News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @12:14AM (#16864557)
> In order to sincerely claim a car has the hardware needed to support a full self-driving capability the car would need several LIDARs, several good quality cameras, a high-precision GPS receiver, and a respectable Inertial Measurement Unit.

No, it needs decent cameras with coverage in all directions. That's all what a human needs so that's enough hardware.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by michaelt on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:27AM (#16865405)
Of the vehicles that completed the DARPA Grand Challenge and the DARPA Urban Challenge, how many do you think used LIDAR on their vehicles?

I'll tell you: 100%. Out of 11 teams finishing, every single one used LIDAR.

And I'll tell you why too: With LIDAR you need much simpler algorithms, and that directly translates into fewer bugs, meaning fewer instances of your vehicle crashing into stationary concrete barriers on clear days.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:10PM (#16873061)
It just means your AI is not intelligent enough. The hardware is sufficient, as proven by billions of humans.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by audionemesis on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:23PM (#16869135)
This is extremely disingenuous.

We have brains (at least, I like to think most of us do) which are capable of many, many times the amount of processing power which currently exists in AP2 and AP2.5 cars. Elon himself has mentioned this delta in processing power on at least one occasion, which is why AP2.5 is even a thing.

Simply stating that "humans use eyes to drive, so car can use cameras to drive!" is foolish.

(For those who don't know - AP2.5 is the current hardware suite on Tesla's which, among some other smaller upgrades, doubled the processing power of AP2 cars. AP2.5 has two NVIDIA PX2 units as opposed to AP2's one)

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:12PM (#16873068)
> We have brains (at least, I like to think most of us do) which are capable of many, many times the amount of processing power which currently exists in AP2 and AP2.5 cars.

I think it's just a matter of writing the correct software. Our brain seems really underpowered to me. And considering what even insects can do with highly limited brainpower, I think the hardware is good enough. All the gains need to come from software now.

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by danso on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:48AM (#16865523)
Humans use more than eyesight to successfully drive.
Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by opless on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:06AM (#16867034)
I don't seem to have my LIDAR package installed.

Am I defective?

Re:Selling full autonomy before it's ready could backfire fo... by dingo_bat on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:28AM (#16873332)
A well trained neural net doesn't need LIDAR!