel will be more expensive? The shale revolution has made gas cheap and it will stay so for a long time. You can make methanol with gas for example. The proven reserves go up of fossil fuels as well.
There is also no limit on electrical energy, we could build nuclear plants until the cows come home if that is required. France has shown that it possible and that it is not unreasonably expensive.
Even if farmland would somehow be an issue, we could easily do factory farming. The only reason we don't is that its more expensive then using land.
Where?
As I understand it, pretty much all the good farmland is already in use for farming.
The only available farmland I'm aware of that is not being used for that is being squatted upon by McMansions in the suburbs. The land they're sitting on was formerly farmland, but it was found to be more economically valuable as land for upscale homes.
Think what it would mean for those economics to be flipped around, for farmland to become more valuable than McMansion lots. It means farming has become a very high-dollar economic activity, which means food has become really expensive, which means many fewer people would be buying McMansions.
So what then is your plan? That we put almost all the human population into arcologies like the Stephenson cyberpunk novels, so that we can free up the land to be farmland again?
There is also tons of lower quality land that could be farmed if you really needed to as well.
Around 45% of corn production is used to make transport fuel rather then food. Most of Brazilian transport fuel is also made from food.
Simply put, there is HUGE amounts of potential for increase in food production.
All of this is without using advanced things like factory food production.
Also, food is not becoming more expensive other then being more expensive because of oil and transport cost.
https://thebreakthrough.org/index.php/journal/past-issues/is...
> So what then is your point? That we put almost all the human population into arcologies like the Stephenson cyberpunk novels?
No. My point is that spreading irrational fear and false facts about food availability is wrong and you should stop scaring the uninformed people.
I don't propose anything. Human can just live where they like. Buy food and energy where they want to buy it. Most move to urban centers voluntary. Only 0.5% of land is actually paved and that's where the waste majority of people live.
My point is that we have lots of energy and we have lots of food. There is no real concern that either is gone run out. There is not even a need for government to do any gigantic policies (unless they want to fix carbon emissions, then a carbon tax would easily resolve the problem).
The future will be one of more unused land that is untouched by humans and that will happen without a conservation policy.
That's consistent with my claim that all the good farmland is already taken. The shrinkage in use of farmland could be that marginal farmland is falling away due to soil exhaustion and economic effects.
> humans are becoming more urban.
That sounds like the path towards arcologies.
You can see it now: former single-family dwellings in the large cities are being rented out to groups of yuppies, each of whom, despite being high earners, would struggle to pay the rent alone. The low earners are being forced out, but to where? Where does this road lead, if not to arcologies?
> It has nothing to do with McMansions, humans are becoming more urban.
Only if you define "urban" as identical to "metropolitan area."
Take any large US city, then include its complete metropolitan area, which I'll define here as the area of continuous land surrounded by either farmland or wasteland. I'll stretch the definition of farmland to include single-family-owned parcels of land which are large enough to support small alfalfa crops, horse pasturage, etc.
How many "cities" are in that metropolitan area? Why are they called "cities," even though there is no farmland between them? I'm fundamentally a rural sort, all my life, but I've been in such areas many times, and the only way I can tell that I've traveled from one city to another is that there's a sign situated between a laundromat and a strip mall, with the city boundary going down the alley between them. Once upon a time, they were in fact separate cities.
Take Los Angeles, California as an example. In what meaningful way is Anaheim not "L.A."? I get that its streets don't look much like those of Beverly Hills or Monrovia or Pasadena, but the whole area is one urbanized mess. You used to pass through farmland to get from each of these cities to the next. As an occasional visitor to the area, "L.A" to me extends from Ventura to the north down to San Clemente in the south, and inland almost to the Salton Sea. All that former farmland is paved over now.
> There is also tons of lower quality land that could be farmed if you really needed to as well.
Less productively, by definition.
> Around 45% of corn production is used to make transport fuel rather then food.
Sure, but that's just part of the same problem: as population and wealth rises, the wish to have personal rapid transit also rises, which leads to either:
1. Greater consumption pressure on our oil reserves.
2. A switch to biofuels of some sort, which in turn puts pressure on the rest of the bioeconomy.
3. A switch to electric vehicles, which requires massive solar cell arrays and massive distributed mines for rare earths, which stresses the environment still further.
...or some combination of the three, of course.
