> Trimet says that implementing its technology across Germany’s four aluminum smelters, three of which it owns, could provide a demand response capacity equal to a third of Germany’s 40 gigawatt-hours of pumped hydro storage.
There was a lot of confusion about this one when it was published, but as the article points out, they're not using their molten aluminium pools as a liquid battery - they're merely dynamically adjusting the electricity usage of their hydrolysis cells, which also requires some other adjustments to keep the process going, but it's still a lot of power and more responsive than what they do today (which involves taking the smelters entirely offline for short periods).
It helps that their test plant is near Hamburg in the North, "close" to most of Germany's wind turbine capacity which helps alleviate transmission/interconnection problems to the South.
[1] https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/german-firm-tur...
The UK is already up to about 15% of its electricity from wind right now, these developments will open that up significantly more. Obviously at high levels of penetration there are going to be issues, we'll just have to see how far we can go, but even 25-40% of electricity would be a huge contribution.
Combine that with the new and existing nuclear, another 15%, some biomass and tidal lagoons, with the rest from gas (which produces half as much CO2 as coal) and it will go a long way towards meeting the UK's 80% CO2 reduction target from 1990 to 2050.
There's also various news articles reporting on German mines beginning to be used as pumped storage sites, with a reservoir on the surface, and water dropping into the mines below when there's sudden demand.
This is a good problem to have, though.
(NB: I didn't check whether the power output of this battery is enough to actually meet demand, but wikipedia says it can run at full capacity for 22 hours, so no)
Unfortunately two weeks without much wind are common in general weather patterns. Thus my gut reaction is it isn't enough. However we are now talking weather where local patterns are the important thing which means each situation needs to be considered separately.
(I've been to Cruachan, well worth the visit even though you can't walk around the turbine hall any more)
But indeed, as the amount of renewal energy production increases, more storage is needed. Perhaps less so for wind which has a more smooth output over days, but for solar, which has a strong peak over noon and of course shuts down alltogether in the evening. Distributing the solar curve over more time of the day would be very useful.
There are also many nuclear plants perfectly capable of "load following", responding in the time frame of minutes to 10's of minutes to load changes.
In the UK, all of our nuclear power plants operate at their design capacity all the time. Their output only changes during scheduled periods when they are shut down for maintenance, refuelling, etc.
In contrast, all of the remaining coal-fired power plants in the UK effectively operate as load-following reserve. They ramp up only on cold winter days when demand is high and when wind generation is low. There are now many "coal free" days in the warmer months where there is no coal-fired power generation in the UK at all (it looks like today will be one of them!)
This is one reason why I'm skeptical for home production of solar and wind for the ability to "feed back" into the grid while getting a credit on your account.
If the power company is also doing this, at scale, I find it really hard to believe that there's no reason the power company won't discredit/discount my rates being returned to the grid.
In which case, I'd rather have a battery installation and not rely on the power company at all.
Most service reps for solar disagree with me. Maybe because battery storage isn't super common/in their inventory?
Are you OK with using the grid as a highly-reliable, ~infinite capacity power source to smooth over your uneven solar generation at a cost of selling your excess back at a discounted rate,
or
do you want to try and capture that discount yourself at the cost of having to buy, install and maintain your own integrated battery backup system?
Maybe the calculus works out in your favor for you, specifically. Maybe not. But it's good to have options.
Though I rarely experience power outages, knowing almost all instances would be non-existent is really nice (for a battery backup program), especially as more and more heating solutions are using electricity as the main component (heat pumps; winter power failures are most of the power failures for me).
I think they're an efficient use of market based tools to ensure that the group who can reduce the input to the grid does so, and to incentivize electricity production that can meet the flexible demands of the grid (e.g. slow ramping coal would be penalised over fast ramping gas without any regulation needing to specifically target the coal and the coal plant can do anything it wants to improve this, e.g. fit batteries, since no technology is mandated.
Negative prices are a helpful market signal, but must be combined with battery storage requirements.
They are the solution to that problem, not part of the problem.
As for batteries, there needs to be an economic incentive for people to invest in deploying batteries (or any other type of storage). Negative prices are that incentive. Negative prices don't need batteries, batteries need negative pricing.
Of course with a lower reservoir, you can go into negative territory instead of "just" taking the plant down to 0.
EDIT: with the one caveat of transmission capacity, which certainly can be an issue.
