News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by staplers on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:12PM (#16887110)

  When did you last get 100Mbit+ speeds with 4G?
In a real world scenario, I would max out my data cap in 5 minutes.. Telcos will never give up their guaranteed profits by throttling speeds even with unlimited speed/capacity.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by roenxi on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:09PM (#16888802)
This claim just seems ... unlikely and counter to economics. Prices dropping isn't about business owners deciding they feel nice, it is about the fact that consumers reward cheap producers. If the producers refuse to drop prices when thy can, then the first person to break into the market doing something different will get crazy profits.

I would liken the situation to 2007 in Australia. Sending instant messages was basically free from the telco's perspectives - but they charged 20c or something to the sender. Insane margins.

The first company that I remember challenging that was Apple, who bypassed the whole business and enabled essentially free text messages with iMessage. 10 years later, the markup on using text messages seems to have been completely wiped out. Apple also happened to be the most profitable company in the world through that period.

Sure, iMessage isn't linked directly to the profits, yet somehow the invisible hand seems to have been working.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by CountSessine on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:44PM (#16888926)
If the producers refuse to drop prices when thy can, then the first person to break into the market doing something different will get crazy profits

Market entry is difficult because it's gated by spectrum availability. It's hard for new competitors to offer wireless services. The market for wireless services in most countries is very cozy - it's usually one or two incumbent carriers that are about the same size, own about the same amount of spectrum, and don't work very hard to take market share from each other. I would argue that in a lot of cases, wireless services markets are stuck in a Nash equilibrium.

Smart regulation that might fix this would be to outlaw service contracts and cancellation fees to allow consumers to exploit pricing 'mistakes' (which is how you'd break a Nash equilibrium), and maybe force the carriers to re-bid on their spectrum every 5 years. Unfortunately another common problem with wireless services is regulatory capture - in my country, all the regulators who watch the wireless industry also end up working for it.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Rjevski on Saturday April 21, 2018 @04:57AM (#16890604)
My dream startup is a next generation telco (without the usual data cap bullshit) but I have yet to crack the spectrum problem. Spectrum is auctioned off by the government and it's hard to compete with the existing players; we're talking amounts close to billions here, and that kind of money is not easy to come by, even from VCs.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by nojvek on Friday April 20, 2018 @09:27PM (#16889529)
Whatsapp also was born around that period. They were ridiculously faster than SMS delivery too with images and other media.

There’s a reason it got bought for 22 billion. The telcos were digging their own walled garden grave.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:24PM (#16887232)
> I would max out my data cap in 5 minutes

Counterargument: there are fundamental reasons for data caps. To provide service at a high speed to lots of people at a reasonable price, edge-case data users must be throttled. Increasing capacity reduces the number of users who must be throttled.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wlesieutre on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:37PM (#16887370)
Then they should apply caps or throttling during hours when capacity is a concern and let me download 100 GB of games from Steam between 4 and 7 AM when the Netflix watchers have gone to bed.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Stratoscope on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:29PM (#16887794)
That's a bit like how T-Mobile does it. You get 50GB/month that is always at full speed, and then after that you get deprioritized if you're on a busy tower.

So it doesn't depend on time of day, but how many other customers are sharing your tower.

https://www.t-mobile.com/customer/mydatausage.html

> Data prioritization will only be noticeable when you access a congested tower and have used over 50GB of data in a particular billing cycle. You will continue to get unlimited high speed data on your smartphone when you aren’t accessing a congested tower. In that way it’s different from data throttling, which slows you down for the remainder of your bill cycle regardless of network conditions, all the time.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:41AM (#16890011)
That's tantalizingly close, but the goal is a plan that lets you use low-priority downloads to avoid using up your full-speed data allowance.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wlesieutre on Saturday April 21, 2018 @09:00PM (#16894203)
Yeah, there are two aspects that keep me from ditching Comcast at my apartment. Burning through the data limit on bulk downloads that I'm happy to run overnight when it's not congested, and ping, which is the harder one to fix. But it's not _that_ bad on T-mobile, so if it weren't for the data allowance problem I might be willing to suck it up.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wlesieutre on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:59PM (#16888038)
I'm on an old 5GB then throttled plan from T-mobile, the new ones sound pretty good if they didn't cost more than twice as much.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by EpicEng on Friday April 20, 2018 @05:32PM (#16888594)
Crazy that you'd have to pay more for 10x the data and higher speeds...
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wlesieutre on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:12PM (#16889061)
I already have LTE and don’t need 50GB, but their cheapest single line if I were signing up today is $45/month for 4GB.

So yes, I’d expect cell service to get either cheaper or better over time instead of more expensive and worse.

It looks like MintSIM is the cheap option now, they do 5GB for $30 or 10GB for $38.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by nojvek on Friday April 20, 2018 @09:33PM (#16889547)
I’m paying $100 flat rate for 3 lines. About $33/line for unlimited calls, text and data.