It's all an interdependent system. You can't move one part without affecting many other parts.
> food is not becoming more expensive other then being more expensive because of oil and transport cost.
The increasing transport costs are in part because of my original premise: cities used to have nearby farms to draw from. Now that we've pushed the boundaries of so many of our conurbanizations out to the wastelands, we've got to truck in food from much farther away than before.
In the US, some of the areas of most rapid population growth are out in the desert, places like Las Vegas and Phoenix. Why do you suppose that is?
> Most move to urban centers voluntary.
Yeah, voluntary in the same way that having children work in the coal mines was "voluntary" to our forebears. They had a choice: starve or go farming. Back then, we still had much of the West available for expansion. That's largely gone now.
At the grandparent level, my family were farmers. The land they did all of that on is now sold off for houses. My forebears made the desert bloom. The thing is, though, they did it around rivers which now run dry because the remaining farms are sucking up all of the water that isn't going into the houses or being dumped back on the desert to keep all those middle-America lawns green.
You speak of increasing productivity for our existing farmland, but all increasing curves flatten out eventually. There are no exponential curves in ecologies, only S-curves that haven't started to flatten out yet. (Or, collapsing curves!)
Well if you want to disagree with all expert assessments, then feel free.
> That sounds like the path towards arcologies.
If humans voluntary adopt this, then I don't see the problem.
If people want to get a cheap large house in Texas, they can just go ahead and do that.
> Take Los Angeles, California
California is hardly the typical case. Just because you experience this locally doesn't change global statistics.
> Sure, but that's just part of the same problem: as population and wealth rises, the wish to have personal rapid transit also rises, which leads to either:
Yes. But using ethanol never made a lot of sense in the US. It purely because of politics. We are not fundamentally energy restricted, you could easily substitute ethanol for methanol for example. Gas is actually demand constraint in the US right now.
Again, we do not have a lack of energy or land supply. My example about ethanol was more to prove that we have more then enough farm land.
I don't understand what your issue with this accepting this is.
> At the grandparent level, my family were farmers. The land they did all of that on is now sold off for houses.
Again, you continue to assert completely 100% false statistics. The waste majority of land is not covered by houses. In fact there are people who are trying to recreate the North American Step because there is so much empty land.
> You speak of increasing productivity for our existing farmland, but all increasing curves flatten out eventually. There are no exponential curves in ecologies, only S-curves that haven't started to flatten out yet. (Or, collapsing curves!)
Productivity will continue to go up. We have new technology such as GMO that can make a major difference. The reality is that most of the worlds farm land is not farmed with anywhere close that efficiency. Would could have massive amount of food production growth if we had more adoption of current technology.
I really don't understand any of your arguments. We have lots of access land. We have so much land we can use part of it for ethanol and another huge part for meat. If there were any real constraint on food production, those things would change. Its the same in other countries, Britain used to be intensively farmed and now they are talking about establishing a prehistoric forest across the whole for northern Britain because they DON'T NEED LAND TO FARM. Its the same in many countries. That is a simple fact, however much you want to invent stories about your grand parents farm. WE ARE NOT CONSTRAINT IN THE AVAILABILITY OF FARM LAND!
Even if land was the issue, we could still do very efficient factory farming where land is not a constraint at all.
In general, people has been proportional spending less money on food for each decade that has gone past. Production per acer has also gone up, while the number of people working as farmers has significant dropped.
I am pretty sure that the reason why there is not more potato farmers in the world is because the price of potatoes are not high enough to utilize all the land where potatoes can be grown.
But even if we somehow run out of land we would still not need to build arcologies. The primary reason we don't have many seaweed farms in the world is because few cultures has seaweed as an primary diet. Economics could likely change that.
Would you be able to explain why that is, or link to something that can? It's not immediately obvious to me why that would be.
Of course, human activity could speed up the transition for these areas, but soil building is a quirky technology that's hard to scale up.
Some land is lost in X, and gained in Y. That land in Y will be close to where farming currently happens and with a delay of a couple of years the farmers can extend northwards a little bit.
I can't see how such a slow process could lead to a 'shortfall'.
In most of the world farming is limited by water and fertiliser availability. Water availability is an increasing problem from California to Yemen.
