News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Friday April 13, 2018 @11:57PM (#16835784)
Huh. I read on a tablet all of the time, I guess that makes me a prisoner of hype! Minority view, yes.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by TeMPOraL on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:09AM (#16835813)
Education is not about just reading, but regardless - you know what's better for reading than an iPad? A paper book. And if your concern is weight, you know what combines the best qualities of a paper book and a tablet? An e-book reader with e-Ink display.

(This is sad, really. As I understand, e-Ink tech is patented to death, so there's little progress there.)

Still, I'm not saying iPads are useless in general. The topic is relative merit of iPad vs. other possibilities, in education. My claims are as follows:

- iPad is a bad idea in education, partly because of the low capabilities of the device, and partly because not much apps that would would make full use of the capabilities of the device in order to encourage learning (this is kind of similar to "edutainment" or "educational games" for PC - utter crap that only fools parents)

- given that, iPad looses to plethora of other tools available for teachers, most of which are low-tech

- neither of the two points above will prevent iPad from succeeding on this market, as the hype is strong enough to overcome rational obstacles

--

Incidentally, I feel like back in 2015. I thought iPads already succeeded in getting sold to schools en masse, and it already turned out to be a colossal waste of money. I'm pretty sure we already had those discussions on HN.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by make3 on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:23AM (#16836028)
- e-ink has garbage level latency, which makes it useless for anything even slightly dynamic, including educational videos of course

- e-ink doesn't have color, color is helpful in educational material to make it friendly and accessible

- there are outlets everywhere, so unless you're going camping, the battery life is not that big of an advantage, more of a slight convenience thing

all of these points are why tablets aren't going anywhere

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by schtitt on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:22AM (#16836175)
The ReMarkable has, by some black magic, managed to reduce the latency by quite a lot compared to, say, a Kindle.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by ptman on Saturday April 14, 2018 @11:14AM (#16837643)
Because they update a small part of the screen, full page turns still take time
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by rhaps0dy on Saturday April 14, 2018 @04:59AM (#16836565)
Only for writing, not for getting to the next page.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by pjmlp on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:48AM (#16836094)
Tablets have strong light intensity that make them unsuitable for reading causing more eye strain than e-ink.

The first thing I did after trying to read on a tablet was to buy a Kindle.

Reading on a tablet, minutes, reading on a e-ink device, hours.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by Fnoord on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:25AM (#16837430)
Good points, but if children resort to Android devices I am not sure that makes me happy given they fall pray to advertising and profiling.

An e-reader has some disadvantages compared to a tablet. For example, it does not have a capacitive screen and does not have the ability to draw (low refresh rate) or use a stylus as input. It is a great tool for reading and it does that better than any other device (if you agree with its advantages over paper book which is weight vs amount of content) but not for say practice and exams.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:44AM (#16835916)
Wow. As a highly educated person, I had no idea I was choosing inferior tools! Thanks for letting me know.

I gave all my nieces and nephews tablets, and they all used them, I hope I didn’t destroy their lives.

Seriously, I have a hard time believing you can quote any evidence that a paper book is much better than a tablet for everyone. Which appears to be your assertion, although it’s hard to tell.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by TeMPOraL on Saturday April 14, 2018 @05:33AM (#16836634)
Wow, this subthread is getting out of hand...

My assertion is in context of education. If you're going to use a tablet as an electronic version of paper books, then paper books are better, because:

- they're much faster to skim through and search through

- print has better resolution than screen

- you can actually make notes on them - I mean free-form notes, made in an efficient way

- you can pull out multiple books and compare them

- they're much nicer on your eyes

Note again, I'm talking about education. That's different from recreational reading of fiction, and more akin to reading technical books - you need the ability to skim, skip, quickly move around and cross-reference stuff separated from each other by many pages.

Now tablets could be better if electronic textbooks actually exploited the medium they're using - the way Bret Victor has been talking about for ages now. See e.g. http://worrydream.com/KillMath/ or http://worrydream.com/ScientificCommunicationAsSequentialArt... (just got on HN frontpage, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16836530). However, I'm yet to see that happening in the wild.