T-mobile doesn’t even charge for roaming on a whole bunch of countries. In my Australia vacation I didn’t even need to buy a new SIM card. Whatsapp and google maps all the way.

Their speeds also beat Sprint and AT&T. It’s the only carrier I have faith that screws it’s consumers the least.

AT&T has my blood on its hands by charging me $500 for roaming in Canada when I didn’t even cross the border.

T-mobile is a night and day difference.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Camillo on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:50PM (#16889209)
The problem is that T-Mobile has poor coverage. Enticing me to switch away from my cheap pre-paid T-Mobile plan actually works against them, because at that point I'll absolutely switch to another carrier.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by kzrdude on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:42PM (#16887903)
That's a very good deal. Is that a standard or expensive subscription?
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by ac29 on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:58PM (#16888032)
It's their standard ONE plan: $70/month for 1 line, but much cheaper with more (for four lines its $160/month).

Tmobile does have some prepaid plans and older grandfathered plans, but the ONE plan is pretty good, especially at the multi-line rates.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wlesieutre on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:02PM (#16888058)
Any carriers do better pricing for a single line with high caps? $840/year on service for a single phone feels crazy to me.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by oscilloscope on Friday April 20, 2018 @06:06PM (#16888791)
You'd probably need to go with an MVNO plan like PagePlus or Mint SIM.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Analemma_ on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:15PM (#16887692)
They do, or at least T-Mobile does: their unlimited plan throttles you once you exceed X gigabytes in a month (I believe X is 25), but only when the cell is congested.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by mbruce on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:58PM (#16888027)
Counter - counter argument: data caps fundamentally help segment users and make more $$$ from those who value more data. This doesn’t directly relate to capping download rate. Related: Growth on total users and downloads is far far greater than improved spectral capacity in 5G and hence more cells are needed to improve capacity. So costs not only to refresh, but to build more cells are significant.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by TheCoelacanth on Saturday April 21, 2018 @07:45PM (#16893999)
If you were going to make bandwidth costs actually based on costs to provide service, you would probably end up with something similar to the way that electricity is priced. A connection fee plus a metered rate that varies to be higher during periods of high demand and lower during periods of low demand. The data cap model is pretty clearly designed just to extract extra money from customers, not as a genuine way of fairly allocating costs.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by metalliqaz on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:37PM (#16887365)
That might make sense IF the caps only applied during times of congestion.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by Rjevski on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:00AM (#16890613)
This can be solved by selling plans by speed instead of data caps; ie, you pay for a guaranteed speed (like 1Mbps) and can use it as much as you want. The more speed you buy the more expensive it gets, with the full LTE speed being crazy expensive as you'd essentially be buying out the entire tower in that case (but then again, who needs 150Mbps+? I'd be happy with a stable 10Mbps to be honest, for mobile there is rarely a need for more).
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by wyldfire on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:23PM (#16887223)
The cap that they set is a function of their capacity. If we use spectrum more efficiently, prices can drop or caps can go up.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by jhayward on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:04PM (#16889022)
This is an unsupported assertion. Most caps are not sensitive to the environment they are consumed in, whether bandwidth tight or bandwidth plenty.
Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by sanmon3186 on Friday April 20, 2018 @11:35PM (#16889864)
>I would max out my data cap in 5 minutes..

It is important to note that data is not consumed at the same speed it is downloaded at.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by nickysielicki on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:25PM (#16887770)
What are you suggesting? If it's that there's some market-wide conspiracy to provide worse service for the sake of long-term profits, there's zero evidence to back that. Cell phone plans have gotten significantly better in the past decades, and most people are able to pay less and get a better level of service. Things have gotten better and cheaper, because there is competition, and there is always going to be market pressure that pushes them to provide better service at lower costs than their competitors. Or are you suggesting that you think there is going to be a new development of a price-fixing conspiracy among telecoms in the next few years?

Alternatively, are you suggesting (on a website that is ostensibly about venture capitalism) that the entire foundation of economics and markets is shakey?

I hate when these anti-market socialist/communist type comments pop up. Everyone hates their ISP/cellular provider and mindlessly upvotes nonsense like this. There's zero truth to what you're saying!

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by topmonk on Saturday April 21, 2018 @02:21AM (#16890229)
I had a thought that the left tries to divvy up what value already exists, and the right tries to create an environment where new value can be created.

In order for the left to justify their agenda, they try to make it seem that it's pointless to try to create new value because of things like cartels, monopolies, etc. They then present the conclusion that the only way for a person to improve their financial position is to take from others.

Re:No “Material Difference Between 5G and LTE” by daveburstein on Sunday April 22, 2018 @03:10AM (#16895076)
Author here. There's no conspiracy, just an incredible amount of 5G hype. Note that the source of the comment is the CEO of the largest manufacturer, and I have similar from CTOs of Deutsche Telekom and Telefonica.