Unfortunatelt neither fb nor twitter are really designed to support forum style interaction. No list of topics and threads
tldr: Facebooks ability to reach beyond the sort of people that sign up for forums can be very useful in certain important scenarios.
It's not necessary — and I think it's harmful — for that network to be controlled on the whim of one person (assuming you accept that Zuckerberg isn't a robot or a lizard or something).
What if this group was in Reddit and all of a sudden the mod, on a whim, locked all the threads? What if this group met in the local community center and the building owner, on a whim, decided to sell the building to someone who didn't want such groups to meet there?
Someone has to be in charge of a "single communication network". If your community owes its existence to it, they are at their whim, and in a way, that's the cost of doing business. This isn't unique to Facebook or Mark Zuckerberg. If the community is strong, they can find a way to overcome such whims.
This is false. Pen, paper, English and walking is a communication network.
If there are multiple competing implementations of a shared spec, in practice no one group can control it. (This is why it's important to have multiple competing web browser engines.)
My point is, Facebook is a de-facto standard for almost any non-technical community these days, and if not Facebook, then it's some other social platform, like Whatsapp or Telegram. Turns out, centralized platforms are much more user-friendly, have better network effects and easier to set up and administer for majority of users.
https://www.fakenamegenerator.com/
This will give you everything facebook wants.
This is where all of the anti-facebook sentiment loses me. Just put fake data in there.
Is this unique to Facebook? I'll grant that FB is really good at it, but who isn't trying to track you, to sell your info, to target ads to you? If you use a smartphone, a web browser, supermarket loyalty program, etc., is there a way around this?
It just doesn't make any sense to me how people expect that you can use a web service without the webservice like...knowing that you're using it?
Reddit knows what subreddits I'm subbed to. Usenet servers know what groups I post to. Gmail knows what email I get (sortof) etc.
If I didn't want anybody to know that I was interested in amateur radio, then I wouldn't post to /r/amateuradio with my real name.
This is a classic "have your cake and eat it too". You can't both share your real name with people and also not share your real name with those same people at the same time.
It is not as simple as you are making out because of
1. The vast amount of meta data that can be mined from your browser requests, scripts running on sites, your logging into multiple devices.
2. The scripts that run on other sites when you are not using FB, that know your FB identity or might send data back to FB. Safe to assume it's being shared with 3rd parties. Safe to assume those parties are in different countries with different laws.
3. The amount of computational power FB has, machine learning technology etc.
4. What we learned from Snowden.
It is naive to think of giving information to Facebook as being the same as giving it to a small community site running PHPBB.
There are personal privacy concerns, as well as aggregate ones. I.e. by being on facebook you are helping other's to have less privacy unless you use it in a very restricted way.
This is true, but what you seem to disregard is that [webservice] can monetize differently.
You can set up your own forum for almost free, or your community could pool a couple of bucks each month for server cost.
You can use some experimental p2p mesh hosting for your conversations.
You can charge users a low low price for the cost of your service.
Or you can sell userdata like facebook et al.
All these services would know everything I'm willing to share with users on said service, but how that data is used could be very different.
Wanting to both share your data and have that data used scrupulously isn't having/eating your cake. It's very reasonable and possible. Maybe not for free, but close to.
A specific example: a local tabletop gaming store has a 'Facebook community' but no alternative forum. There is potential friendship and worthwhile discourse to be had by joining the community, but it is not accessible without joining Facebook.
This problem just doesn't seem significant because so many are already in the 'Facebook community' already. It's not that Facebook set the rules or defines the community, it's that they own the front door and you need their key to enter.