Ultimately, my point isn't that tablets are bad. Hell, I'm happy user of such devices, and they definitely help me read on the go (they beat Kindle for technical books, due to color and better workflow with PDFs). My point is that tablets get dumped on schools and are used to view textbooks, which is something at which they're worse than regular textbooks. Both teachers and publishers have little clue on how to use these devices to their full potential, and there doesn't even seem to be a movement to help them get that clue.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by enitihas on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:56AM (#16836948)
How on earth are paper books faster to search through?
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by fsloth on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:47AM (#16837514)
Not OP but I can second this. When I have a really hard topic I need to understand that requires rapid context switching to check on details nothing beats a book. Highlighters and post it book marks make it much faster to browse through than PDF on my IPad.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by sincerely on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:10AM (#16836001)
books can last decades. an ipad absolutely won’t.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by schoen on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:55AM (#16836111)
I have a printed book that's the same age as the U.S. constitution (now 231 years) and another printed book that's a few decades older (293 years), both of which are still completely legible. "Decades" feels like a big understatement to me. :-)

We mostly think of paper as a poor archival medium because of a few decades, mainly at the end of the 19th century and the first half of the 20th century, when high-acid wood pulp paper was very widely used. (Newspapers are also sometimes printed on cheap acidic newsprint.) Acidic paper can become brittle within 20 years or so, or in any case much less than a century, although this also depends on many other factors. But both before and after this period, many books were printed on acid-free paper, and these are likely to survive for centuries, even with occasional use. The observations about paper's longevity in, for instance, Nicholson Baker's polemical Double Fold, tallies well with my experience as the son of a bookdealer. My father routinely sells books that are over a century old to people who fully expect to read them.

And I remember visiting an antiquarian book fair where a first folio Shakespeare was for sale for millions of dollars. It was still possible to turn the pages with no damage and all the printing was completely legible, even though the book was already 380 years old or so.

Books on low-acid paper are really a very durable technology when treated with respect.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eecc on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:02AM (#16836267)
Assuming the file format is documented, also bits remain completely legible throughout time. Perhaps we haven’t yet worked on a redundantly encoded, self documenting file format but eventually we will. At that point in time - assuming all relevant content won’t be copyrighted to death for 1000 years, that’s a big one - we will be able to simultaneously have unfettered access to any content
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eitland on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:59AM (#16836398)
Disks exist in two states:

- broken

- about to break

Even poor quality books are mostly readable after decades.

I don't know for certain a single example of any of my disks that have survived since 1990ies although I could hope.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eecc on Saturday April 14, 2018 @05:43AM (#16836646)
Also books exist in few states, of which only one is useful: well preserved, wet, burnt, torn apart. That’s how entropy works folks! One advantage of books is that the information density is lower so the loss of one specimen isn’t that significant, unless it’s unique
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eitland on Saturday April 14, 2018 @09:25AM (#16837238)
This isn't entirely correct.

A book can be usable even if it has a few loose pages. Also you can fix it.

Disks break more often and when they break you are lucky if you get anything out of them without paying (or being) a specialist.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eecc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:59AM (#16842641)
A disk will also survive some local data corruption or loss, even recover it and provide warnings sometimes. Catastrophic failure of a disk akin to total combustion of the book. Listen, can we stop this false analogy debate? It’s not advancing the discussion that much
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by eitland on Monday April 16, 2018 @02:56PM (#16851696)
I try once more:

I have a big shelf of books.

It includes my mothers chemistry book from before I was born as well as a few books bought second hand.

I have maybe one disk from the time I was a teenager.

Yes, fire will destroy a book (although parts will often be recoverable using low tech methods).

The same fire will certainly destroy disks and make them unrecoverable for everyone but recovery labs (if they are recoverable at all.)

Summary: books fail slower than disks. When they fail they often fail gracefully and you can still use them and even repair them using low tech tools.

