Such schemes would likely come as "labels" that the district or individual sex workers buy into, provided that they comply with the regulations set up by the label. Some labels might gain a reputation for being stricter and cleaner then others, other might be cheaper and "good enough".
It's too hard to regulate individual prostitutes, but quite easy to regulate brothels under the banner of existing local planning authorities. There will still be individual prostitutes working outside the legal brothels, but you're ensured much more safety if you go to one of the legit places.
/not from personal experience
Btw. regarding your argument that brothels could be regulated under local planning authorities - I'm pretty sure that's exactly what the OP was talking about. We just got side-tracked by the minor point of who gets to do the H&S.
And they ARE regulated, the Health Ministry does checks, and issues a license. So a "john" that purchases sexual services over here has a reasonable assumption that the sexual worker doesn't have diseases (and they're mandated to use condoms anyways)
and just saying public health efforts were successful is not the same as proving that coercion improves health more than cooperation and at a reasonable cost
I can restrict everyone to their homes and stop all disease transmission. yeeaa, we found the correct approach. not
jk. You're right about labels or brands. It works for every other product.
Would you buy a electrical appliance that was not certified by Underwriter's Laboratories? Or buy a car that had no crash test rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety? Would you take the word of a car company that "oh, we don't need that stuff. we done tested it ourself."
It seems humans do know how to solve safety problems without coercion, at least when allowed to. There is no reason to believe prostitution is any different.
And yes its buyer beware. As it always is when you decide to have sex.
When things people want are illegal, they are LESS safe. There is no visibility, no legal liability, very little incentive to build and protect a brand name.
Alcohol was a lot less safe during prohibition. And the crime was very dangerous as well. Legalization is much safer and its rare that people die from the manufacturing and distribution of alcohol today.
should prostitution be regulated at all? I think that should be left at the local level. And I mean very local. It should be possibile for neighborhoods to ban it when most people don't want it and keep it legal where people are ok with it, right in the same city.
I believe many people try to control things like prostitution, drugs and gambling because they do not wish to be around it or have it devaluing their property, not because they wish to control what everyone else is doing. We need to find ways to let them do this and still preserve the freedom of others.