The higher temperatures will also be melting mountain snowpack earlier, so the highly variable rivers that feed much of our irrigation will be getting dry by late June rather than the first week of August with serious impact to crops.
Not so much the sea level, as the effect in change in average temperature; many plants have their reproduction cycles triggered by particular temperatures. The boundaries between different types of ecosystem are determined by temperature range. It will also make a difference to which crops are viable in which areas.
It makes rather a lot more difference if you think of it not as "each day is 2C warmer than the corresponding day of the previous year" but instead "most days are the same temperature but some are warmer by enough to wipe out the local staple crop".
One problem with a single headline number is that this is an average temperature rise. What we're actually seeing is a mixture of things: more energy accumulating in the hydrosphere and atmosphere means more energetic weather events (e.g. powerful hurricanes/typhoons). Some areas warming lead to other areas cooling (e.g. melting Arctic ice cap and meltwater outflow from the Greenland ice cap may lead to temporary shutdown of the North Atlantic thermohaline circulation and a Gulf Stream stall, freezing the British Isles and Western Europe with a -5 to -10 celsius temperature drop in the short term -- meaning, decades to centuries). So there'll be a rise in the incidence of weather/climate related disasters.
Another problem is that we can't simply shift agriculture to new, thawed territories. The Canadian Shield and Siberian Tundra are pretty poor soil, unsuited to intensive wheat/corn growing: it might be possible to condition them, but it'd take decades to centuries of hard work, during which other agricultural territory (the US mid-west and south, much of Asia and sub-Saharan Africa) will be subject to lethal heat emergencies. Lethal not so much for humans -- we know how to build solar-powered air conditioning -- but for crops and livestock which will die in the fields.
Suggestions that we're one supermarket supply chain collapse away from the end of civilization are obviously bogus. But if we start having large-scale crop failures 3-5 times a decade, food prices will soar globally, leading eventually to civil unrest and war. (For example, the Arab Spring was to some extend a side-effect of the 2007-08 global financial crisis, as capital sought refuge in commodity futures and the price of bread throughout the Middle East doubled-to-tripled in twelve months: what will 2-4 consecutive wheat harvest failures accomplish?) Infrastructure damage (including agricultural infrastructure) due to strife and mass migration will in turn increase our dependence on surviving infrastructure, reducing our overall resilience. And there may eventually come a tipping point at which we end up in a positive-feedback loop of mutually reinforcing failures.
The issue is that, while climate change at UN COP21-23 estimates isn't necessarily an existential threat to Western society, it 1.) has exceptionally real effects on individuals who are affected (and those who are going to be affected in the near future) and 2.) requires an enormous amount of investment and development to manage the transition from a pre 2C rise to a post 2C rise.
When you're looking at having to protect at least 20K+ square km of land and ~150-200M people, some amount of directness is acceptable.
Saying "200mm of people will migrate or die" (assuming its true) would be direct, but the "we are all doomed" is very misleading because the effects are not universal and not evenly distributed. The described scenarios will not cause doom to me, and most likely to you as well.
Furthermore, even for the politicians that have completely publicly accepted the notion of climate change, statements like "requires an enormous amount of investment and development to manage the transition" and "having to protect at least 20K+ square km of land and ~150-200M people" are simply literally false - they can (and possibly will) choose not to protect that land and those people, because they're "others". They have the ability to choose not investing in managing that transition globally, but only handling the direct local consequences, and protect their population from the global effects simply by investing into armaments/defence industry - as Dr. Hillman is saying in the original article, "How are these regions going to respond? We see it now. Migrants will be prevented from arriving. We will let them drown." Looking at some of our global leaders, such a scenario seems at least possible.
You can read my attempt at a primer, which details some of the consequences here : https://climate.btmx.fr
For example the Younger Dryas¹, about 15ky ago. The best estimate is global temp dropped 2-6° over 50 years and 1000 years later, did the opposite. Before that our data is so poor it's hard to distinguish between 1000 years and 1 year.
[1] https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/abrupt-climate-change/The%20Younge...
We have been figthing to survive nature from the start. Ex. sea rise is not a problem that can't be solved just look at Holland.
What is your point in saying this? Everything always has uncertainties, but scientists and economists are in agreement there is enough known that we need large changes in energy use (which affects all sectors of the economy). That is found in the latest version of the report you linked to, or even the version you linked.