Disks fail more often. In fact you rarely see working disks from last decade. They fail for a number of reasons and other times seemingly for no reasons at all. When they fail they might have tried to warn you but often they just fail with no warning and unless you work in IT you'll rarely see those warnings anyway. Also after they've actually failed you more likely than not need a recovery lab to get anything back.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by bwbw223 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @07:56PM (#16845732)
Although if you hit a book with a hammer, it’ll probably fare a bit better...
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by icc97 on Saturday April 14, 2018 @04:39AM (#16836509)
I bought Heisenberg's quantum theory paper back from a second hand shop. It's 90 years old and in amazing condition with just sun damage to the spine. The pages are sewn together.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:14AM (#16836159)
I've digitized a bunch of 16th century books so I (and everyone else, they're out of copyright) can read them on a tablet or whatever. Added a search function, too.

I am suggesting that claiming that one thing is best for everything and everyone is not true.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:59AM (#16836122)
Undergraduates mostly have textbooks which change every couple of years. Also, electronic books that don't have DRM don't die when the device does.

I was physics/math and was lucky that my textbooks didn't change that rapidly, but still, it's a bit odd to claim that paper is the obvious choice for everyone based on widely varying circumstances.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by coldtea on Saturday April 14, 2018 @04:11AM (#16836441)
ebooks can migrate from ipad to ipad (or any other system) without any damage to their contents.

books can't.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by goshx on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:15AM (#16837387)
And you can create backups of them

And you can search through the content

And you can carry thousands or millions of them in a single device

And you can add a new one to your collection without having to physically go anywhere to buy

And you can draw and make marks without damaging the content forever

And you can create bookmarks in multiple ebooks and have them all available at the same location, also with search functionallity

And the device you use to read can be lighter than an actual book, at least it will always have the same weight regardless of how many ebooks you carry

There is probably more.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by goshx on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:21PM (#16837989)
I’m really curiuous to know what is apparently wrong with my comment. Any downvoter care to comment?
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by hiq on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:29AM (#16836050)
As a starting point, can you quote any evidence that a tablet is better than a paper book? Both for reading and for more general educational activities?

I assume your family doesn't use their tablets with candycrush-like apps unlike some of my acquaintances. Which apps do they use to make it worth it?

I tend to assume that the burden of the proof of value is on the new tool, otherwise we just keep changing and nothing gets ever battle-tested. Paper, pen and other boring educational tools have drawbacks and benefits that are well-known; what about tablets?

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by coldtea on Saturday April 14, 2018 @04:10AM (#16836438)
>As a starting point, can you quote any evidence that a tablet is better than a paper book? Both for reading and for more general educational activities?

Have we regressed to the point where the simplest statement requires third party ("scientific" references)?

A table offers 100x the functionality of a paper book.

Even just in reading mode, it can carry 1000s of books in it, one can take notes, highlight, search them, remember its position on each, it has its own light (adjustable to match ambient levels or go beyond them), increase the font size (ever though about those with no perfect eyesight? Sucks to be them with paper books huh?), even spoken to the reader through TTS.

Not to mention that the price of ebooks is much cheaper than paper books to boot (and that one can even pirate the latter, if they are so inclined). Or that there are also 100,000s of FREE ebooks (classics, and such) but seldom (if ever, except for charity or so) free paper books.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by coldtea on Saturday April 14, 2018 @07:39AM (#16836913)
I meant, "a tablet". A table offers different kinds of functionality...
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by goshx on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:17AM (#16837392)
Still 100x the functionallity of a paperbook
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by hiq on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:39PM (#16838764)
Sorry I should have phrased it better than I have, I hope the following makes what I meant clearer.

I do agree with your statement that a tablet has more functionalities than any given book. Indeed, as you point out, a tablet can contain thousands of them.

What I tried and failed to express was that, in an educational setting, these functionalities are sometimes poorly used. This obviously depends on the teacher, if there is one.

It is not clear to me how teachers are supposed to use a tablet to enhance their classes, and in my (admittedly limited) experience, they are left to their own devices or with poor guidance to say the least. It could be that teachers more familiar with technology (beyond just using it) know what to do with it while teaching, but to which extent? I would have assumed that using tablets instead of books is at least as expensive; is this cost worth it in terms of gains?

In the Alan Kay interview which has already been linked in this thread[0]:

[quote]

I said, “If we’re gonna do a personal computer”—and that’s what I wanted PARC to do and that’s what we wound up doing [with the Alto]—”the children have to be completely full-fledged users of this thing.”

