The companies are fully or partially state owned, so the political pressure may be greater. https://qz.com/1000541/norway-wants-china-to-forget-about-th...
You do not want to give too much power to a single actor. Doesn't matter if this is China, USA, EU.
"Greece was one of the early flashpoints for Germany's concern about the growing competition from China. Benefiting from Beijing's large direct investments, Greece blocked last June an EU statement at the United Nations about China's repressive human rights policies."
"Hungary, where China is building a high-speed railway line from Budapest to Belgrade, joined Greece to block another EU statement criticizing China's territorial claims in the South China Sea, after The Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled against Beijing in July 2016."
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/16/chinas-growing-economic-pres...
Sounds like an assault on Europe. But let me help you look at it objectively.
"Germany's concern about the growing competition from China" <-- Isn't this protectionism? This isn't political influence, but that Germany is shying away from genuine free market competition. Germany benefits at the expense of Greece. Germany is unfair in how it plays the game
"block another EU statement criticizing China's territorial claims in the South China Sea" <-- This is political, yet it doesn't affected EU. Why is EU so concerned about China's backyard anyway. Imagine if China picks sides in Europe's petty fights like Catalan independence, and brexit, etc. To me it's European overreach (just like Americans), and the less of this the better.
It seems reasonable, upon observing a growing trend in Chinese ownership of one's domestic economy, to want to formulate a plan to monitor and understand that trend, and to be ready to regulate or mitigate it if it proves to be pernicious to to have unwanted consequences.
And, while I cannot say that I know what is in the minds of those officials in Europe, i suppose the main difference (as compared to US or middle eastern companies) might be the suddenness/newness of the trend and the rate at which they are buying up the economy.
Of course, this could be the "Summer of the Shark", as discussed in an HN thread last week.
It's fair to scrutinize the investments and how the investors behave. This is not unexpected or unreasonable, since China itself also generally insists that outside countries stay out of China's internal decision making processes and domestic governance.
It's well known that China's companies are controlled to a relatively great extent by its government. And the priorities, values and goals of the ruling party of China differ from those of the EU.
When local EU priorities, values and goals come into conflict with those of China's government and, by extension, China's investment companies, it's reasonable for the EU to be concerned about pressure and influence from the government of China.
Here's an example:
"China has long won diplomatic allies in the world’s poor countries by helping them build expensive roads and ports. Now, it appears to have similarly won over a needy country in Europe.
At a meeting of the United Nations Human Rights Council this month in Geneva, the European Union sought to draw renewed attention to human rights abuses in China — only to be blocked by one of its member countries, Greece. A spokesman for the Greek Foreign Ministry in Athens called it “unproductive criticism.”"
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/19/world/europe/china-human-...
I would suspect it's because a lot of China's foreign buying spree involves state owned/controlled companies. If the US used the Federal Open Market Committee to purchase big chunks of foreign assets, especially in "critical" infrastructure, other countries might start to get a little worried.
Though, honestly, we brought it on ourselves -- China has ~4 trillion in foreign reserves which we happily gave to them in exchange for cheap consumer gadgets (totally ignoring why the government has these funds instead of the producers of said gadgets) which we've always known they would someday want to cash in on some real goods. Well, it turns out they like to buy "critical infrastructure" so woe is us.
Yet if you look at the data objectively, Chinese companies (both private and state-owned) are just playing by the rules of the western market economy. They are purchasing and investing, playing the capitalist game just like everybody else.
The west also has state-owned enterprises. In Canada, we call them crown corporations (e.g., Bombardier). Yet whenever a corporation is owned by a western government, tons of waste happens and somehow our companies rarely make products that are competitive with the global market. They are just not competitive.
So it seems to me that China and their companies are playing the capitalist game better than EU, and the core of EU are being sour grapes.
In some ways, this kind of thing improves international relations. You're less likely to fight with a country you own a lot of businesses in, but make the decision just because China has a lot of money seems short sighted. It seems likely the cash will be short lived compared to the transfer of industry and property.
The very concept of a common strategy is something that China will likely win on, since they have more centralized decision making.
pretty simple: They aren't part of the free-market democracy petrodollar regime..
I guess I missed something. When exactly did we decide that China advancing on Europe was a bad thing? Was that before or after the trade deals? Was it before or after every world leader went to china begging for them to invest in western economies? If we are going to have some grand plan to deal with something, we need to first decide whether the thing is good or bad. We haven't done that. Do we want to limit China's spread or not? I have my opinion, but my opinion is not consensus. Before we move to limit China's growth, I want to see the open statement as to why that growth is a bad thing.
At the moment stories like this seems to take for granted that the reader will understand it as some nebulous evil that must be addressed. I worry that that assumption relies upon fears that we dare not express openly. Gut feeling and "smell tests" are too often cover for darker motivations. Few complain about middle eastern or american companies buying up europe. What exactly is so different about China?