I think there will be a lot of "growing pains" as businesses adjust to "actual cost of an employee." Typically my friends back in Texas make fun of me for this after my move to SF, then turn around demanding the removal of illegal immigrants... despite the fact that every one of their favorite restaurants out in Houston exists because of their ability to underpay unreported workers. I see very little difference (costs go up because employees actually get healthcare now vs costs go up because historically underpaid employees have to be paid at least minimum wage because they're reported now).
This is misleading right-wing B.S. This only kicks in once you employ 20 or more people.[1] Anyone reading this on HN, if they eventually do employ 20 people, probably would want to offer them health insurance by that time.
[1] http://sfcityoption.org/hcso-compliance/employer-spending-re...
LOL. No. I campaigned for Barack Obama and met him in 2008. That's how 'right wing' I am.
> Anyone reading this on HN, if they eventually do employ 20 people, probably would want to offer them health insurance by that time.
That's a benevolent attitude, but practically, it will drive your business bankrupt if you are paying the CA-rate health care costs. That's the single biggest reason why even big corps like Wells Fargo, Charles Schwab and Bank of America are relocating many of their employees to Arizona and Colorado and elsewhere.
> CA-rate health care costs [are] the single biggest reason why even big corps like Wells Fargo, Charles Schwab and Bank of America are relocating
Source?
If you want to do business in California, you will be paying that tax whether you register in California or another state. Consequently, if you're in California there's no reason to consider exposing yourself to the jurisdiction of another state.
I really don't understand.
PS: It seems the original startup school video is gone. This version is linked by their page: https://www.startupschool.org/?course=1
If an LLC, say software services, incorporated in DE provides some consulting to a firm in California, that counts?
https://www.ftb.ca.gov/businesses/Structures/Limited-Liabili...
And btw that’s the rule in every state. They all want to tax whatever revenue is generated in that state (unless they don’t have a business tax at all, which is somewhat rare)
Given that you're taxed on profits (reductive, I know) isn't this literally impossible?
God forbid Californians value healthcare and that a city 45 minutes from the HQ of the richest company in the world, in the midst of a homelessness crisis, attempt to improve the lives of its at-risk citizens
http://sfist.com/2017/06/26/2017_san_francisco_homeless_cens...
That is not only condescending but also insulting to people who are working very hard to just survive.
I would respectfully request you to come down from your ivory tower of tech employment and notice the small people. My brother has an LLC and does landscaping. After paying all sort of bills and liabilities his company made $4K profits last year. $800 is pretty big amount compared to those profits. The profits might look negligible but he was able to employ 2-3 people on hourly wages, invest in buying a vehicle, equipment and so on.
When we talk about inequality we should realise that $800 flat tax hurts the poorest of poor lot more than people like you and me. This eventually adds up into making poor people even more miserable than rich people.
It could have been lot more sensible to say don't pay any taxes if you are making less than $20K profits. That would help poor people more.
I am not saying this about you but I come across so many people in tech industry who claim to have bleeding heart for poor and yet are totally ignorant of reality of poor people.
And by the way I’m not in agreement with most taxes; I am almost a Libertarian. I’m also not a Californian. I’m just saying, I think it’s not that big a deal in the grand scheme.
I'm using the language of statists because most people today are statists. It doesn't necessarily follow that I also personally agree with the idea, though I can see why you'd draw that conclusion.
It might be, but that's not what the tax is for. The $800 tax applied to LLPs, LLCs, and corporations isn't a tax on the privilege of operating a business in California: sole props and non-limited-liabilty partnerships can operate as businesses in California and don't pay the tax.
The privilege you pay for with the tax is that of offloading business failure risk onto the public while protecting your own personal assets with a publicly granted corporate liability shield.
No, it doesn't, you can do that as a sole prop or (non-LLP) partnership, and not pay the $800 tax applied to corporations, LLPs, and LLCs.
Asking the public at large to absorb for you (by granting you a personal liability shield) the risk that that the resources you give to the business plus those it is able to earn will not be able to meet the businesses liabilities is what you pay the $800 for. Which is why only the limited liability entities pay the tax.
