Re:Myths about prostitution
by rjurney on Sunday September 12, 2010 @04:22PM
(#1684458)
See: Public health. The federal government, and even 'world government' have been wildly successful in this area. As a result, the quality of human life has dramatically improved.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Myths about prostitution
by stretchwithme on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:50PM
(#1684633)
there are different ways of pursuing public health.
and just saying public health efforts were successful is not the same as proving that coercion improves health more than cooperation and at a reasonable cost
I can restrict everyone to their homes and stop all disease transmission. yeeaa, we found the correct approach. not
Requiring whores to register and be checked for STD's is not the moral equivalent of quarantining people in their homes. It's more similar to product safety regulations or building codes.
Re:Myths about prostitution
by stretchwithme on Sunday September 12, 2010 @07:56PM
(#1684913)
I didn't say they were equivalent. I am just saying that there are many considerations and the individual rights cannot be sacrificed just to achieve some health goal.
Individual rights aren't relevant. This is a public health issue that doesn't infringe on anyone's rights outside of some Libertarian wet dream. We license restaurants based on health inspections, does that infringe on your right to serve or eat filthy shit? I think not ;)
Re:Myths about prostitution
by stretchwithme on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:50AM
(#1689515)
then you won't mind if the government makes you get tested periodically. its for the safety of others, so your rights are irrelevant