News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by danso on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @03:08PM (#16861330)
> Tesla charges $5,000 for Autopilot's lane-keeping and advanced cruise control features. On top of that, customers can pay $3,000 for what Tesla describes as "Full Self-Driving Capability."

Is $5,000 what owners of other cars pay for similar driver-assist features?

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by michaelt on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @05:19PM (#16862410)
In order to sincerely claim a car has the hardware needed to support a full self-driving capability the car would need several LIDARs, several good quality cameras, a high-precision GPS receiver, and a respectable Inertial Measurement Unit.

If you get all that hardware, $5,000 is a great price; back in 2005, any one of those components would have set you back that much.

Of course, if Tesla doesn't have that full complement of sensors - and from the price, they might not have all those sensors - the promised self-driving capabilities may never materialise.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @12:14AM (#16864557)
> In order to sincerely claim a car has the hardware needed to support a full self-driving capability the car would need several LIDARs, several good quality cameras, a high-precision GPS receiver, and a respectable Inertial Measurement Unit.

No, it needs decent cameras with coverage in all directions. That's all what a human needs so that's enough hardware.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by michaelt on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:27AM (#16865405)
Of the vehicles that completed the DARPA Grand Challenge and the DARPA Urban Challenge, how many do you think used LIDAR on their vehicles?

I'll tell you: 100%. Out of 11 teams finishing, every single one used LIDAR.

And I'll tell you why too: With LIDAR you need much simpler algorithms, and that directly translates into fewer bugs, meaning fewer instances of your vehicle crashing into stationary concrete barriers on clear days.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:10PM (#16873061)
It just means your AI is not intelligent enough. The hardware is sufficient, as proven by billions of humans.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by audionemesis on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:23PM (#16869135)
This is extremely disingenuous.

We have brains (at least, I like to think most of us do) which are capable of many, many times the amount of processing power which currently exists in AP2 and AP2.5 cars. Elon himself has mentioned this delta in processing power on at least one occasion, which is why AP2.5 is even a thing.

Simply stating that "humans use eyes to drive, so car can use cameras to drive!" is foolish.

(For those who don't know - AP2.5 is the current hardware suite on Tesla's which, among some other smaller upgrades, doubled the processing power of AP2 cars. AP2.5 has two NVIDIA PX2 units as opposed to AP2's one)

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:12PM (#16873068)
> We have brains (at least, I like to think most of us do) which are capable of many, many times the amount of processing power which currently exists in AP2 and AP2.5 cars.

I think it's just a matter of writing the correct software. Our brain seems really underpowered to me. And considering what even insects can do with highly limited brainpower, I think the hardware is good enough. All the gains need to come from software now.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by danso on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:48AM (#16865523)
Humans use more than eyesight to successfully drive.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by opless on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:06AM (#16867034)
I don't seem to have my LIDAR package installed.

Am I defective?

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:28AM (#16873332)
A well trained neural net doesn't need LIDAR!
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by audionemesis on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @03:55PM (#16861728)
"Is $5,000 what owners of other cars pay for similar driver-assist features?"

Although at its core, that's what Autopilot is (nothing more than Lane-Keep Assist and Adaptive Cruise-Control), to leave it at that is not giving it enough credit. Tesla's Autopilot is far beyond any other manufacturer's drive-assist features that I have personally driven (and I tested quite a few before purchasing my Model S).

In fact, a lot of people are saying that how well the assist features work is part of the reason why we saw the unfortunate fatality where the Model X ran right into a median. It is so good that people (wrongly) begin to place too much trust into it, and don't pay attention when they need to. When I first got my car (Feb 2017), it was shortly after the big MobileEye departure, and TeslaVision was still in its infancy. Never in a million years would I have taken my hands off the wheel or stopped paying attention when using this early version of TeslaVision AutoPilot. That thing tried to kill me more than once. The current version works very, very well and I'm totally happy with having paid and additional $5,000 for it.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by geoelectric on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @03:36PM (#16861577)
It's a little high, compared to the last couple of cars I purchased with those features. Want to say that $3k was more in line with what I paid for a full safety/tech package, and that included a speaker/nav bump, etc.

Keep in mind that most cars (including my two examples) only really have lane centering and adaptive cruise, though, as far as driver-assistance features go. Tesla's ability to change lanes and do basic highway nav is above and beyond the norm. I'd probably pay another $2k for that. Also, the way most of these packages work, you often can't get them a la carte--they're on top of another package, so the effective cost might actually be $5k depending on how that's structured.

Paying $3k for vapor that won't arrive before I sell the car/return the lease would piss me off, though.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by mst on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @05:08PM (#16862342)
Given Tesla's track record to date, it seems to me that not-yet-ready features should mostly be treated as a kickstarter.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by rimliu on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @06:11PM (#16862761)
I think the latest Honda Civic offers it for $1000 in US (gor the lower end trims that do not include it by default). There in Europe I think all trims have this (ACC, LKAS, CMBS).
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by mannykannot on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @07:09PM (#16863102)
Well, the point of the article is that the "full self-driving capability" is not actually available yet, and there is no firm delivery date (AFAIK, that's so for the whole industry, not just Tesla, but I think Tesla is the only manufacturer selling it.)
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by danso on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @07:44PM (#16863337)
Sure, but the suite of driver-assist features (e.g. lane assist) for $5,000 is available for Tesla and its competitors, though most reviews say that Tesla is currently leading the pack.