Think about what this means in the context of say, a Mac, an iPhone, an iPad. They aren’t full-fledged users. They’re just television watchers of different kinds.

[/quote]

That doesn't sound so promising in terms of education, unless I am missing something. From time to time, I see parents leaving their phone or tablet to their kid, who invariably plays some game like candy crush. How do you transform a device that was made for entertainment into an educational tool?

There have also been stories in the past about big tech leaders sending their children to "boring" schools without much in terms of technology, and mostly pen and paper, which suggests that better technology is not necessarily better for education.

Regarding the more limited scope of "just reading", I read a lot on my phone, but it is easier for me to get distracted since I can do so many things with a phone or a tablet. Granted it's the user's fault, but you don't need any self-discipline when using a simple book, which is at least one advantage.

[0]: https://www.fastcompany.com/40435064/what-alan-kay-thinks-ab...

Edit: I should have seen that TeMPOraL's comment already says it all: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16836634

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:41AM (#16836076)
I was expressing a personal anecdote, which I said (up one) that I knew was a minority opinion. I wasn't saying that I was expressing a universal truth. Sorry that I wasn't obvious.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by coldtea on Saturday April 14, 2018 @04:05AM (#16836423)
Considering hundreds of millions have bought an iPad, and sales are strong 8+ years on, it's not much of a minority view.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by ekianjo on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:17AM (#16835830)
there are better devices for reading. Objectively.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by jrs95 on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:45AM (#16836086)
You’re right. But it’s not about making textbooks digital. It’s about bringing more interactive software into the mix. IMO a combination of text, video, and interactive applications would be much more effective than just reading a book. And for what it’s worth, textbooks are rarely “read” anyways. Subsections of chapters are used and often not in order. And that’s mixed with a plethora of other content which is still largely being managed in a manual and ad-hoc manner. Clearly we can do better than this.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:45AM (#16835920)
And the source you are citing is... ?

And it would have to be a lot better to be the obvious choice for 100% of readers that some folks in this thread appear to think that it is.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by Fnoord on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:20AM (#16837408)
E-readers, for example. The battery lasts far and far longer, they're a lot cheaper (at least 50% of the price), and probably lighter. Source: my own experience with them two Kobo devices.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by axaxs on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:26AM (#16836044)
Are you a k12 student? If not, why are you replying at all? Anyone who asserts that iPads are a good choice for education are completely out of touch at best, or ignorant at worst. I'm sorry if this borders on a personal attack, but it feels like you're just looking for a reason to be offended.
Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by jrs95 on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:41AM (#16836075)
I had an iPad in high school and loved it, despite not having any apps for any of my school stuff. Just the browser and the form factor was enough to be a pretty good device. Note taking was the main thing I couldn’t do with it, and now it’s a great device for note taking. That is a big enough differentiator from Chromebooks to make it the best choice IMO.

But of course this is just based on my limited personal experience, I could be totally wrong.

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by greglindahl on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:43AM (#16836080)
I'm not offended, so if that's what you're reacting to, now you know. Instead, I was giving a personal anecdote in reaction to a statement which looked like an over-generalization.

My nieces and nephews were k12 when I gave them tablets.

Apparently I missed the news that tablets were terrible 100% of the time! Which appears to be what you're saying, but I can't really tell, what with all the names you called me. "Out of touch" or "ignorant", what a choice!

Re:What did Alan Kay and Steve Jobs talk about at the 2007 i... by axaxs on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:43AM (#16837494)
Perhaps we are looking at it from two different angles. It seems you may be looking at it from the 'educational to have one', while i'm looking at it from feasibility at an institutional level, which I thought OP was referring to. I know nothing about ipads, so I'm not questioning it as a device. What I'm questioning is why anyone thinks it is realistic for schools to spend the money on the, vs similar options at a fraction of the cost. Teachers in multiple states are walking out over pay, right now. Teachers in most states are underpaid. Most students are on free lunches. Where does the money come from to buy kids an ipad? Seems the state doesn't have it, nor the parents.