They often convert to an LLC or corporation if they scale beyond a very small operation, because at any but the smallest scale $800/year is nothing (it's less than the wages—not total cost—of a full time minimum wage employee in the state for two weeks.) But, you only need to start that way when you have or are seeking early investors that are protecting substantial assets outside the business; lots of people starting a small business sink most of their personal assets into them initially anyway, so the corporate liability shield isn't protecting anything: if the business fails, they are personally wiped out with or without it, and their exposure is limited more by personal bankruptcy than anything else.
Doing business in California: both local and foreign LLCs doing business in CA pay it.
> Why is it almost 4 times more than Delaware?
Why shouldn't it be?
> WHY does it cost $800 just to exist?
You can do business as a sole proprietor or general (or limited, but not limited liability) partnership without the franchise fee. You are paying for the right to do business in CA with a liability shield. The potential value to you (and cost to the public) of such a shield, all other things being equal, is greater in a bigger market. California has more than 30 times the population and 40 times the GDP of Delaware.
But yeah, there’s really no valid reason other than the fact that California can get away with it.
It's simply a bad policy to start aspiring small businesses in debt. $800 isn't much to many of us on here but it is for a lot of people that want to be entrepreneurs in different fields from different backgrounds. Most businesses have other startup costs as well.
California already has the highest state income taxes. The privilege of doing business here is already accounted for. The franchise tax fee is just a bad policy and it's regressive.
And, so, they start businesses as sole proprietorships, or general or limited partnerships, and reorganize as LLCs or corporations once they've proven the idea. They are exposed to more (and the public exposed to less) risk of unmet business liability, but they can still run a business.
We always see entrpreneurs praised for taking risk, why are we hearing so much complaint that California charges for the privilege of offloading risk on to the public?
California has a pretty progressive income tax. It's the highest at the top income bracket (> $1 mil is taxed at around 13%), but it's significantly lower at the low end than many other states including Alabama, Arizona, Connecticut, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and DC.
I'd be willing to bet that if you adjusted the brackets for cost of living, CA is taxing the poor more than those other states are.
Why bet when you could actually look up the figures yourself? California has a very progressive income tax with more brackets (ten) than other states, starting at 1% for the lowest bracket. Meanwhile North Carolina charges a flat 5.75% and Wisconsin's lowest income tax bracket is 4%.
Or simply get an LLC from another state. Seems like there are states (Utah?) where there is no annual fee/tax.
I believe you only need a CA LLC if you hire employees in CA.
But no state allows you to register any entity for free. Lowest I’ve seen is South Dakota at $50 per year with no other tax on receipts.
Ask Detroit how that worked out for them.
If they are not useful unless they are at a certain amount, then what would that be and why aren't they at that level already? And wouldn't that just mean that anything below that level actually is useless if it doesn't meet the minimum needed to do anything?
What is reductive about wondering why a situation that you outlined exists for decades when there are specific extra taxes to help battle it?
[1] https://www.sidley.com/en/insights/newsupdates/2013/09/phase...
https://www.ftb.ca.gov/businesses/faq/712.shtml
>> Minimum tax is the amount you must pay the first quarter of each accounting period whether the corporation is active, operates at a loss or does not do business. The current minimum tax is $800.
If you're not making $800 then you don't have a business - you have a hobby.
Either way, yes it's just a cost of doing business in California, and so profits need to be greater than the cost for the business to be sustainable. Perhaps it's not a great description to say "taxed into bankruptcy" but it's no different than "did not meet costs and ended in bankruptcy", with the costs specifically being taxes.
More likely the hourly equivalent will be a lot higher. A dog walker would make that in 4 days at worst. A week or two if they are casual ones.
So to not make that it’s not the taxes that are killing your business.
The only time you can dispute this is when the tax is directly on an activity that requires two participants. Who pays sales tax, the buyer or the seller?
CA has 1 of the highest business taxes. LLCs have to pay the State $800 every year, even if your business is losing money or has no revenue and even if you are a single-member LLC, in which case IRS regards it as a pass-through entity.
On top of that, if you form your business in San Francisco, you are mandatory charged a 4% "Healthy San Francisco" city tax that is supposed to helps pay for employee's healthcare.
> 2008 Health Care Security Ordinance, which provides health care to San Francisco residents without insurance (the Healthy San Francisco program) and requires businesses to help fund health care for their employees in San Francisco.
Source: https://www.tripsavvy.com/restaurants-healthy-san-francisco-...
Restaurants were busted running a scam where they passed on this tax to the customer and pocketed the $$ themselves, but that's a whole different story (see Source link above).