Re:I was Zuckerberg’s speechwriter
by specialist on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @02:17PM
(#16860900)
Emphatic agreement.
Governance is the final frontier. By that I mean "How are grievances adjudicated?"
Any one struggling with the "platforms as government" analogy might think of MMORPGs instead.
The final frontier is coercion... threat to life and liberty. Saying MMORPG is a government because the game controls the adjudication of your grievances is like saying Macy's is a government because Macy's Customer Service adjudicates your grievances. Except when it doesn't. Except when the FTC, or the FBI, or any other (real) government overrules them.
I know this is an old thread, but wanted to note that this is similar to saying that federal courts are not courts because they can be overruled by the supreme court. The existence of more powerful forms of government does not negate the existence of less powerful forms.
The point is less to be abstract or symbolic, and instead look at the concrete decisions they have to make. Corporations or general relationships do not have to consider these points to the same degree for survival.
In the past, governments would create policies, laws, and make decisions that would determine the well being of a citizen. Now, web platforms are more commonly making decisions of regulation, censorship, interoperability, which all fall in the realm of governments.
Companies or corporations in general may have a degree of these problems, but not in a way that their survival depends on.