The idea that Bangladesh can "solve" sea level rise because Holland can is laughable. Just look at these maps: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2015/08/bjorn-...
Of course Holland and Bangladesh isn't the same situation so to call your own strawman laughable says a lot about where you are coming from in this.
But against my better judgement I am still engaging in the hopes that you are in fact interested in hearing what my point is.
Yes everything has uncertainties which would be good to remember in this debate as thats the difference between whether we are doomed or whether the climate will change as I has always done and we need to adjust to it. Instead of trying to claim that we know for a fact what the outcome is, how big our involvement in climate change is, how much we can do something about.
Even the IPCC does not deal in such certainties and have toned down their doomsdaying over the years. That's important to keep in mind before we all jump on the "we are doomed" bandwagon.
There are things we can do especially these days as we are much better at handling nature than we were 100 years ago which means that no matter how much of climate change is manmade we have a better chance of dealing with the consequences today than if those changes had happened 100 years ago.
I can’t in good conscience call them fun, “terrifying” would be a bit more accurate
This is from a scenario where the world warms by 4 degrees. Other parts of the world, e.g. Western Australia and Canada, would benefit. See http://bigthink.com/strange-maps/what-the-world-will-look-li...
Large animal populations (> ~10kg) have responded poorly to larger ones, of the scale we're facing in < 100 years.
Good earlier discussion, and links:
"Future climate will depend on committed warming caused by past anthropogenic emissions, as well as future anthropogenic emissions and natural climate variability. The global mean surface temperature change for the period 2016–2035 relative to 1986–2005 is similar for the four RCPs and will likely be in the range 0.3°C to 0.7°C (medium confidence). This assumes that there will be no major volcanic eruptions or changes in some natural sources (e.g., CH4 and N2O), or unexpected changes in total solar irradiance. By mid-21st century, the magnitude of the projected climate change is substantially affected by the choice of emissions scenario. {2.2.1, Table 2.1} Relative to 1850–1900, global surface temperature change for the end of the 21st century (2081–2100) is projected to likely exceed 1.5°C for RCP4.5, RCP6.0 and RCP8.5 (high confidence). Warming is likely to exceed 2°C for RCP6.0 and RCP8.5 (high confidence), more likely than not to exceed 2°C for RCP4.5 (medium confidence), but unlikely to exceed 2°C for RCP2.6 (medium confidence). {2.2.1} The increase of global mean surface temperature by the end of the 21st century (2081–2100) relative to 1986–2005 is likely to be 0.3°C to 1.7°C under RCP2.6, 1.1°C to 2.6°C under RCP4.5, 1.4°C to 3.1°C under RCP6.0 and 2.6°C to 4.8°C under RCP8.59 . The Arctic region will continue to warm more rapidly than the global mean (Figure SPM.6a, Figure SPM.7a). {2.2.1, Figure 2.1, Figure 2.2, Table 2.1} It is virtually certain that there will be more frequent hot and fewer cold temperature extremes over most land areas on daily and seasonal timescales, as global mean surface temperature increases. It is very likely that heat waves will occur with a higher frequency and longer duration. Occasional cold winter extremes will continue to occur. {2.2.1}"
https://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar5/syr/SYR_AR5_FI...
It's really difficult to overestimate the level of damage something like this would do to society. Picture half the population of humanity starving to death in famines or being killed in combat over water resources.
And yes, you're right, photosynthesis would probably cease. We're going to see similar problems in the opposite direction, probably drought on a scale heretofore never experienced in human history in temperate areas. Imagine the climate of Los Angeles moving north to Vancouver BC, and similar cascading effects across the board.
Katrina was "just" a local event.
And see how civilization respond to this.
Now, think what will happend if we get this kind of events more often, EVERYWHERE. AT THE SAME-ish TIME.
I completely accept the evidence and the consensus that human action is causing global carbon levels and therefore temperature to rise. The part I don't get is what exactly happens to the planet, our species and other animals given say, a 2C rise by 2200. Say that's a 2 metre sea level rise. Ecosystems and societies are pretty robust to that level of change over 200 years. There would be very bad effects on some low-lying coastal cities, and the areas of the earth that are productive for different kinds of agriculture and habitats would change.
This is bad and we should work to avoid it, but I think that we lose credibility when we speak of the end of civilisation, or even major threats to our normal way of life globally.