http://37signals.com/manifesto
I find myself in agreement with most of what they say. I do not need to filter. I do not need to internally think "Oh, there they go again, leaving it to me to translate their thoughts into something normal."
Their style has gotten more extreme over time. They have been bent out of shape by their success. They seem increasingly convinced that their experience allows them to speak with authority about everyone's startup experience.
http://blog.jgc.org/2009/05/can-you-trust-37signals-with-you...
The 2 year lag on that deserves some explanation.
"I don't understand why our industry seems to be afraid of profits, which really just means you make more money than you spend."
http://smallbusiness.aol.com/2010/05/26/37-signals-jason-fri...
The accusation is that people in the tech industry are "afraid" of making profits. Of course, we all know that people in the tech industry are experimenting with models where it might be possible to make large profits by giving something away for free. Twitter is free but potentially it is worth a great deal. But the nuances get lost in the writing that the 37 Signals crew engages in.
37signals is becoming one of the most accomplished trolls on the internet. The first (non patent) corporate troll? Surely they can't be, but I can't think of another.
The sad thing is, they have interesting things to talk about. But today, just like yesterday, they go for the cheap thrills of a spicy headline over having a substantive discussion about things that are important.
In the short term, this generates pageviews and, potentially, sales. In the long term, it just makes them look like schmucks. Through the tone of their blog, I've gone from having a decent opinion of 37signals to being entirely unwilling to ever work with or for them. They just seem more like zealots than they do fun guys.
Is alienating tech professionals really the best strategy for their business?
Joel Spolsky wrote once about how if you're going to make an airtight argument, it takes so long to list all the caveats that all the power is out of it.
But that doesn't make it any less tiring... my mental output filter requires a decent amount of effort to keep going and makes things more verbose...
"Is alienating tech professionals really the best strategy for their business?"
How many people does this sort of post actually alienate? From what I can tell, 37signals' customers are primarily small businesses who enjoy the "rail against the behemoth" approach.
I wouldn't call them $word, just definition($word)[1]?
IMO writers often care about controversy because they make money based on engagement and get better responses if people are passionate about the subject. I don't think this harms their legitimacy as a writer it just provides a poor motive. Trolls on the other hand want to maximise engagement as it gives them a sort of sadistic pleasure, they do it for free.
At the same time, controversy over substance feels like the cheap way to have a conversation. It feels exploitative, instead of virtuous. I find more enjoyment in, say, Paul Graham's measured, thoughtful approach to a subject. It feels like I'm reading someone who respects me and respects the conversation he is joining. It's entirely possible to voice powerful disagreement without being inflammatory.
If 37signals wants to be the Howard Stern of tech blogging, that's an entirely reasonable position. It can be entertaining to watch and I'm sure it's fun to write. It's just not for me.
"Having an enemy gives you a great story to tell customers, too. Taking a stand always stands out. People get stoked by conflict. They take sides. Passions are ignited. And that’s a good way to get people to take notice."
I get that 37 Signals is successful. But I think their writing does their software no favors. If anything I'd be more tempted to not purchase product from a company like this.
Their market segment is the small biz and they write stuff about how to run one. This is a blog topic segment that is super-saturated, ranging from PG's essays to "get rich quick!" blogs. So 37s made a choice to get notice (and gain leads for more BaseCamp subs) in this arena by any means.
Yes, you can argue it is at the expense of audience deciding NOT to become a customer due to opposing their view. But this is the gamble they are taking. They are betting that most people are able to separate having an opposing opinion from seeing the value of being a paying customer of their products.
Here is why their style works:
We read the exaggeration and translate it from 37Signals to the reasonable thing we expect they are trying to say. For example, he might be saying:
* "Buying ideas/talent rarely works out"
* "Buying ideas/talent only works if you pay with culture"
* "Buying ideas/talent can't work if the buyer is big"
So when we encounter a 37Signals post and generally disagree with it, there is easy fuel for our side of the argument. Those that agree with the general idea get to argue for their favorite interpretation of what they must be saying.
The imprecision and tone creates two sides maximally equipped to have a stupid internet discussion.