Prices go negative in the US at times and in Germany more often. That is exactly when something like this would be used: to store that capacity.
The original point was that you do not need to have a reservoir to pump from to take advantage of the fast start/stop capability of a hydro plant: Closing the sluice gates and/or bypassing the turbines is sufficient to reduce supply by the generating capacity of the plant.
Having a reservoir as the potential to significantly increase the reduction in excess supply you can handle, that is true, but the lack of that option does not change the benefit of shutting off generating capacity.
Hydro plants have been used to adjust grid supply for as long as they have existed in this way. Not least because with grid prices adjusting dynamically, as long as the reservoir is not full, most hydro plants yield better economic result if they respond to falling prices by letting the reservoir water levels build back up.
The point is to not turn off generation capacity that we don't control the start of, like wind. Why should we not generate if the wind is blowing at night?
That's the entire point: That hydro plants can act as storage even if there's no lower reservoir to pump from. Which means they're good fast response plants exactly so that types of plants where turning them off wastes potential energy, like wind farms, can keep running.
The original claim I took issue with, was that a hydro plant can't serve this purpose without a second reservoir, which is not true - a second reservoir can be used to increase total effective storage capacity, and to make the plant increase demand rather than just decrease supply, but a hydro plant on itself can improve grid responsiveness, given enough transmission capacity.
> You are taking power off the grid: The power otherwise produced by the hydro plant. > > Of course with a lower reservoir, you can go into negative territory instead of "just" taking the plant down to 0.
In other words, my point from the beginning was that there is - absent transmissions limitations - no conceptual difference in the outcome of stopping a damn and pumping into a reservoir, as I've gone into at great length in the subsequent comments.
At a hydro plant you have multiple options: You can bypass the turbines; you can close the dam, as long as it's not near capacity; if you have a lower reservoir you can close the dam and pump water up to the upper reservoir. All of these help reduce the excess supply, but pumping up does so by increasing demand and reducing supply, and the other two options reduce supply.
You can of course do pumped storage without normally producing electricity too - in places where the only convenient location for a reservoir is not "in line" with a water source with sufficient fall height, you can still pump up to a convenient location, in which case the plant is basically "only" storage.
Going from $0.20 per kWh $0.05 to per kWh only increases profits by 50%
http://whattomine.com/coins/151-eth-ethash?utf8=%E2%9C%93&hr...
vs
http://whattomine.com/coins/151-eth-ethash?utf8=%E2%9C%93&hr...
and going from 0.05 to -0.05 only increases it by 20%
http://whattomine.com/coins/151-eth-ethash?utf8=%E2%9C%93&hr...
By the way, these mining calculators are very "optimistic" but for relative comparisons they are sufficient. In practice you will get significantly less because of increasing difficulty and hidden costs like motherboards, CPUs, etc.
(1) Cheap, large scale storage of electric energy might be a big game changer.
(2) Without such storage, basically a country has to notice what their peak load is and assume that they have installed capacity that is reliable, e.g., independent of the weather, and meets this peak load.
(3) So, net, intermittent sources such as wind and solar don't much lower the capital expense needed. That is, the country still needs the same capacity to meet peak loads without the intermittent sources. So for this capacity they can use nuclear fission, coal, oil, natural gas, hydro, geo-thermal, and that's about it.
So, net, when power from intermittent sources is available, then get to save on the fuel cost of fission, coal, oil, and natural gas and accumulate some water behind hydro. So, e.g., a big fission or coal plant is still there, still with its capital expense and operating expense but is running at reduced power and, thus, saving on direct fuel costs.
At that point, I'm wondering if, really, just for the money part, if the intermittent sources are wanted on the grid even for free.
There is an issue about the intermittent sources: They are not very predictable and, thus, can cause some grid stability problems. E.g., IIRC, can't just change the power level of a fission or coal plant minute by minute to match the minute by minute fluctuation in the intermittent sources; so, can get some grid instability, and that is bad stuff for the whole grid and country.
E.g. in Germany, they frequently have days of negative energy prices, where producers need to pay to feed energy into the greed because of overproduction of energy on windy/sunny days [0](in German). Without storage and grid interconnection, there is only so much renewable energy from intermittent sources like wind and solar you can handle.
[0]: https://blog.energybrainpool.com/bereits-103-mal-in-2017-neg...